Forum Settings
       
Reply To Thread

Dual Spec & You!Follow

#1 Mar 16 2009 at 1:28 AM Rating: Good
***
2,183 posts
Ok, cheesey title =P but oh well. I was just thinking about this, and I was curious what everyone here was going to do, and why, when dual spec is finally released. Are you gonna be a tank/healer to maximize your chances of finding a PuG? Are you going to have a PvP spec and a PvE spec? Are you not even going to worry about it?

Also was curious, what do you guys think about dual spec "solving" the tank/healer shortage issue?

For a while I was thinking that I would go Prot/Holy for my 2 specs. There's such a shortage of healers out there, at least ones willing to PuG. And DPS are a dime a dozen (most of the time =P). But really, anytime anyone wants me for a run, whether it be 5 man or raid, they want me to tank. I haven't donned my healing gear since BC raiding except once to see what my stats were like, and then to be a Cleanse-bot during Heigan since the Warrior was tanking him. And really that's all I had to do, Cleanse. I'd be much more useful tanking him, or being able to throw around some meaningful DPS.

I also started doing some PvP here and there again when I got bored. Respecced Ret for this, and (for the most part) have been enjoying it. Plus questing/farming is a lot more fun as Ret.

So, with my Paly, I will be purchasing dual spec and getting Ret as my second tree to Prot. Still want to have a healer, so I'll be taking dual spec on my Shaman as well: Enhancement/Restoration.

Second part: I really don't see dual spec doing much to solve the healer issue. If people don't like to heal, then they won't heal! More then anything I see Priests, Paladins, Shaman, and Druids who don't heal doing something more of a tank/DPS dual spec (where applicable), or a PvP/PvE DPS dual spec, or not buying it at all.

Tanks, it might help a bit. Most of the DPSers in my guild who are a tanking class have said they'll more than likely dual spec tank and their current DPS spec (Warriors, Druids, DKs: we got no Rets =P). And I have heard others that will do this as well. I'm sure you'll still see plenty of DKs who will be PvE/PvP specced, as well as the other classes, and refuse to tank, but I do see alot more "tanks" coming out of this feature than "healers". Thoughts?
#2 Mar 16 2009 at 1:38 AM Rating: Decent
***
3,229 posts
I know what you mean about healers. I had a conversation with a guild leader last night who was trying to persuade me to go dual holy when 3.1 hits. I'm currently building up tanking kit.
#3 Mar 16 2009 at 4:48 AM Rating: Decent
***
3,761 posts
I spend most of my respecs jumping between PVE holy and PVP holy, so I might as well use those for my dual specs. Still disappointed we hybrids only get 2 specs.
#4 Mar 16 2009 at 5:23 AM Rating: Excellent
**
678 posts
I'm going prot and holy.

Prot is my main specc and holy is a fun specc to me. I am, however, leveling a shammy for resto, so I might go prot/ret when I manage to get the shammy to 80. He's actually leveling faster than I expected, so if he hits 80 before patch, it'll be clear that I'll go prot/ret.
#5 Mar 16 2009 at 6:20 AM Rating: Good
***
1,594 posts
PvE Holy and PvE ret. My DK does my tanking and PvP now.
#6 Mar 16 2009 at 6:38 AM Rating: Decent
***
1,419 posts
Quote:
Second part: I really don't see dual spec doing much to solve the healer issue. If people don't like to heal, then they won't heal! More then anything I see Priests, Paladins, Shaman, and Druids who don't heal doing something more of a tank/DPS dual spec (where applicable), or a PvP/PvE DPS dual spec, or not buying it at all.


All it will do is have people rolling against main specs for their offspecs on drops in heroics and such. I guarantee that within a week of 3.1 going live, we have at least one thread in the general forums of someone asking if this is a recent issue for anyone else as well.

For myself, I'm going prot/holy. I have good sets for both, and am mostly needed as tank on 10 mans, and heals on weekened 25mans. It'll be nice not to have to pay so much to respec/reglyph twice a week, and I'll still be able to do some questing/farming during the weekend now too(I HATE trying to kill stuff as holy).
#7 Mar 16 2009 at 10:26 AM Rating: Excellent
***
1,225 posts
I'm already building an off-spec set of gear so I can switch to tanking if needs be. My guild (probably the whole realm) has a shortage of tanks right now so that's what's needed. However, I'll still count my main spec as holy.
#8 Mar 16 2009 at 11:09 AM Rating: Decent
***
1,912 posts
Hmm... yes, what this will do for the healer/tank problem...

Healer characters are only playable in groups. They are pretty sucky for solo content, and THAT is the reason why even people who like to heal in group content do not play healer characters.

As for tanks, tanks are ok at solo, but general consent is that you're not any use at PvP unless you either do a lot of damage or a lot of healing.

Now, what this will do for loot drama... Anybody remember when the only sources of gear upgrades were raids? So you had to go to raids for PvP gear upgrades and classes like warriors, shamans and Paladins would compete over the kind of items that hunters and rogues used for PvE.
#9 Mar 17 2009 at 4:00 AM Rating: Decent
I was a tank then listened to my guild and went holy to heal. Now with the duel spec I get to heal and go back to what I know best.

Thanks blizzard!!! (insert thumbs up)
#10 Mar 17 2009 at 5:37 AM Rating: Good
**
713 posts

Definitely going Ret/Prot for my two specs. I think over the last 2 months I have spent well over 1k in respeccs so this is not coming soon enough for me =P

On the tank/healer shortage I'm still not convinced its a good thing. Yes for guild raids it's a great idea but will there be a flood of skilless healers/tanks out there in the LFG too? I mean a simple gear check doesnt tell you if the said tank/healer is any good now does it?

From what I have heard though quite a few players that dps are looking forward to using duel spec for PvE and PvP. If they really wanted to tank or heal they would already be doing it.
#11 Mar 17 2009 at 7:41 AM Rating: Default
2 specs are better then 1. But even with 2 specs you can only cover 2 builds. There are a at least 5 builds (RET pvp/pve Prot pve and Holy pvp/pve). So we still have to respec, and choose our specs very carfully.... It would be better if Blizzard, would let us pay for free respecs for ever. That would be very nice :P



#12 Mar 17 2009 at 8:33 AM Rating: Decent
***
1,503 posts
my first impression too was re: the barrage of unskill healers and tanks. but then you need to consider that most raids will be guildies only and that all the current heroics are godawful easy.

we got through the whole DK thing alright. you know, the one where the 800dps huntard rerolls as a DK tank. all it takes is a good healer and a couple solid dps to carry a group now.

same thing applies for loot drops. if you haven't already squeezed all the heroics dry for a main set, you haven't been playing. my Tank set is at block cap, my Heal set is +2.2k, and then i have my main Ret set. for raids, main spec(usually the one you bring) will still take prority.


in BC i kept 3 characters: Prot/Ret pally, Holy priest, and Frost mage. obviously each had their role. now in WotLK, a pally can fill any spot will a simple respec/reglyph. this is very advantageous too since you keep all your rep/professions/achievements without having to regrind. dual spec makes this even more powerful.

Ret and Prot raid specs for me.
#13 Mar 17 2009 at 9:22 AM Rating: Excellent
LTkoen wrote:
2 specs are better then 1. But even with 2 specs you can only cover 2 builds. There are a at least 5 builds (RET pvp/pve Prot pve and Holy pvp/pve). So we still have to respec, and choose our specs very carfully.... It would be better if Blizzard, would let us pay for free respecs for ever. That would be very nice :P


Or.. just like bank slots, let us pay for Spec slots or something of the like. They can be progressively more expensive, so there's another money sink (which they like to have), and it will help those who really like to bounce around do it at their leisure. Spec slots beyond a couple will be more of a luxury than anything.

Not sure what I'm going to do yet... might go Ret PvE/Holy PvP or Ret PvE/Tank, or still might go Ret PvE/Ret PvP, although I don't think I'll be doing that last one.
#14 Mar 17 2009 at 9:46 AM Rating: Decent
***
3,761 posts
CapJack wrote:
LTkoen wrote:
2 specs are better then 1. But even with 2 specs you can only cover 2 builds. There are a at least 5 builds (RET pvp/pve Prot pve and Holy pvp/pve). So we still have to respec, and choose our specs very carfully.... It would be better if Blizzard, would let us pay for free respecs for ever. That would be very nice :P


Or.. just like bank slots, let us pay for Spec slots or something of the like. They can be progressively more expensive, so there's another money sink (which they like to have), and it will help those who really like to bounce around do it at their leisure. Spec slots beyond a couple will be more of a luxury than anything.

Not sure what I'm going to do yet... might go Ret PvE/Holy PvP or Ret PvE/Tank, or still might go Ret PvE/Ret PvP, although I don't think I'll be doing that last one.


I've seen this idea in various forms before. I have to admit, I don't like it/don't feel it's fair. Pure classes will be happy with 2 specs, they can PVE and PVP and never have to worry about a tanking spec/PVP spec/soloing spec/healing spec etc..


Not sure why they should punish hybrids who can perform different roles. I already pay triple what a mage/rogue pays in gems/enchants by keeping my off set up to date. I don't see the need for 1000g/2500g/5000g/10,000g just to play my entire class.

Edited, Mar 17th 2009 1:48pm by mikelolol
#15 Mar 17 2009 at 9:56 AM Rating: Decent
***
1,912 posts
mikelolol wrote:
CapJack wrote:
LTkoen wrote:
2 specs are better then 1. But even with 2 specs you can only cover 2 builds. There are a at least 5 builds (RET pvp/pve Prot pve and Holy pvp/pve). So we still have to respec, and choose our specs very carfully.... It would be better if Blizzard, would let us pay for free respecs for ever. That would be very nice :P


Or.. just like bank slots, let us pay for Spec slots or something of the like. They can be progressively more expensive, so there's another money sink (which they like to have), and it will help those who really like to bounce around do it at their leisure. Spec slots beyond a couple will be more of a luxury than anything.

Not sure what I'm going to do yet... might go Ret PvE/Holy PvP or Ret PvE/Tank, or still might go Ret PvE/Ret PvP, although I don't think I'll be doing that last one.


I've seen this idea in various forms before. I have to admit, I don't like it/don't feel it's fair. Pure classes will be happy with 2 specs, they can PVE and PVP and never have to worry about a tanking spec/PVP spec/soloing spec/healing spec etc..


Not sure why they should punish hybrids who can perform different roles. I already pay triple what a mage/rogue pays in gems/enchants by keeping my off set up to date. I don't see the need for 1000g/2500g/5000g/10,000g just to play my entire class.

Edited, Mar 17th 2009 1:48pm by mikelolol


Well, look at it this way... If you play an hybrid you can have a dps pve spec and a dps pvp spec, that way you'd have all the same options as dps classes. But you'll have the same amount of opportunity as any DPS to enter a run in PvE.

So really, tanks and healers have more an advantage than a disadvantage in that you CAN actually chose a role other than dps in pvp, pve, or both.

If you spec healing or tanking your opportunities to enter runs in PvE are huge.

And if you dual spec pve healer and pve tank you just got yourself an express entrance to any instance run.

IMO, unless you're into hardcore raiding your PvP spec will work good enough in PvE (be it holy or ret). Anyway, being melee dps kind of sucks in raids, and in 5-mans you can be melee dps with your good ole ret pvp spec.



Edited, Mar 17th 2009 2:12pm by xorq
#16 Mar 17 2009 at 10:13 AM Rating: Excellent
mikelolol wrote:

I've seen this idea in various forms before. I have to admit, I don't like it/don't feel it's fair. Pure classes will be happy with 2 specs, they can PVE and PVP and never have to worry about a tanking spec/PVP spec/soloing spec/healing spec etc..


Not sure why they should punish hybrids who can perform different roles. I already pay triple what a mage/rogue pays in gems/enchants by keeping my off set up to date. I don't see the need for 1000g/2500g/5000g/10,000g just to play my entire class.

Edited, Mar 17th 2009 1:48pm by mikelolol


I don't see this as a punishment, no one is forcing you to buy the extra specs. If you don't want to spend the money and want to continue paying the respec fees, go ahead. You might save money just doing that, since you'd have to respec so many times just to break even. But for those who are swimming in it, have been keeping their gear up to date, and been buying every other luxury in the game (mammoths/hogs/whatever) this is just another thing for them to get as a luxury, not a requirement.
#17 Mar 17 2009 at 11:07 AM Rating: Decent
***
3,761 posts
Quote:
I don't see this as a punishment, no one is forcing you to buy the extra specs. If you don't want to spend the money and want to continue paying the respec fees, go ahead. You might save money just doing that, since you'd have to respec so many times just to break even. But for those who are swimming in it, have been keeping their gear up to date, and been buying every other luxury in the game (mammoths/hogs/whatever) this is just another thing for them to get as a luxury, not a requirement.


I don't think it would be a very great money sink, because it's really only viable for hybrids. What about rogues who like you say, have everything in the game purchased? That might be the case, but theres far less reason for a rogue to buy 3 specs, then say, a paladin or druid.

My beef is more with spending 1000g (to "save" money on respecs), then still spending money on other respecs. I play 4 myself, and in order of most played they are PVE holy, PVP holy, prot, ret. On my mage/rogue, the dual spec system is amazing because it will cover all my needs, but on a hybrid my feeling is just "meh".
#18 Mar 17 2009 at 11:27 AM Rating: Good
Well I respeced 3 times this weekend and another time last night. So mostly I play Ret and Holy but occasionally I like to tank for people or offtank Naxx. So of the 200g I spent since last friday on respecs I could have cut that in half with leaving Ret all the time and just switching Holy and Prot occasionally.

It's not perfect but it will pay for itself eventually. I dont PvP much anymore so for now I just have need for 3 PvE specs Ret Holy and Prot.
#19 Mar 17 2009 at 11:57 AM Rating: Good
***
1,503 posts
Quote:
My beef is more with spending 1000g (to "save" money on respecs), then still spending money on other respecs. I play 4 myself, and in order of most played they are PVE holy, PVP holy, prot, ret. On my mage/rogue, the dual spec system is amazing because it will cover all my needs, but on a hybrid my feeling is just "meh".


do you really rotate 4 specs on a regular basis? or are you just fluffing your point?

i play Ret as my main(pve and pvp) and i will respec to Prot for the week to fill in guild runs as needed, i can tell you from experience that switching rolls does take a toll on your ability to play. example: when on my game a H CoS run puts me at about 3.2k dps. last week coming off of 3 weeks of tanking, i was only about to pull 2.6k dps in almost the same group setting(mount farming). the built-in reflexes of playing a particular roll for so long become invaluable.

so, unless you are not human or have ridiculous experience in each roll, i would consider the option of respecing to be a compromise between efficiency and convenience.

now, this is different when compared to playing another class entirely. when playing another class you have a whole new set of tools and a much different playstyle. but, i'll be damned if i still don't get caught looking for my bubble on my DK sometimes.
#20 Mar 17 2009 at 3:35 PM Rating: Excellent
mikelolol wrote:

I don't think it would be a very great money sink, because it's really only viable for hybrids. What about rogues who like you say, have everything in the game purchased? That might be the case, but theres far less reason for a rogue to buy 3 specs, then say, a paladin or druid.

My beef is more with spending 1000g (to "save" money on respecs), then still spending money on other respecs. I play 4 myself, and in order of most played they are PVE holy, PVP holy, prot, ret. On my mage/rogue, the dual spec system is amazing because it will cover all my needs, but on a hybrid my feeling is just "meh".


I think it would be a better money sink than a 20k motorcycle or 10k rings that are replacable. Sure, the hybrid classes might get more use out of it than the straight DPS classes, but it will still take a good chunk of money out of the economy, especially from those who have a lot of money who can afford the luxury of having 5 different spec slots. And with the first couple of specs easily affordable, more people will want to spend on that. And you say it's only viable for hybrids so... DK(3), Warrior(3), Priest(4), Paladin(5), Druid(5-6), and Shaman(5)... 6/10 classes would benefit from more than 2 specs.


Annnnyway you are saying it would be nice to be able to pay for free respecs for life. I don't see that happening since Bliz doesn't like to give away free stuff. My suggestion I think is more in-line with what Blizzard would do and I think would help, again, with bringing down the economy and inflation.

If they do decide on free respecs at some point in the future, that would be awesome, I'd also like them to stop taking money from my AH sells and repairing as well.
#21 Mar 17 2009 at 8:40 PM Rating: Decent
***
3,761 posts
"Annnnyway you are saying it would be nice to be able to pay for free respecs for life. I don't see that happening since Bliz doesn't like to give away free stuff."


Forums are all messed up, I can barely type this :P

Just wanted to point out, they're essentially giving that service to my mage/rogue, and players who play a warlock/hunter are getting the same thing as well.

Seriously, my mage drops 1000g once, I basically never have to pay for a respec again in my life. Why can't it be like that on my paladin?
#22 Mar 17 2009 at 9:41 PM Rating: Excellent
They are essentially giving that out because you choose not to respec beyond those 2 specs for your dps. You can choose to only keep 2 specs for your Paladin if you wanted, but it's a different situation. I guess all this extra money and everything is the price for versatility. We want to dps as good as the dpsers, tank as good as the other tanks, and heal as good as the other healers, we gotta pay a bit more for it. *shrug*

When they first started coming out with the Dual Spec, they were saying that they might expand on it in the future, so maybe we'll see hybrids get more specs or some other way of managing the spec issue. Either way, Dual Spec is still a nice thing that they didn't really have to do, it's a luxury and not a requirement (I don't think). It will make it easier when a particular raid fight requires 1 less or 1 more tank or healer than the previous one.
#23 Mar 18 2009 at 7:50 AM Rating: Good
***
1,503 posts
Quote:

Just wanted to point out, they're essentially giving that service to my mage/rogue, and players who play a warlock/hunter are getting the same thing as well.

Seriously, my mage drops 1000g once, I basically never have to pay for a respec again in my life. Why can't it be like that on my paladin?


i dont know. on my mage i could do:
-PvE Arc for raids
-PvP Arc for arenas
-Frost(W/E) for quest/farming
-FFB would also be usable for plenty of stuff

my priest could run through about 5 usable specs depending on situation, but i'll be happy spending the 1000g for first 2 and respec fees for those specialty respecs that happen only once in a while.
#24 Mar 26 2009 at 6:59 AM Rating: Good
**
308 posts
PVE Holy and PVE Ret

I'm not a hardcore PVPer, although I do quite a few BG's. I find that either of my PVE specs work just fine for the BGs.

Ret is my main, although I enjoy playing holy and my guild occasionally needs another healer. So that's what works for me.
#25 Mar 31 2009 at 11:17 PM Rating: Excellent
**
678 posts
Some things went slower last night and we ended up staying late as some members left and had to be replaced, and thus so did our needs. To make a long story short I respecced 3 times in one night. Not only would dual specc have saved me 100g, but also about 10 mins traveling to/fro the paladin trainer and my bank. And no, I don't change my gylphs so yes, I wasn't contributing to the fullest of my class potential.

Three respeccs in one night is obviously excessive, but it will save me a ton of gold and also enable me to play the extra specc to a fuller potential.

Please, let next wednesday be patch day ...
Reply To Thread

Colors Smileys Quote OriginalQuote Checked Help

 

Recent Visitors: 181 All times are in CST
Anonymous Guests (181)