Allegory wrote:
Someone will be elected. There is no way to vote for none of them to be elected, therefore you must choose between the candidates. Even if you believe all of the candidates will be bad one will be the least bad in your opinion. The rational decision is to vote for the candidate who you believe will achieve the most good (synonymous with "least harm"). By not voting you increase the probability of the worse options being elected.
I enjoy neither having my finger pricked nor waterboarding, but having my finger pricked is far less painful than waterboarding. I would rather have neither done to me, but since I must choose between the two I choose the one that hurts the least.
If that is still confusing then I could grotesquely mutilate the idea down to "lesser of two evils."
Edited, Sep 13th 2008 9:15pm by Allegory
Except you don't have to vote. You have the option of saying "please don't prick my finger and I also don't like waterboarding so let's not do that either." No-one's going to like, tie you to a waterboard and shove you into the ocean screaming.
Your allegory doesn't make any sense because voting isn't compulsory in America. People can actually choose to remove themselves from the entire process and absolve responsibility, so there's no...
requirement.
I mean, look at this: you have two candidates for President and both suck. Maybe one's a psychopath and the other likes to fist kittens. You go with your system and say "well, fisting kittens is
less bad than being a psychopath, so I guess I'll vote for the kitten-fister." The kitten fister gets into the White House, everyone goes, what the ************ America, and then when he gets caught fisting your tabby cat all he has to do is point to the voters and say "You put me in office and you knew I liked to fist kittens!" and you know what? He's right. It wouldn't be his fault, it would be the fault of the people who decided that least harm equates with most good.
You want to say that it's your right as a citizen to hold power and be responsible for the use of that power? Good! Go run for office.