Forum Settings
       
1 2 Next »
Reply To Thread

Euthanasia EssayFollow

#27 Feb 13 2007 at 8:37 PM Rating: Decent
****
4,632 posts
Quote:
In this essay, I will attempt to look beyond these relativistic factors. I will argue that any person seeking euthanasia to relieve their own pain and suffering is not in a clear state of mind, and therefore unable to make a coherent, rational decision regarding their current state of life, and the conditions of their death. This essay will focus on the specific case of voluntary euthanasia, so all other cases will be ignored for the sake of argument.


While there's nothing glaring wrong with the rest of your essay (from a purely writing-based standpoint), this particular part raises alarms in my head. One of the things I've been taught ever since 4th grade is to not use "I" in an essay. Whether or not this is simply bias taught from youth or actual writing technique, I don't know. If you're making an essay arguing a certain standpoint, you want to make your thesis definitive. Instead of saying, "I will argue that any person...", say, "One can see that any person..." Right there is the point you are trying to prove for the entire essay. Putting in the "I will argue" makes it seem like a cop-out for inserting a clear, concise, and easily identifiable thesis within the rest of the beginning text.

Edited, Feb 13th 2007 11:39pm by DodoBird
#28 Feb 13 2007 at 9:16 PM Rating: Decent
*****
10,359 posts
Quote:
Whether or not this is simply bias taught from youth or actual writing technique, I don't know. If you're making an essay arguing a certain standpoint, you want to make your thesis definitive. Instead of saying, "I will argue that any person...", say, "One can see that any person..."


Not in analytic philosophy (that's the bad kind by the way).

In analytic philosophy most people tend to write incredibly dry stuff and frequently use the first person to argue and defend thier views. They also refer directly to the paper on numerous occasions. If the professor is not a Literature professor then they probably couldn't care less about it.

The reason we are told not to use first person in fourht grade is because the writing can become overwhelming with sentences that all begin as "I think that..." or "I don't believe that..." and so on.

The technique that you refer to places more emphasis on style than logical, argumentative form, and it much more pleasing to read. It is my prefered style since it was what I was taught in Literature, but you wouldn't believe the amount of professors that hate it, and even ask you to use first person more.

***

Some say... When you want to make a point, then just say it. Obviously it's your opinion because you wrote the paper! There is no need to state that it is so.

The others say... Of course you can use first person; it is your paper and your opinions. You might come across as generalizing without your person attatched to the work.

Edited, Feb 14th 2007 12:18am by Pensive
#29 Feb 13 2007 at 9:56 PM Rating: Default
Did you beat the **** out of yourself and call yourself a moron or did you just say to yourself "Agree to disagree." In any case if you did either of the 2 you might be crazy.

good job on the paper. see you in 2 weeks
#30 Feb 14 2007 at 7:49 AM Rating: Decent
**
418 posts
In case anyone is interested in following up Monoxdot's neoclassical economics reference:

Diamonds and Water

1 2 Next »
Reply To Thread

Colors Smileys Quote OriginalQuote Checked Help

 

Recent Visitors: 270 All times are in CST
Anonymous Guests (270)