Really the end result would be that anyone without scholar would quickly be rated down enough to have all their posts start unrated, and for everyone else would depend on how often you posted. If you posted davejohnsan style (ie 1 post per year), then you'd be sitting comfortably at guru, but if you post more than once or twice a month, you'd be rated down over 9000 times per post, resulting in a very quick subscholar status.