U-Haul can get pretty expensive. When they quoted me unbearably high, I looked into moving companies.
ABF Movers had the best price versus what the Better Business Bureau had to say. They had a good rating (I didn't know anyone to ask for references). I ended up ditching all of my furniture and moving freight. I had just over 1,000 pounds of stuff and it cost 860 bucks to move from Watertown, NY to Oxford, MS (just over 1,200 miles and from one small town to an even smaller one). The catch is you have to pack it all yourself, and everything has to be in a box. You also have to label all the boxes as if they are being mailed. Included in that price was residential pick-up and drop-off...they came to my house. It took about 1 week to get the stuff, with the Christmas Holiday being right in the middle.
They also do U-Pack moving, where a moving van comes and you pack it. It is more expensive, but also a good deal if you have to move furniture. ABF is a big company and offers lots of options, and I had good luck with them. It really was cheaper to do ABF than to rent a trailer from U-Haul to stick on the back of my car.