I dunno. I've seen his admin notes. They almost rivaled mine in length (probably longer by now :P). And he definitely had more reprimands. If anything could be said in his defense, it's that there WERE so many notes saying, "IF HE DOES THIS ONE MORE TIME..." and then he did, and there wasn't any follow-through beyond another short mute. I remember in IRC there was a lot of "GOD I WISH HE'D STOP. I'M GONNA MUTE HIM FOREVER THE NEXT TIME HE DOES THAT!" He really is good at getting under people's skin.
Yeah, other people get away with being jack asses and no one says or does anything. That's the user base's fault just as much as it is the admins' uneven enforcement of the rules. I know when I was an admin, I hated moderating the forums. I got so sick and tired of reading report tickets about "HE CALLED ME A DUMB FACE" and "WAH WAH I'M GONNA GO HOME AND CRY MYSELF TO SLEEP" I'd want to find the person responsible for that and make them stop too. It's easier than trying to explain to a bunch of whiny cry babies to get a thicker skin.
I forgot my point, maybe there wasn't one.