Smasharoo wrote:
Still ranks 7th all-time.
Sure, in a fairly useless statistic. Unless you think Kurt Warner is the greatest QB of all time.
What statistic do you want to use then, huh?
Kurt Warner has only played in 58 career games. So his QB rating is largely from his 3 excellent seasons 99-01. If he repeated those same statistics from those seasons over the course of a 13 year career, then yes, he would be one of the best all time.
You argue that the longevity statistics are useless because Warren Moon and Dave Kreig show up in them. Well, Moon and Kreig don't show up in the percentage statistics.
Then, you argue that the percentage statistics are useless because Kurt Warner appears in them. Well, Warner doesn't appear in any of the longevity statistics.
The fact remains that Favre is one of the few quarterbacks that ranks highly in all categories.
And saying that Passer Rating is useless because Warner ranks at the top of it is bad logic. That's like me saying that OPS is a useless statistic in Baseball because Travis Hafner had the 10th best OPS in the major leagues this season.
Edited, Tue Oct 12 16:31:49 2004 by trickybeck