So back in BC I turned my then Resto 1-55 druid into Feral. My guild needed a tank. That's what I was. A tank. I of course kittied for solo and questing and occasionally to get into a heroic I didn't feel comfortable tanking. But dpsing in cat was AWKWARD for me and my DPS generally sucked so bad it well...sucked.
Stuck in feral (I just couldn't bring myself to boomkin or resto again, i had enough casters/healers) I leveled through Northrend as a hybrid feral more geared towards DPS, but picking up half the tanking talents because well, I'm a tank, right? I'd run instances regularly with my leveling partner who just happened to be a holy priest.
I DPSd a few runs here and there. My DPS was "okay" but I wasn't topping charters. My "rotation" as you were was sloppy and I was sitting there trying to mash buttons like I do with my mage frustratingly stuck at 0 energy 90% of the time.
Then lo and behold just after reaching 80 this dual spec thing appears. Ooo! Pretty! And then this absolutely amazing thing happens. I can spec one spec fully and totally on dps and this other one on completely tanking. A novel concept. A feral druid that can actually be fully one or the other. No need to sacrifice this awesome talent here because its net effect wasn't useful when I was tanking.
Another amazing thing happened. Our guilds ret paladin respeced protection and was actually pretty good at it. Suddenly, I don't need to be feral for a tank.
Our MT and my best friend (one in the same) kept mentioning to me how he was seeing insane DPS out of feral cats. Feral? DPS? HA! Not for me. I'm a druid tank! HA! But...dual spec...DPS...why not?
So I start running heroics. Dagnabit 0 energy. I get frustrated and start reading up on basics of DPSing as a kitty (because I had NEVER bothered since I had never been interested). I start separating DPS from tanking set. Run some more heroics. Then all of a sudden I'm topping the DPS charts. 1.4k DPS quickly went to 1.9k dps. And now an almost solid 2k.
I find myself completely mesmerized. I start crafting epics from LW and I find myself making DPS pieces before the tanking pieces. I find myself enchanting pieces for DPS and not tanking. I'm asking for might over kings. Next thing I know in crafted epics and 80 blues I'm hitting 3k DPS consistently on trash mobs in vault. I run Naxx with my guild and I'm doing 2.2k dps throughout the arachnid quarter. This is just awesome! Getting rotations down. Seeing massive numbers. DPS count go up and up. Having to worry about pulling threat of the tank rather than the healer. I'm addicted!
These aren't insane numbers. But for me in just 78-80 blues pulling that kind of DPS seems awesome. I can't imagine what it'll be like when I start getting raid geared. Was feral buffed big time? Or am I doing something right? or both?
This is really fun!