Forum Settings
       
Reply To Thread

Health Tax - a proposalFollow

#27 Jan 29 2009 at 11:38 PM Rating: Good
***
2,086 posts
Aripyanfar wrote:
Other people are utterly shocked and bewildered that such ideas could be even suggested. WTF is wrong with food and snacks and the drinks that they drink all day every day? Why do you want me to suddenly pay twice as much for my food and my kid's food? How shocking cruel and insensitive and classist that is. Most people couldn't afford it. What the hell is wrong with you that you are asking for a ban on advertising snacks and food that is aimed at kids during children's TV programmes? What else is the point? You can't put companies out of business, that isn't fair. You think my kids are going to eat a salad sandwich and an apple for lunch with a bottle of water? Oh ha ha. Think again. I'd like to watch you try.


Its a little different in the UK with mass advertising campaigns fromm people like Jamie Oliver (Nobby will no doubt hate him) and other chefs all advertising organic food and accessible healthy food options.
We are now being told about our eating choices and claiming not to know about risks to your health from your diet is simply a poor excuse in the United Kingdom.

Aripyanfar wrote:
I'm not saying that adult individuals don't have a responsibility to hunt down their own and their kid's problems, and do something about them on an individual and community basis. They have a responsibility to make themselves aware of problematic issues so that they can vote in governments that make the right policies. I'm just saying it's not quite so simple as "They did it all to themselves."


Actually, in many cases it is. Anyone who took up smoking in the UK in the last 20 years has done it to themselves. With "Smoking kills" clearly written on the side of packets and advertising banned since forever and anti smoking campaigns in place on TV, in doctors surgeries and in schools that is definitely the case that taking up smoking is ignoring all advice and being irresponsible. The same is now occuring for food abuse and exercise with campaigns reaching a crescendo of publicity resulting in government action.

Aripyanfar wrote:
Would you find it interesting that my private health insurance will pay $100 a year for a pair of sports shoes, and will subsidise certain gym or yoga type classes?


Not surprised at all.
#28 Jan 29 2009 at 11:44 PM Rating: Good
Avatar
*****
13,240 posts
Quote:

And I may be a sceptic but I am loathe to beleive that the taxes generated by cigarettes will pay for all the future treatments required.


Don't forget to add in social security funds that dead people can't collect.
____________________________
Just as Planned.
#29 Jan 30 2009 at 12:33 AM Rating: Decent
The Great BrownDuck wrote:
My original point still stands here. Suffer the American health care system for one year and you'll never complain again. Honestly, I think you're taking for granted how good you have it over there.


Suffer Alberta naked for a year and you'll never complain about the cold again.

Or anything else, actually.

Suffer the food in the Congo and you'll never complain about bad food ever again.

And it's fairly likely you'll never complain about anything else, either.

Edited, Jan 30th 2009 3:33am by Kavekk
#30 Jan 30 2009 at 2:25 AM Rating: Excellent
GwynapNud the Eccentric wrote:
No one forces someone to smoke, drink, eat to excess or make poor lifestyle choices. As it is entirely personal, it is entirely reasonable that you personally assume the costs of your actions and are taxed for it.


I don't think it's that simple.

Smoking: Lots of people take up smoking when they're young. Especially in this country. The parents smoke, so the kid, at 12-13, starts smoking. He smokes 20-a-day for 10 years, and it's bloody hard to stop after that. He might develop lung cancer, or throat cancer, at 35. Who knows? Should we blame the kid because his parents set a bad example?

Eating: In the UK, eating healthily is expensive. At least in London. Organic food is super expensive, free range chicken is expensive, cooking from scratch with fresh ingredients is expensive. Not only that, but it's not really in teh national culture to do it. I don't want to generalise too much, but the cheapest food in the UK is processed, disgusting ready meals, junk food, or fast food. If you're very poor, and plenty of people are, you can't really afford anything else. If you're a kid, and that's what your parents feed you, you are conditioned to eat badly. Of course, you can break the habit and start eating healthily, but it's not the most common course of action. Same with exercise. There are virtually no sports field left in this country. No basketball courts on street corners, no green area where you can play footy, unless you joina Gym with an expensive membership, it's not taht easy to do sports. I play football every week, and our pitches are under the motorway in Latimer Road. And we pay for that.

Drinking: Same. Lots of people start drinking very young because their parents don't gie a ****. And the UK is very much a drink-orientated culture. Everyone does it, a lot.

So no, I don't agree it's down to personal choice. It might be this way if at 18 you suddenly got a new body and mind, but you don't Many of the "lifestyle choices" are not choices at all, they are the continuation of conditioning from when you were a kid. And then there is all the genetic stuff.

I agree some of the money being spent by the NHS is not always spent wisely. But that's part of the game. If I devide to not have kids, should I stop paying taxes for other parent's kids education? If I'm against the war in Iraq, can I not pay the taxes that go to fund it? I don't think the UK should renew it's Trident ******** can I not pay taxes on those? Etc, etc...

Quote:
The population was not this unhealthy and this diseased at any time in its history


Hmm, what? Did I read this correctly? Cos I would say the population has not been this healthy at any other time in History. Life expectancy has never been higher. People have never been given better health care. Think to pretty much any period in History before ours, and it was amazingly unhealthy. The Victorian and kids working in factories or begging in the sewer-filled streets? The people working in mines? The plagues in the Middle-Ages? The starvation pretty much through out history? I really can't think of a single time in History where people were healthier. They might not have the same ailments as we have today but they had others and these were much worse.
____________________________
My politics blog and stuff - Refractory
#31 Jan 30 2009 at 2:26 AM Rating: Excellent
Ministry of Silly Cnuts
*****
19,524 posts
Ahh dear Gwyn is speaking out of her pretty little botty again.

1. Any idea how much revenue is generated by the taxation on tobacco and alcohol products? It's lots! To be precise; lots and lots and lots

2. You clearly have no clue about medeconomics.

Guess who costs more out of these 2 people:

Person A: The Chain Smoker, boozaholic that will die at 60-65 years of age needing probably a few months of acute care and medication before popping their clogs

Person B: The person who remains active and lives to be 95, consuming care and medication costs for 10-15 years at the end of their life in care homes, nursing homes and hospitals.

Very old people are incredibly expensive to keep alive.

I'm not advocating unhealthy lifestyles, just shooting down your outstandingly ill-informed premise. Your lifestyle has a major impact on your health, but little impact on how much healthcare expenditure you consume in a universal public funded service like ours. If anything, the smokers and boozers and lard-***** will die young and save the inordinate costs of maintaining them in their dotage, as well as having filled the coffers with baccy & beer taxes.

Hugs
____________________________
"I started out with nothin' and I still got most of it left" - Seasick Steve
#32 Jan 30 2009 at 2:49 AM Rating: Excellent
Nobby, I think we're being a bit harsh on Gwyn, so maybe we should say something nice to her...

DON'T WORRY GUYS, I'VE GOT THIS ONE!!

Gwyn, are you over 21?
____________________________
My politics blog and stuff - Refractory
#33 Jan 30 2009 at 2:50 AM Rating: Excellent
Ministry of Silly Cnuts
*****
19,524 posts
RedPhoenixxx wrote:
Gwyn, are you over 21?
I think bringing her dress-size into the argument is very impolite.
____________________________
"I started out with nothin' and I still got most of it left" - Seasick Steve
#34 Jan 30 2009 at 2:53 AM Rating: Good
RedPhoenixxx wrote:
Nobby, I think we're being a bit harsh on Gwyn, so maybe we should say something nice to her...

DON'T WORRY GUYS, I'VE GOT THIS ONE!!

Gwyn, are you over 21?


Planning to go to America, Red? I'm afraid I can't let you do that.

/closepodbaydoors
#35 Jan 30 2009 at 2:56 AM Rating: Good
*****
15,512 posts
Kavekk wrote:
RedPhoenixxx wrote:
Nobby, I think we're being a bit harsh on Gwyn, so maybe we should say something nice to her...

DON'T WORRY GUYS, I'VE GOT THIS ONE!!

Gwyn, are you over 21?


Planning to go to America, Red? I'm afraid I can't let you do that.

/closepodbaydoors
You're right, the UK is an American colony.
#36 Jan 30 2009 at 3:01 AM Rating: Excellent
sweetumssama wrote:
You're right, the UK is an American colony.


That's very true, but with a bit of luck and a sharper economic downturn, it might one day become an European colony.
____________________________
My politics blog and stuff - Refractory
#37 Jan 30 2009 at 3:05 AM Rating: Decent
RedPhoenixxx wrote:
sweetumssama wrote:
You're right, the UK is an American colony.


That's very true, but with a bit of luck and a sharper economic downturn, it might one day become an European colony.


More of a member state than a colony in that case.

I think the recent revelation that we're the hardest hit country by the recession and the fall of the pound against the euro is working strongly in that direction.
#38 Jan 30 2009 at 3:17 AM Rating: Good
Kavekk wrote:
More of a member state than a colony in that case.


Man, can't I just belittle my country of adoption in peace??

Quote:
I think the recent revelation that we're the hardest hit country by the recession and the fall of the pound against the euro is working strongly in that direction.


Me too, but strong is the Euro-sceptic force in this country, and Conservative the next government will be.
____________________________
My politics blog and stuff - Refractory
#39 Jan 30 2009 at 3:25 AM Rating: Good
Ministry of Silly Cnuts
*****
19,524 posts
Kavekk wrote:

I think the recent revelation that we're the hardest hit country by the recession and the fall of the pound against the euro is working strongly in that direction.
Naah. Oirland is taking a much harder hit than UK of A.

We're looking at -2.4% growth - with them it's -4%

Hence

Q: "What's the difference between Ireland and Iceland?"
A: "The letter 'c' and 6 months" Smiley: lol
____________________________
"I started out with nothin' and I still got most of it left" - Seasick Steve
#40 Jan 30 2009 at 3:33 AM Rating: Decent
Red wrote:
Me too, but strong is the Euro-sceptic force in this country, and Conservative the next government will be.


I'm praying for a miracle in the next year and a bit. Although neither side is particularly appealing at the moment.

Maybe I should go to Australia. It might be just as bad over there, but at least I'll be warmer.

Nobby wrote:
Naah. Oirland is taking a much harder hit than UK of A.

We're looking at -2.4% growth - with them it's -4%

Hence

Q: "What's the difference between Ireland and Iceland?"
A: "The letter 'c' and 6 months" Smiley: lol


Isn't is -2.8% for us? Still, you're right. It's nice to see someone suffering more.

Edited, Jan 30th 2009 6:38am by Kavekk
#41 Jan 30 2009 at 3:42 AM Rating: Good
Kavekk wrote:
Red wrote:
Me too, but strong is the Euro-sceptic force in this country, and Conservative the next government will be.


Although neither side is particularly appealing at the moment.


I agree. I don't think I could ever vote Tory, but I am completely sick of New Labour. It's the same old faces we've had for 12 years, playing musical chairs with cabinet seats, saying the same non-sensical bullcrap we've heard a thousand times before, still blaming the tories for everything that's wrong in this country... And I can't stand people like Geoff Hoon, or Hazel Blears, or Gordon Brown...

Oh well, at least there's always the good old BNP to defend our national interests against those bloody foreigners Smiley: mad.
____________________________
My politics blog and stuff - Refractory
#42 Jan 30 2009 at 3:45 AM Rating: Good
RedPhoenixxx wrote:
Oh well, at least there's always the good old BNP to defend our national interests against those bloody foreigners Smiley: mad.


Maybe the Great Depression will radiaclise the politics in this country, leading the BNP to gain power. Then they can rearm the country, cancel foreign debt and begin annexing small European countries, resulting in a lightning fast campaign of conquest that revitalises the country with plundered goods until everyone gets mad and invades.
#43 Jan 30 2009 at 4:02 AM Rating: Good
Kavekk wrote:
Maybe the Great Depression will radiaclise the politics in this country, leading the BNP to gain power. Then they can rearm the country, cancel foreign debt and begin annexing small European countries, resulting in a lightning fast campaign of conquest that revitalises the country with plundered goods until everyone gets mad and invades.


We had that with Napoleon, and really, it was a lot of fun while it lasted.
____________________________
My politics blog and stuff - Refractory
#44 Jan 30 2009 at 4:22 AM Rating: Good
*****
15,952 posts
RedPhoenixxx wrote:
Kavekk wrote:
Maybe the Great Depression will radiaclise the politics in this country, leading the BNP to gain power. Then they can rearm the country, cancel foreign debt and begin annexing small European countries, resulting in a lightning fast campaign of conquest that revitalises the country with plundered goods until everyone gets mad and invades.


We had that with Napoleon, and really, it was a lot of fun while it lasted.

Mmmmm, Empire Line clothing Smiley: nod Although I'm certain that the wars with him put paid to the long running fashion of make-up worn by men, which makes me Smiley: mad



...although I think Kavekk was picturing Hitler.

Which was probably a lot of fun while it lasted, too.

#45 Jan 30 2009 at 6:02 AM Rating: Decent
RedPhoenixxx wrote:
sweetumssama wrote:
You're right, the UK is an American colony.


That's very true, but with a bit of luck and a sharper economic downturn, it might one day become an European colony.
Or it could end up being more socially acceptable than either, and become a leper colony.
#46 Jan 30 2009 at 6:17 AM Rating: Good
Skelly Poker Since 2008
*****
16,781 posts
GwynapNud the Eccentric wrote:
Nobby - why on EARTH, are the NHS considering paying for special harnesses for lifting obese people? Thats not what my taxes are for .. Smiley: mad Smiley: mad Smiley: mad
Would you rather the health care employees try and lift heavy people, possibly injuring themselves in the process.

My guess is, if the UK is anything like the US, cigs, booze, fast food are all taxed heavily - no?

Quote:
Oh Honey, I could not disagree more strongly. The population was not this unhealthy and this diseased at any time in its history. The lack of health in the population is directly linked to a poor lifestyle that has occured with our weath, prosperity and rise of convienience foods. Really, Health is something you can influence.
You answer your own question. Sounds like a societal problem.

It doesn't seem as if you are lacking for health care. You probably live comfortably in your country of choice.

I conclude this is a whine post. Just what friday calls for.

Wine suggestions for the weekend anyone?



____________________________
Alma wrote:
I lost my post
#47 Jan 30 2009 at 6:20 AM Rating: Excellent
*****
15,952 posts
Botrytis Semillon.

Dessert Wine.

Although it's particularly good as the last drink after the cold lunch of meat, salads and fruits on a warm Summer day, It would probably also be awesome to go with a heavy dessert on a Winter evening, when everyone is rugged up and cosy.

Botrytis Semillon is very sweet for a wine, and is usually drunk in smaller amounts than reds or other types of whites. Although sweet, it is no less complex and satisfying than other good wines.

It is produced by an infection of Botrytis "noble" rot on Semillon grapes, which leaches out the water from the grapes, naturally concentrating the juice and sugars before it's made into wine. This is where the sweetness and heaviness of the wine comes from. It also means that the yield of liquid from a set amount of vineyard is far lower than for other types of wine.

This pushes up the price of the wine, but the tradition is to only drink half-glasses of it anyway, so glass for glass the price is effectively the same. Frequently it comes in half-sized bottles.

Edited, Jan 30th 2009 9:32am by Aripyanfar
#48 Jan 30 2009 at 6:25 AM Rating: Good
Elinda wrote:
Wine suggestions for the weekend anyone?


My local wine shop recently started selling some Brouilly, and it is absolutely delicious. Quite cheap and unpretentious, too. It's from the Beaujolais region, but it's one of the nicer beaujolais wines. Fleury is not bad either, but not quite as nice.

That's my tip for the week-end.
____________________________
My politics blog and stuff - Refractory
#49 Jan 30 2009 at 7:30 AM Rating: Good
Ministry of Silly Cnuts
*****
19,524 posts
Cotes de Ventoux, or any cheap-and-cheerful Claret
____________________________
"I started out with nothin' and I still got most of it left" - Seasick Steve
#50 Jan 30 2009 at 7:42 AM Rating: Decent
I had this really nice cherry wine once. I can't remember what it was called, but you should try it.
#51 Jan 30 2009 at 8:03 AM Rating: Excellent
Will swallow your soul
******
29,360 posts
I think it would go over better if you offered a tax break to the healthy, rather than a penalty to those who don't meet your pristine standards.

Go in for an annual checkup and come out with a clean bill of health and get a tax deduction for that year.
____________________________
In a time of universal deceit, telling the truth is a revolutionary act.

Reply To Thread

Colors Smileys Quote OriginalQuote Checked Help

 

Recent Visitors: 250 All times are in CST
Anonymous Guests (250)