Demea wrote:
They didn't come right out and say it. Instead, they said:
Quote:
Raid attendence will mean something to this guild in a VERY short time. Those that never show up, will not be asked to come on 25-man raids, simply because we won't have space. We work fantastically as a team. Our core members can progress through content very rapidly. So when only our core members are necessary, our guild will be one of the top raiding guilds on the server, EVEN IF WE ONLY RAID A FEW TIMES A WEEK.
And:
Quote:
Raids will be 25-man in the XPac. Ultimately raid space is going to become a premium commodity. If we field one team, then yes, 25 people will get to raid come raid night, and the rest will sit the bench.
So basically, those that can't make a serious time commitment to show up at nearly every raid will just have to sit on the bench, unless there are enough bench warmers to field another raid, and those that aren't even raiding yet (i.e. me, Moe, Onyxia, Psichi, and any other Asylumite that just started up again) are going to be doing PuGs because the "core members" are too busy making sure that their raid attendance is perfect to do anything else.
Considering I'm the person that said these things (in our protected guild-only forum that isn't really supposed to be brought outside the guild forum, and I don't appreciate the fact that you brought that content out of our forums without my consent, but whatever), I'm going to weigh in on this.
What actually happened: The drama llama came to town for TFS and we lost a few months of progression because a bunch of regulars left. A lot of people got tired and for a combination of reasons (holidays, PVP, XPac coming out, loss of several regulars, and someone's house catching on fire) we had some difficulty fielding a raid one night. Some tempers flared and things were said, and one more person left. I made the above post to tell people that coming in and leeching purple from our guild for no effort and then leaving to go somewhere else was going to stop. We're tired of being the de-facto "farm team" for Anetheron's other guilds.
What was perceived by a certain individual: That I was saying that only members of an "inner circle" would get to raid and everyone else would be left out. In and of itself this was a legitimate concern. However, it was NOT said in a respectful or adult manner, and when people called this person out on it and told them to stop acting like an asshat, they said "That's just the way I am, deal with it". Perhaps this person will one day realize that acting like an angst-filled 14 year old is not some "endearing lovable persona", but is just childish. If this issue was presented like an adult, it would have been respectfully answered. In fact, even though it WASN'T presented like an adult, it was STILL respectfully answered.
Here is what I will say on the issue: If you get to level cap and actually play with us, you will actually get a spot in the raid. If you come once a month and expect loot to be defaulted to you for 20 DKP so you can gear up and go to another guild, you will NOT get a spot in the raid. We won't need to deal with crap like that any more, and we won't. It's that simple.