Unbuffed crit weirdness.Follow

Can someone tell me why Darmane has more crit than I and by such Huge margin. From what I can tell I should have more

90agil for reference is 1.08crit and 46crit rating is 1crit. He has 128agil more than me, which is around 1.4 crit more.

He has 558crit rating +12.16%crit, while I have 716crit rate +15.60%crit minus that 1.4% 14.2% or so. yet he has 39.81% unbuffed crit and I got 36.71.

I tried switching weapons to fist dagger like his, no change. we both went naked, our crit was pretty much same. He added items weapons 1 by 1 and it was nothing unusal with crit. Am I bugged or I am going crazy ;p?

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-sheet.xml?r=Elune&n=Narumi <me
http://www.wowarmory.com/character-sheet.xml?r=Elune&n=Darmane <him

>.>

It is rather odd your crit adds up correctly adding crit from rating+agi+talent gives you 36.72% almost exactly what the tool tip says. Your friends though is off by 5%. My only guess is that he is getting the effect of close quarter combat twice one for fist one for dagger. So to test this try equipping a dagger+fist and see what your tooltip says then.

Possibly a result of this bug?

http://www.wowinsider.com/2009/01/08/ghost-talents-hotfixed/

Basically, people who had Fist specialization before it was removed from the talent trees, didn't actually lose the talent! That would explain an extra 5% crit for him, if he used to have fist spec and you didn't.