Quote:
Made a mistake in my numbers above. Assume the company has 490 employees, taxes are cut to the company by 500k/year, allowing for 10 more employees to be hired at 50k/year, with taxes per employee going up by 1k/year. Not only does the math add up, it's more sensible to expect a ~2% increase in employment in the short term rather than a 25% increase...
Not to mention that by reducing wages by 1k via taxable income, limits their free economic capital by significantly more than 2% thus stagnating a consumer centric economy.
(It limits free capital by >2% because you have to discount the cost of living, as well as current tax amounts.) I'll be generous and say basic cost of living plus taxes/fees etc. are 40k/yr leaving them with 10k in unallocated capital. After a 1k reduction, they are left with 9k, or a 10% reduction in money to be invested or funneled through the economy in some way. Which inevitably hurts small businesses most especially those in the consumer goods and services sector.
In addition, if the CO. were to receive a 500k bounty, they would likely split up the areas of expenditure, put a little into dividends, give the CEO a ~50k bonus for procuring these additional funds, and maybe hire 2-3 more people if it looked like they would be useful long-term. In any event, short term capital gains are unlikely to result in more jobs, unless they really should already be hiring and expanding their company based on economic indicators. A well run company should be adding jobs based on need for production, as those jobs should provide a net greater output than input, not because they have cash burning a hole in their pocket.
Trickle down is a significantly worse approach, especially in this case because you don't get anywhere near the full dollar or >$1/$1 output that you get from cycling it through, since you need to have those funds flow through so many middlemen brokers.
It can be useful in cases where the net return for it is higher than demand side capital flow, but that is very unlikely to be the case in this situation.