RCP has Michigan as O+4, 538 has it as O+5.6, both weighed down slightly by the tie poll which was likely an outlier when compared to everyone else's numbers.
MI and Pennsylvania have gone Democrat every cycle since 1988 (Bush vs Mondale). Somehow they get lumped into "battleground states" and the GOP makes some half-assed play for them each cycle (McCain did the same in '08) and the media runs stories about how Michigan or Pennsylvania looks close but, in reality, by the time they flip you've almost certainly flipped enough other states to win.
As for the NYT, I'm guessing they just have some polling threshold like +10 or more to move it from "Leans" to "Likely". They only have three levels of ratings on that map, Leans, Likely or Battleground. MI isn't a battleground but it's not as "sure" a lock as New York, IL or California.
____________________________
Belkira wrote:
Wow. Regular ol' Joph fan club in here.