Kachi wrote:
Which might be a valid point if you were talking about his executive experience, but you weren't. You were talking about his patriotism.
You missed the point I was making completely. In the absence of some kind of experience, Obama is running on personality. That means that he has to be the kind of person that people would want to represent them, since he can't run on "I'm the guy with the best qualifications".
It's critically important that he himself appeal to American voters. Making a habit of bucking traditional symbols of patriotism isn't a great way to do that...
Make more sense now?
Quote:
It's a meaningless gesture to put your hand over your heart, particularly in comparison to one's actual service record.
He doesn't have a service record though. See how that's relevant? We don't have a long record of this guy to look at and see what sort of President he would be. All we have is his words in his speeches and a pretty short (and incredibly Liberal) voting record in the Senate. So things like this become important indicators that people use to see if they think he'd make a good President.
Quote:
If all you have to go on someone's love for their country is that, then ok, fair enough litmus test, but asserting that someone who has served their country lacks a love for it under that basis is utterly foolish.
He hasn't served his country though!
He was elected to local office in one city in one state, then elected to the Senate for less then a single term, by more citizens of that same state and under conditions in which he didn't have much serious competition.
He has no record for people to judge him by. Not one that Americans as a whole will see as relevant. Understanding and appealing to specific political issues in one part of the country does not automatically translate to a knowledge of what's best for the country as a whole, much less the host of foreign policy decisions he'd have to make.
Given that lack of experience and record for people to judge him by, every single action he makes is going to be that much more significant. So something that seems insignificant to you, is *huge* to the general population.
And on the topic of foreign policy, we haven't even started on the whole Odinga issue...