"OMG There's no Santa?????"
Haha. There, I said it. Wow, that was funny. Moving on.
I'm sure this has been done before but, as per the topic, when did you stop? Or were you too cool and smart and sadly deprived of the magic of childhood?
I think it ended for me around six or so. My sister, who was a big nosy snoop, used to dig around the closets and under the beds and find where my parents hid the gifts and then show them to me. So it was kind of obvious come Christmas morning where they came from. Around nine or so my mom once asked me if I knew that Santa wasn't real. I said I knew but could she continue labelling some of the gifts as from Santa because I liked it. She did (and still does -- it's how I can tell the fun gifts from the sweaters!)
I'm not sure about Joph Jr. I find it hard to believe that classmates haven't spread the word yet but he either still believes or else pretends to believe because he thinks that it's what we want to hear. He obviously knows that the mall Santas and stuff are just pretending. I've heard others say that, when they were kids, they were worried that if they admitted that they didn't believe any more, they'd stop getting the 'Santa' presents on Dec. 25th.