Actually, that WOULD be a fun exercise to undertake!
First off, a list of who is who so we're comparing apples to apples.
This list, although it was designed to compare the diversity levels of the cabinets, gives a clear contrasts to who is in what position.
My prediction? Parity. You don't get nominated to cabinet positions without some base qualifications. In order to get accepted into the federal internship program, the minimum degree required is a master's degree. My husband was accepted to that program (the Presidential Fellows) but no position in education was immediately available, so he got a job as a professor locally instead. He still wants to go to Washington to work on education policy in the US eventually.
1. NATIONAL SECURITY ADVISER
Bush (1): Condoleezza Rice. I always said she was Bush's best pick. She has a PhD in Political science, and speaks fluent Russian.
Bush (2):
Stephen Hadley. It can be assumed he has a law degree, since he was a partner in a law firm, but the specifics on his degree are not on his wiki page.
Obama:
Marine General James L. Jones. BS in Foreign services. His military career is to long to list here. Obama went for military experience over education in this instance.
Bush wins on the education front, Obama wins on the experience front. A tie.
2. WHITE HOUSE COUNSEL
Everyone here
needs to have a law degree. So this one is a little bit unnecessary.
Bush: Alberto Gonzales, (JD from Harvard), Harriet Miers (JD from Southern Methodist Uni) and Fred Fielding (JD from University of VA.)
Obama: Greg Craig (JD from Yale.)
A tie.
3. SECERTARY OF STATE
Bush (1): Colin Powell - MBA from George Washington University. Long history of decorated military service. Experience over education here.
Bush (2): Condi Rice. PhD in PoliSci.
Obama: Hillary Clinton - JD from Yale.
A tie.
4. DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY
Bush: Paul O'Neill (MA in Public Administration), John Snow (PhD in Economics) and Henry Paulson (MBA from Harvard.)
Obama: Tim Geithner (MA in International Economics from John Hopkins.)
A tie.
5. DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE
Bush(1): Donald Rumsfeld (BA from Princeton, some law school but no degree)
Bush(2)Robert Gates (PhD in Soviet History.)
Obama: Kept Robert Gates.
Unscorable since Obama kept the Bush appointee.
6. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE/ATTORNEY GENERAL
Everyone in this position MUST have a law degree.
Bush(1): John Ashcroft (JD from University of Chicago)
Bush(2): Michael Mukasey (LLM - similar to but not the same as JD - from Yale)
Bush(3):Alberto Gonzales
Obama: Eric Holder (JD from Columbia Law)
A tie.
7. DEPARTMENT OF INTERIOR
Bush: Gale Norton (JD from University of Denver)
Obama: Ken Salazar (JD from University of Michigan.)
Still lawyers, but both of these are from more modest state universities rather than Ivy Leagues. A tie.
8. DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE
Bush: Ann Veneman (JD from University of California, Hastings)
Obama: Thomas J. Vilsack (JD from Albany Law School)
Again, still lawyers, but from more modest schools. A tie.
9. DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE
Bush: Donald Evans (MBA from UT, Austin), Carlos Gutierrez (BA from Monterrey Tech in Mexico.)
Obama: Gary Locke (LLD from Boston University.)
Obama has the more educated cabinet member, but Locke was his third pick after Judd Gregg (JD from Boston University) and Bill Richardson (MBA). However, based on their degrees, Obama wins this round.
10. DEPARTMENT OF LABOR
Bush: Elaine Chao (MBA from Harvard)
Obama: Hilda Solis (MA in Public Administration.)
A tie.
11. DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES
Bush(1): Tommy G. Thompson (JD from University of Wisconsin)
Bush(2): Mike Leavitt (BA in Economics). He wins Bush's 'worst pick' for essentially ignoring the growing health industry crisis.
Obama: Kathleen Sebelius (Master of Public Administration from University of Kansas)
Averages out to a tie.
12. DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT
Bush(1): Melquiades Rafael Martinez (JD from Florida State),
Bush(2): Alphonso Jackson (JD from Washington State)
Bush(3): Steven Preston (MBA, University of Chicago)
Obama: Shaun Donovan (Double MAs: Master of Public Administration and Master of Architecture.)
Although Bush had two lawyers in this position, Obama picked someone with two
very salient degrees to this particular post. Giving this one to Obama.
13. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
Bush(1): Norman Mineta (MBA, University of California.) Notably, he was Bush's only Democrat cabinet member.
Bush(2): Mary Peters (BA from the *snerk University of Phoenix. Probably not the online version, but you want to talk about a tainted reputation . . .)
Obama: Ray LaHood (BS in Sociology and Education.)
Obama's worst pick. No relevant education or experience here. (Also a Republican. I think this was a secret jab at making bipartisanship look really bad.) I've got my bets on his being the first to be replaced, especially after the recent Toyota debacle (which he exacerbated with some very stupid comments.)
Bush wins.
14. DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY
Bush: Former Michigan Sen. Spencer Abraham (JD from Harvard)
Obama: Steven Chu (PhD in Physics from the University of California.) Also won the Nobel Prize in physics in 1997.
Bush picked a politician, Obama picked a scientist. Obama wins this one, and also gets his 'best pick' with this one.
15. DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION
Bush(1): Rod Paige (PhD in Physical Education)
Bush(2): Margaret Spellings (BA in Political Science)
Obama: Arne Duncan (BA in Sociology)
Bush wins this one, although barely, as he lost his PhD person who resigned because he disagreed with Bush's policies.
16. DEPARTMENT OF VETERAN AFFAIRS
Bush(1): Anthony Principi (JD Seton Hall)
Bush(2): Jim Nicholson (JD from University of Denver)
Bush(3): James Peake (M.D. Cornell, 42 year army career)
Obama: Eric Shinseki (MA in English Lit - but also a retired 4-star general)
A tie for this. Both Obama and Bush picked military veterans, which is more important than specific education for this post.
17. DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY
Bush(1): Tom Ridge (JD **********
Bush(2): Michael Chertoff (JD Harvard)
Obama: Napolitano (JD University of VA)
Tie.
18. CHAIR OF THE COUNCIL OF ECONOMIC ADVISERS
Bush(1): Glenn Hubbard (PhD in Economics)
Bush(2): Harvey Rosen (PhD in Economics)
Bush(3): Ben Bernanke (PhD in Economics)
Obama: Christina Romer (PhD in Economics)
Both Bernanke and Romer have their PhDs from MIT.
Tie.
19. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
Bush: Former New Jersey Gov. Christine Todd Whitman (BA in Government)
Bush: Michael Leavitt (BA)
Bush: Stephen Johnson (MS in Pathology)
Obama: Lisa Jackson (MS in Chemical Engineering)
Obama wins, as Jackson is the only one with a relevant degree to the position.
I'm going to stop here, because it is as I predicted - more or less parity between the two. The biggest distinction is that an awful lot of Bush's picks were also personal friends (Rice being a distinctive exception), rather than being people well-known for their own merits.
Edited, Feb 9th 2010 4:03pm by catwho