Quote:
It is. It's exactly the same. The things that really irritate me about this issue is the fact that
a) Immigrants pay taxes. They contribute to the NHS, to pensions, to welfare. If the number of people paying for these services increases, then surely the number of people using these services can increase too.
b) We have a huge pensions problem. It's blindingly obvious to anyone who knows how the pension system works. We need more immigrants. And not just "skilled" ones either. We need builders, plumbers, electricians, shopkeepers, bus drivers, traffic warders, etc, etc...
c) Lots of British people and "skilled" workers don't pay taxes. The number of loopholes in the system is huge, and the only people that benefit from it are those that can afford "creative accountants". If you really wanna moan about the system being abused, then at least direct your anger at the right people. You know, those that register themselves at as a company on the Isle of Man, Jernsey, Guernsey, or the Bahamas. Or at the "non-doms".
I agree totally but before I ever get to explain these points to anti imigration people they are branded racists and get so defencive they will never change their minds.
The problem isn't racism, the problem is loss of social identity. You have numerous subcultures in Britain who quite rightly celebrate their culture visually and loudly, but there is nothing like Independace day for people to grab hold of their Britishness.
It's amazing to me that this country celebrates St Patrick's day with an almost unhealthy zeal and I think thats because there is nothing equivelant for England.
Of course it doesn't help when officious PC idiot do something stupid like banning someone having a St Georges cross flag and the papaers get hold of it
.
The BNP effect could be totally defused if there was something positive for people to do instead.
The other side of the coin is when a City council announces that 4000 jobs will be created because of a building scheme and the 12 months later figures released show that 75% of the jobs went to the Polish and most of the rest to people from outside the City dispite many of those jobs (90%) never being advertised to the locals.
But free market forces and all that, the Polish could afford to take minimum wage for skilled jobs because the cost of living in Poland is so low.
When things like that happen you're swimming against the tide trying to convince people immigration is good when the jobs they where promiced (or at least announced) where for locals have gone to imported workers.
50% of Taxi driver in plymouth are now eastern European, not because there is a lack of plymouth employee's but because the largest Taxi company can hire them in say Poland, charge them to train, charge them rent in flats the company owns, hire them cars the company owns, hire them equipment like satnav and comms the company owns and make profits at ever stage. This guy exclusively hires abroad now, he will not take on UK drivers even though he legally has to pay all his drivers the same money.
So you have 100 would be taxi driver unemployed in plymouth or moved on to other jobs.
As a non driver I use taxi's alot and these guys can do the job no doubt, but they lack the local area knowledge that the local drivers and don't bring the extra 10% that the local cabbies do.
For the local ecconomy there is no benefit as these are not extra jobs, they are jobs that would have been filled by locals but no are not and the service is reduced.