So here's basically what happened. I'm the guilds muti rogue. The rest are usually combat, but the CL and one other decided to try mutilate out. They both have a Titansteel shanker in the MH and Lightblade Riverner in the OH while I had just 2 Riverners. Both have more hit, and more AP then me. Yet, on the heroic dummy in IF, I out dps them by about 200. Not alot, but it begs the question of what the hell, so we looked at the combat logs. I would crit envenoms for 5k-6k constantly, and normal them for 2k-3k. Pretty alright, but they are lucky to break 2k on a crit. Is there any reasonable explaination for that? They all copied my spec 51/13/7, the one from the sticky. *boggle* Riddle me that one, bat-dudes.
http://www.wowarmory.com/character-sheet.xml?r=Duskwood&n=Valtus
^- Armory to my toon, if it helps.