RichardvdD wrote:
Then why dont you use improved blessing of might and vindication?
Improved BoM is great. Having the BoM glyph extends your (Improved) BoM to 30 minutes. Ret Pallies should be using this on themselves constantly.
Vindication is meh. Great stuff while leveling and it does proc fairly often, but is isn't NEEDED when soloing as you still kill everything within a few seconds anyway. In dungeons/raids vindication is useless because bosses are immune.
As far as your stats go, it has been well established that while you are leveling STR > Agil > Stam, so a mix of Tiger and Bear is more beneficial than straight Bear. You say you get plenty of crit from talents, but that isn't totally true. You do get a LOT of crit from talents, but you also get a lot of crit from Agil.
Compare your crit rating with all Bear equipment on VS. some Bear and some Tiger. You will notice a big difference.
Sure, Stam is nice, but you should be killing things fast enough that a TON of stam is not needed. By taking all Bear, you are getting a lot of Strength (which means a lot of attack power) and a lot of stamina which equals... health pool. I would rather have a somewhat smaller health pool and a higher crit chance, so I balance Tiger and Bear. Also, Agil gives you a decent armor boost in addition to higher crit chance. Once you get to the mid to upper 50s the BEST Ret Pally gear for that level (of the Beast) has all 3, Str, Agil, and Stam.
If stacking nothing but Bear equipment works for you, that is fine, but the established order of stats for maximum DPS is STR > Agil > Stam while you are leveling. If you want more surviveability and less DPS, then straight Bear equipment is probably more for you. I would rather kill stuff quicker as a means of staying alive... dead mobs can't hurt you at all.
Once you get to end-game and are doing level 80 dungeons, heroics, raids, etc. people will be evaluating you on your DPS. Check out the Retribution Sticky to see what stats are important at that point, but I think even the people who are far more expert at Retribution (Capjack, Toolofjesus, and others) would agree that if you totally ignore Agility while leveling you are missing something.