Quote:
Now put those soldiers into a situation where the people they are making "go for a swim" can not speak english, without a translator or with one that doesn't know the word "swim" because his training was focused on military matters rather then knowledge of the simpler things in the language
If the US military is stupid enough to run check points without translators they would of nuked themselves by now. It is immpossible to run a checkpoint without being able to understand the people going through it, so it would be manditory for a translator to be there for every shift. It is just common sense and the reason why they are working with the Iraqis.
Quote:
If an NCO caused the death of a soldier serving under him by ordering him to swim in a river while back here in the States, it would be labled as a training accident. Even if the soldier is known to be unable to swim and has severe aquaphobia.
I watched one soldier get pulled out of swimming pool during "drownproofing" class because, after stating he was deadly afraid of water, he was pushed into the deep end of the pool by an NCO.
That soldier passed out when he hit the water and had to be revived by lifeguards.
For one these are totally different situations. The recruit is there by choice and is in training to have their limits pushed. On the other hand the Iraqis civilians were forced there, they had no choice. So this comparison is not accurate. Another point is were the soldiers under orders to do this like they were in training. Sorry I dont think so, or there would of been lifeguards to prevent deaths and other mishaps. I understand a soldier will do what they are ordered and do some terrible acts under orders, but there was no orders for this or the media would of jumped on it before now. There is nothing to justify a soldier to take actions in their own hands. These soldiers forced a man to drown to death, knowing full well that he could not swim ( I don't believe your no translator argument for a second.) They deserve more then 10 years in jail for doing this act, just as anyone who deliberatly kills another does.