catwho wrote:
See, sane Dems and Republicans CAN see eye to eye on some issues.
Legalize marijuana and tax the sh*t out of it. Legalize crack and tax the sh*t out of it. Bam, prison overcrowding solved and healthcare paid for.
If people are allowed to give themselves cancer with tobacco, then everyone else should be allowed to get a little high once in a while.
Lol. yeah if it were that easy.
If marijuana becomes legal, on what grounds do you justify taxing it anymore than say, herbal tea?
If it is legalized on the basis of it's health benefits, you'll be hard pressed to tax it at all.
While I have no issues legalizing the smoking of a naturally occurring substance (pot), I don't know if I feel the same way about cocaine, especially crack cocaine. You can't make your own booze because it's dangerous to have stills in your house or garage and moonshine can be deadly if not properly distilled. Crack cocaine is made in a similar process but add in pressurized ammonia. Cocaine does not provide any recognized health benefits.
So, ok, Cocaine is made and sold by licensed companies to insure it's good clean stuff and made safely. Now we 'tax the sh*t' out of it. Again, how do you justify taxing the sh*t out of it. If it's legal it's just another product - you could probably justify taxing it at the same level as booze or cigs.
Keep in mind now you've put a product on the market with an extremely regressive tax on it. Not only will it require lots of legislation and oversite, but it will probably not be affordable by the people that are hooked on it. So the trade remains underground.
Mostly, I'm not for legalizing cocaine because not only is it dangerous to make, but also to use. If it was deemed just another drug to be put into pill form and doled out to the public through prescriptions...well so be it. But to legalize it simply to ease the stress on law enforcement is not enough of a reason, imo. Also, Pulp Fiction has scarred me for life.
The word on the street is that legalizing pot will not create a huge tax stream, and what it does bring in will be spent up regulating the stuff.
Edited, Mar 22nd 2010 10:05pm by Elinda