BlixofFenrir wrote:
I think they did the Phantom of the Opera movie really well. Though I can't compare it to the Stage performance as I've never seen it.
I have to disagree, keeping in mind, of course, that I have seen the stage performance, including once in Toronto when the magnificent Colm Wilkinson (who was actually Andrew Lloyd Webber's first pick to play the Phantom, until he saw the chemistry between Michael Crawford and Sarah Brightman) played the Phantom. There is no describing how incredible that performance was...Colm Wilkinson was just larger than life.
Emma what's-her-name did a credible job as Christine, but her acting was quite weak. My biggest problem with her performance was that she was clearly intimidated by the music (as well she should be.) There were a number of times, for example when approaching the trills at the end of "Think of Me," where she really pulled back and was basically handling the notes with kid gloves, like she was afraid of them. It was an okay performance, but not a phenomenal one by any stretch of the imagination.
As for the kid they got to play the Phantom, I don't know what the hell they could possibly have been thinking. He was far, far too young, and it came across in his voice. He simply didn't have the depth and richness to his voice that comes with maturity. He tried to make up for it by faking a "gravelly" edge to his voice, and it came off as exactly what it was: a kid pretending to sing like an older man. Furthermore, apparently because they wanted the audience to know the Phantom was, except for his disfigurement, quite a hottie, the camera spent a lot of time on the unflawed side of his face, which was very clearly YOUNG. Which pretty much made the whole flashback scene where Madame Giry rescues him from being a sideshow freak make very little sense, because in that sequence he was nearly the same age as she was.
All the other performances were okay, including Minnie Driver as Carlotta, but I think they made in mistake in being so determined to find young, popular, up-and-coming actors to play the leads, which really was a detriment to the quality of the musical.
Ambrya, life-long
thespian.
Edited, Thu Sep 29 02:21:42 2005 by Ambrya