RedPhoenixxx wrote:
gbaji wrote:
One of the concerns that the Israelis have is that the Palestinians (specifically Muslim Palestinians) have become so anti-Semite that if they allow their population to grow too much they fear that their country will become a muslim country with Judaism eliminated entirely.
This has
nothing to do with anti-semitism, and everything to do with democracy. If the right of return was granted, Palestinian Muslims would vastly outnumber Jewish Israeli. In a democracy, it seems kinda normal that the majority of the population would not want to live under a state-religion which wasn't theirs. It's not anti-semite, it's the same reason as to why you don't want the US to become a Muslim country, or why I wouldn't want the UK to become a Sikh state.
Yes. And the fear (as I clearly stated in the sentence you quoted) is that if the Muslim Palestinians gain a majority, they'll use that majority to change the democracy of Israel into one more like those in the surrounding Muslim states, with Muslim religious leaders having great influence over the government. Once that happens, the democracy will be gone and Judaism will at best be a second class religion, and most likely will be outlawed. The Jews will leave, and they'll have lost their country.
Can we agree that the two groups cannot share a country? It doesn't work for either. But of the two, Palestinian Muslims are vastly better off in a Jewish controlled Israel than Jews would be in a Muslim controlled Israel (or whatever they'd presumably change the name to once they had control).
Quote:
Second, everyone knows the refugees can't come back. It's stupidly obvious. What they will/might do is allow a few of them to come back, as a symbolic gesture. But even the Palestinians know damn well that the vast majority of the refugees won't come back. What the hell would they come back to anyway? It's not like their 60 year old house is still standing empty in a field somewhere...
Part of the demands connected to the "right of return" would require returning the property and providing for those who returned. It's quite obvious that the plan here is to flood Israel with refugees which they'll have to pay to support and shift the population sufficiently so that Islam can gain dominance as the majority religion. There is no other reason to be so adamant about specific conditions for a right of return. It's not about just being able to move back, it's specifically about crushing the Israeli economy and control of their own country in the process.
That's why it'll never happen. The Palestinians put absolutely unreasonable requirements on it.
Quote:
This is also the reason why Israel hasn't annexed the West bank and Gaza and made them officially part of Israel. If they did, demography would mean that pretty soon the majority of the population in this new "Greater Israel" would be Palestinian Muslims. Since it's a democracy, this would mean the end of Israel as a Jewish state. The only alternative would be to have an apartheid state, where Muslim Palestinians don't have the right to vote. But while this is palatable to some in Israel (Lieberman and the ultra-orthodox), it thankfully isn't to most of the population.
Which is why there is no other choice but to give Palestine its independence. There is simply no other alternative. And the more you wait, the more blood is shed, the more anger grows, and the harder it gets. And yet, there is no alternative... And everyone in Israel and in Palestine, knows that.
Amazingly, you and I are in agreement. Here's the thing though. Israel has on at least 3 separate occasions offered exactly that. They've offered every single thing that the Palestinians wanted *except* the right of return. They've offered to give all the land taken back. They've offered to pull their own settlers out. They've offered to help fund for any costs involved. They have done everything they possibly could to help the Palestinians gain that "dream" of a state of their own. And they have been rejected.
There's a point at which one must acknowledge that a significant cause of the conflict is the fact that there are powerful factions within the Palestinian movement who don't want the conflict to end. They want their people to be stuck in this eternal refugee condition. They like it because it gives them power and influence which they might not keep if a stable state were created. If you want to find why this situation hasn't been resolved peacefully, look to the Palestinian leaders. They are the ones who find some excuse to back out of any agreement that comes along, no matter how much it meets everything they claim that they really want.