gbaji wrote:
Sure. Find me a single study that has examined the effectiveness (both long and short term) of spanking used in precisely the manner I described earlier in this thread. Can't do it, right?
You didn't describe a spanking.
This is your description:
Quote:
Then, he would deliver the spanking.
How hard should one hit when spanking?
Where should you spank a child?
If you spank them in the head should you first make them put their bike helmet on?
Can a male spanker spank a female child on the behind or is that 'sexual'?
Can a priest spank a male child on the behind or is that 'sexual'.
Should a 50 pound 6 year old child receive the same spanking as a 50 pound 4 year old child?
How many hits - one for each year? (oh wait that's birthday party shenanigans).
You're not talking a scientific method of punishment, you've merely gone off on some idealized fantasy story of growing up in suburbia USA during the 'golden years'.
edit: FYI, cant write, 'butt
Edited, Oct 1st 2014 2:34pm by Elinda