Losie wrote:
There's a reason that cut gems don't sell on the AH. If people DID buy cut gems (who knows, maybe on your market they do) then I could understand the point. That would increase the market size quite a bit and give people specialized niches depending on which cuts they've bought. As it is, if you want to make money with JCing, selling raw gems and Dragon's Eyes is the way to go. Buying gem cuts is for being useful to your guild.
For the time being, there are certain cuts (typically heroic drops or exalted rep purchases) that are tough to find. The JCs who do have them are frequently reluctant to speak up when you inquire about it in /2. I've got a couple of gems in my gear now that are less than ideal (+parry/+stam instead of +dodge/+stam) because the gems I want sell for 120g, the JCs who cut them list them on auction from alts, and I can never track down a JC who will cut it for me. Gemming my gear to get the stats I want and still keep my meta active is almost turning into a mini-game, further complicated by finding viable cuts at reasonable prices until some of our guild JCs have had a chance to build their rep and get some drops.
I keep in mind at all times that Naxx is the Kara of WotLK. I'm not about to dump hundreds of gold into augmenting a single piece of gear that will be upgraded shortly after the next major content patch. Gold is easy to make...I'm having no difficulty staying on top of my raiding costs, and all I do for dailies are Sons of Hodir quests. That doesn't mean, however, that I'm inclined to spend it as fast as I make it just because I can. I'm poor by a lot of player's standards at 80. I keep a reserve of 5k gold on my paladin and try not to dip into it for anything. I do, however, have a 440+ leatherworker/skinner alt that can make me epic leg kits quite readily. I've got an enchanter alt that can provide me with some of my enchants via vellum (and also can D/E all the BoE junk for a ready supply of materials even if I can't do the enchant myself). And now my warrior is level 60 with 410 Jewelcrafting...26 stacks of Saronite yielded 19 rare WotLK gems that are in the bank waiting for my next upgrade with sockets.
Quote:
But I do understand your point. It is important to keep professions in check. Nerfing the raw gem market to the point that a Tier V raw gem sells for less than 5g (making Tier IV raws virtually worthless except as vendor trash or for the daily token quests) just doesn't seem the way to do it.
Most professions (to include and/or especially gathering professions) have made an absolute killing since the expansion release. I don't recall the last time I sold anything on auction...the leather, the herbs, and the ore have all been used. With such an incredible abundance of dailies throughout Northrend, not to mention the fact that a frugal player will pull in 5-6k gold from quest rewards and vendor trash in the process of doing the Loremaster of Northrend achievement, it's no longer really necessary for any one profession to be able to haul in tens of thousands of gold over the course of a few months. If they can, great. It won't detract from their ability to keep their gear in top form if they can't, however.
With my first WoW toon, I leveled enchanting because I did a bit of research beforehand and learned about the buy/disenchant/sell method of earning an income. The realm I rolled on was barely a month old at the time, and I made a relative fortune. As the market filled out and more people were around to compete, it slowly became pointless to invest the same amount of time for a trivial gain. When you're used to checking your mailbox on your level 30-40 main and pulling out 100-200g/day on 45 mins worth of effort, doing the same thing for 10g and a mailbox full of returned items is almost like a slap in the face. That's why I try to be careful to not let my opinion degrade into gleeful hopping up and down that another profession is getting "nerfed" to bits.
Ironically, savvy auction house speculation is still where most of the vast fortunes are coming from these days...but behind most successful day traders is usually a well filled out JC book ;D