Ambrya wrote:
I have to disagree, keeping in mind, of course, that I have seen the stage performance, including once in Toronto when the magnificent Colm Wilkinson (who was actually Andrew Lloyd Webber's first pick to play the Phantom, until he saw the chemistry between Michael Crawford and Sarah Brightman) played the Phantom. There is no describing how incredible that performance was...Colm Wilkinson was just larger than life.
Yes, yes he is! Bless you for impecable taste! No one can sing like him. He is my wife's favourite of all time. She liked it so much that she saw the Phantom in Toronto 6 times with Colm, and once with a different actor. He was most beautifully paired with the angelic voice of Rebecca Caine.
I have the CD with the Canadian Cast, and we listen to it in the car on trips. I have heard many other casts including the London cast, and they do not even hold any comparison. To hear what I am talking about, listen to the links from this page. They are cut short, but if you compare the voices to the London cast, you will see the lack of power in the voices from the other performers.
When I make my first $100M, I am going to hold an event featuring the two, if I can get them. (Shh.. it's a surprise for my wife).
Edit: You absolutely MUST listen to clip #6 (The Phantom Of The Opera) it is an excellent example of what I am talking about.
Fixed: Rebecca Caine
Edited, Thu Sep 29 18:14:58 2005 by Elderon