My friend and I are both level 55 paladins and have been questing together, he Retribution and for now I'm a Protection pally. I really enjoy Protection but my guild has a desperate need for good healers so at 80 I will likely spec Holy. Anywho, I currently main tank a lot of raids with my guild on my Death Knight, and just find that groups in which I have a Holy Paladin healing me do not go as smoothly as when I have a resto Shaman or Druid. I'm here to find out why that is. Granted I don't see a ton of Holy Paladins, so the few I group with could have just been poor players which you'll see in every class and spec. Also I haven't really bumped into too many bad Resto Druids.
Are Resto Druids just easier to heal with? Is it differences in a players skill level that I'm seeing? Are Holy Paladins missing something that would make their role as healer easier? I'm just curious what it is that has given me this impression.
All that aside, I have some gear questions for Holy Paladins. What stats do they primarily seek out? I also notice a lot of them will go for Cloth gear as I imagine it gives them more of the stats they need. Are there cases where Plate is the better choice for Holy gear? Or will Cloth usually be better for healing PvE and Plate healing for PvP?