Zemzelette wrote:
Let me warn you off Soul Preserver from reg CoS.
I would really have to question your test.
Where exactly did you test it, how many runs?
2% is 2%, so it's very dependent on how often you cast. In most instances I've ran the lack of casting, usually consisting of some renews, a few pom, and sporadic flash/greater heals per fight would make any proc trinket look like crap.
On the other hand, healing intensive fights, even more so AoE healing intensive fights like Sapph and Patchwerk, make trinkets like these shine.
Your 1-2 procs during an instance makes me believe you are healing very little, my own experience with the trinket, as well as many forums I've read since you posted has suggested a very decent proc rate.
Soul Preserver is one of the better pre-raid trinkets available. None of the trinkets you listed are bad either (although personally I would go with Cannoneer's Morale over Fuselight), but soul preserver is right up there at the top for pre-raid trinkets. After all, their only purpose is to have appropriate gear to get into raids, which offer much better trinkets.
But like I said before, all the trinkets(with the exception of DMC, that one is on par with raid/heroic gear, so you really can't put it in the same category) you listed, as well as the Soul Preserver are pre-raid trinkets. They are meant to get you geared for raids/heroics, all will work well enough, at the same time I wouldn't break my back trying to get any of them, since they will be replaced very easily.
Side note about your DMC: Illusion. Of course it's a better trinket, your comparing a iL187 trinket to a iL200 trinket of similar effects, that's kind of like saying "why get the Heroism Helm when the Valorous Helm is better".
Edit: Damnit posting from work, you responded to Moz before I finished typing, basically confirming the possibility of the lack of required healing on those test runs... I'll keep my post up since it still has significance, but I did start typing it long before you responded.
Edited, Apr 8th 2009 1:14pm by SynnTastic