Jophiel wrote:
gbaji wrote:
There are a relatively small number of people who are on the extremes of this. Some argue that a fetus isn't a person at all and has no rights at all until the day it is born. Others argue that it is a full person with full rights from the moment of conception (ok, it's not a fetus at that point yet, but whatever). The overwhelming majority of people (as well as the Supreme Court) believe said rights scale into effect during gestation.
Joe Biden wrote:
Because it's as close to a consensus that can exist in a society as heterogeneous as ours. What does it say? It says in the first three months that decision should be left to the woman. And the second three months, where Roe v. Wade says, well then the state, the government has a role, along with the women's health, they have a right to have some impact on that. And the third three months they say the weight of the government's input is on the fetus being carried.
And so that's sort of reflected as close as anybody is ever going to get in this heterogeneous, this multicultural society of religious people as to some sort of, not consensus, but as close it gets.
Ironically, you ******* about Biden's answer at the time.
I ******* about it because he uses that as a justification for the Roe v. Wade decision. I know that this might be too nuanced for most people, but I don't actually disagree at all with the broad standards for abortion set in that court decision. What I disagree with is that the court is the correct method for creating those standards in the first place.
As I have stated for years on this forum, the methods you use do matter. There is a huge difference between all 50 states adopting similar abortion laws because they choose to on their own, and having a court rule from on high that every state must pass laws which comply with the courts view on the issue,
even if the resulting laws are exactly the same. How you accomplish something is as important as what you accomplish.
Or, to put this back in a recent perspective: The end does not justify the means.
Edited, Nov 19th 2010 3:14pm by gbaji