Spell Reflection has been my favorite Warrior ability ever since I got it. Reflecting everything from a Mage's Arcane Barrage to a Death Knight's Death Grip to a mob's spell cast.
Then I enter Utgarde Keep with the first boss being a spell caster. I'm thinking sweet, I'll interrupt those I can and spell reflect the last. Well, NO! Apparently bosses, or at least this special little snowflake, can toss spells right through your reflection. Yeah. Useful. Not.
Also, tanking level 70 instances is like tanking heroics in scrub gear all over again. Three hits and I'm dead and the healer goes OOM after 12 seconds. Nice.
I used to love Protection, but it really stinks right now. I'm hoping this boss was a glitch, that you're supposed to be able to reflect spells and stuff, because otherwise the ability is pretty useless.
On another note, Arms is really amazing and while it doesn't have the same health efficiency as Protection or even Fury, it does provide great lulz when you do 2.1k DPS in Nexus with Sweeping Strikes and Bladestorm. Hehe.
Edit: Can't have 'reflection' without 'ion'.
Edited, Nov 24th 2009 7:11pm by Mazra