Hatoa wrote:
In my server (chromaggus), stranglekelp sells for an average of 1g50s per stack and it does not require skill 200. Just saying. =)
In terms of time spent, how long does it take you to gather a stack of stranglekelp? Mining certainly makes more gold for two reasons: more professions need ore/bars than those that need herbs, and each node yields more mats, making gathering ore a bit easier. The drawback to mining is that it's harder to level, since there are many herbs that will help you level herbalism, but ore is restricted to only a few types, and there are largish gaps when it becomes tough.
If you are going to go with gathering skills, supplement your income by fishing. Making money through fishing is covered quite thoroughly in the FAQ.