Quote:
Take this with a grain of salt. NIN/WAR is not the -best- tank, in fact, there is no -best- tank. There are, however, situations that suit one type of tank over another.
Agreed. There are situations where each tank is better for a suited task. However, at level 40 in crawler's nest with the right party setups, I still believe NIN/WAR is the best tank hands down and so on as I listed there after. I'm not knocking PLD as a good tank because it IS a great tank, its just a matter of effectiveness. I actually held hate better on my WAR/MNK than I did with my PLD/WAR at 40. Now this could just mean that since I leveled my WAR second that I got more FFXI experience and I understood 'hate' better, but I don't believe that was the case. WAR/MNK does surprisingly much more damage, even while keeping up with the normal duties of a tank.
So why do I say NIN/WAR above the rest?
The obvious first answer is the NIN/WAR's ability to negate damage. If the NIN tank sucks though, then this whole debate is pointless. NIN won't keep hate, can't keep shadows up etc.
The second answer is that a NIN/WAR has the capability of outdamaging the rest of the competition with relative ease from Ni Spells which he/she has just recieved, which is almost like causing damage at will.
The third answer is that a 40NIN has the ability to keep consistent hate just as well, and many times actually better.
The fourth answer is that a NIN's enfeebling is off the charts if Ninjutsu skill is capped. You'll have enfeebling land better than a RDMs, which is pretty scary.
So not only do you have a tank that can negate damage, you have a tank that has the capability of spurring out 6 Ni spells in less than 15 seconds. A tank that can cast its own enfeebles that can outdo a RDMs, and a tank that is capable of keeping hate in escalating-like form.
At level 40, in crawler's nest, with the right party setups, NIN is comparatively better than the rest.
I know, I hate it too. Check my sig. I've been a PLD for 3 years. Just a very slow leveler.