Smasharoo wrote:
How many of them have had police show up? Guessing, I'd think a few. How many of them have been handcuffed and taken to jail.
None.
You're missing a key element though: How many of them berated the cop who came to verify that the home was not being burglarized by calling them racists, making remarks about their mothers, and then continued to do so after being warned that they were being disruptive and might be arrested if they continue?
We can dance around the questions about motives for everyone else involved in this, but it's abundantly clear that Professor Gates acted like a complete idiot here. We can speculate about racial motivations on the part of the police officers, the caller, and the woman who brought the situation to the attention of the caller, but we can absolutely say the Professor Gates acted in a racist manner. He assumed that because he was black, and the officer was white, that this meant that the officer must be racist. He made a judgment based solely on the color of the skin of those involved. That's racism.
I also love how as more facts come out about this, the goalposts keep getting moved by those who seem unusually insistent to defend Professor Gates on this. First, it's a group of white police officers who arrested him for being black. Oopps! Well, only one was white, another hispanic, and another black, but the white guy was still racist. Ok. Well... He may not have been, and maybe we got it wrong about why and when he was arrested, but clearly the caller was racist when she chose to report two black men breaking into the home. Oppsie! She didn't know their skin color either. Hmmm... Well... Maybe we can guess that the older women who told the caller about it did so because she knew they were black! Um... Yeah!
Do you guys really have to stretch this far to continue to twist this story around so that it is the white guys fault? At what point will you realize your own bias here? President Obama said one thing that was true. This is a "teachable moment". What we should be learning is that black people can be racist too, and that it's just as wrong to assume that the white person interacting with you is doing so because of your own skin color as it is for any other example of white racism out there.
It does not matter how often you think white people are racist towards black people, or even how often it actually happens. None of that excuses this behavior on the part of both Professor Gates, and President Obama, and neither does it do so for posters on this forum. In
this particular case the officer did nothing wrong. The caller did nothing wrong. The person who reacted in a racist manner was Professor Gates, and everyone who assumed he must have been the victim here. You all did that because he was black and for no other reason. Each situation should be judged on it's own merits. Making assumptions about the events which occurred based on the skin colors of those involved makes *you* a racist.
A whole lot of people really ought to be ashamed of themselves in this case...
Edited, Jul 27th 2009 8:14pm by gbaji