Forum Settings
       
Reply To Thread

Advice on my DKFollow

#1 Dec 08 2008 at 10:15 AM Rating: Decent
36 posts
Hello all
I was wondering if you would take the time to review my DK and offer any constructive advise?
I would just like to know if i am on the right track.
http://www.wowarmory.com/character-sheet.xml?r=Runetotem&n=Kadora

Thanks in advance.

DS
#2 Dec 08 2008 at 10:49 AM Rating: Default
woooow What the heck kind of spec is THAT? And what's with all the haste gear? You, sir, are a certified deathtard. Congratulations. I will, however, still help you with some recommended builds.

Blood
Unholy
Frost

Pick one.
#3 Dec 08 2008 at 10:59 AM Rating: Decent
21 posts
Hi

Im far from a specialist, but i wouldnt go for that spec, i dont really see the point on going hybrid while leveling, and it seems kind of messy to me the way you have your points laid out.

Lets see, 1 point in anticipation, whats with that?
Full unholy command instead of epidemic doesnt seem correct while leveling.


And I could point some other things out, but I cant keep my mind away of why would you go so far into blood and dont take Hearth Strike, or even, have all those points in Unholy without taking a few more to get SS !

If you seek advice, get rid of the hybrid spec and try a full blood or full unholy.

In blood I would do something like this:

www.wowhead.com/?talent=jfVMqI0IcboxzAoG0bZfM
#4 Dec 08 2008 at 11:01 AM Rating: Decent
21 posts
Missed Dilbrt post xD

#5 Dec 08 2008 at 11:03 AM Rating: Excellent
**
676 posts
Come on Dilbrt...

Ok Door, your spec is definitely not helping you. Are you looking to DPS or Tank or have some ability to do both? That would definitely help us out to know. Also, do you like Blood, Frost, or Unholy? Looks from yours that you're torn between Blood and Unholy.

Second, your gear should be upgraded to look for the following stats in order

DPS
Strength, Hit Rating, Attack Power, Critical Strike, Expertise, Stamina

Tanking
Defense Rating, Stamina, Strength, Parry/Dodge Rating, Expertise

Haste is horrible for DK's as such a small percentage of our damage is from white attacks. I know you only have 2 pieces and Dilbrt exaggerated, but you shouldn't have any at all if you can help it.

Hopefully this gives you a little more insight on what to look for. I'll check back to see if you've replied to any of my questions. Also, despite any previous knowledge of Theo, he has a couple good Blood DPS builds in his threat to take a look at. You can also Armory my DK (got hacked, hence no gear till they send it back) for spec. He's in basically a testing Unholy tank spec right now. I'm still working on it, but I do well for what I built it for.

Good luck and hope to see you around.
#6 Dec 08 2008 at 11:22 AM Rating: Default
Galenmoon wrote:
Come on Dilbrt...


Come on nothing. Sorry but if someone doesn't know how to play, it's fair game to tell them.... they don't know how to play. It's like coming across a DK in full spell power gear. Do you think I'll walk up to them be all warm and fuzzy and politely explain to them that spell power isn't good? Nope. I'm one of those that laugh, call them a deathtard, and carry on with my life. There are SOOOOO many guides out there and FAQs out there that completely explain every aspect of playing a DK, from what spells to use in what order, to what stats you need, to what specs you should try. If you can't handle google, then you're fair game for me.

Come into these forums and ask "what are the appropriate stats?" I'll answer.
Come into these forums and ask "what are some good builds for X?" I'll answer.
Come into these forums and post the worst spec that you can humanly come up with, and I'll eat you alive.
#7 Dec 08 2008 at 11:28 AM Rating: Good
**
676 posts
Fair enough, most of the people who know wtf they are doing aren't going to do that. That leaves us with the "deathtards". Guess they'll figure it out eventually.
#8 Dec 08 2008 at 12:19 PM Rating: Excellent
36 posts
Gee apparently you have never been asked for “constructive advice” before Dilbrt
If I wanted to be called a “Death-tard” I would have asked my 10yo daughter or my 18yo son.
I am new to the class (as is everyone) and I figured I may not have it right so I asked for help. I have read a bunch on the class, but there is no real definitive answer I have found regarding what is a “bad” build I guess I do now thanks to more intelligent responses.
As far as my build I put the points in UH so I could get the Ghoul as a permanent pet.
Then I went into blood for the dps/healing ability.
After running with a group last night, seeing the stats and giving it some thought I may have been off base and it looks like I was.
In reference to my gear I have what I have from rewards and drops I have steered away from rewards that gave me int or mana re-gen for obvious reasons.
I replace my gear with items that have more appropriate stats when I get them, this I do understand.
So, to the people that did not act like elitist 12 year old jerks. Thank you I will be re-tuning my DK tonight after work.

DS

#9REDACTED, Posted: Dec 08 2008 at 12:54 PM, Rating: Sub-Default, (Expand Post) No, actually I get asked for it a lot. I just rarely actually give it. Being a smartass is much more entertaining.
#10 Dec 08 2008 at 1:02 PM Rating: Good
***
2,680 posts
Quote:
Second, your gear should be upgraded to look for the following stats in order

DPS
Strength, Hit Rating, Attack Power, Critical Strike, Expertise, Stamina

Can you quantify this statement please? Or link to where the analysis of this stat weight order was made?

Thanks. =D

EDIT: Best analysis I can find puts stat weights at: Hit > Str > Exp > Crit > etc. (see Alla's wiki page, sourced I believe from EJ's thread)

Edited, Dec 8th 2008 1:27pm by TherionSaysWhat
#11 Dec 08 2008 at 1:14 PM Rating: Good
36 posts
Dilbrt
It sounds like we would get along in RL :).
To answer the question earlier I would like to dps and survive during leveling, then possibly move into a tank role.
However i do not really like the frost items much. It seems like the survival spec for hunters.
so i guess the question is..
1. If I go UH I loose some of the heeling ability's that i use all the time.
2. If I go Blood I loose by buddy and exploding bodies.
Is there a big benefit to the ghoul and CE? and will i do as much dps as blood?
Are the heeling parts in Blood worth it?
Or am i looking at the small picture of a few of the goodies in the trees?

DS

#12 Dec 08 2008 at 2:05 PM Rating: Good
***
2,069 posts
These are just examples:

Leveling build (as per Jame from Jame's guide fame)

LVL 80 DPS Builds (as per Theo from these boards)

LVL 80 DPS build (as per Elitist Jerks)

Personally, I have found that Unholy has better survivability than Blood, but play what you enjoy the most.
____________________________
http://www.marriageissogay.com/

Song of the day:
May 26, 2011 -- Transplants
#13 Dec 08 2008 at 2:31 PM Rating: Decent
Ailitardif, Star Breaker wrote:
Personally, I have found that Unholy has better survivability than Blood, but play what you enjoy the most.


It can have more survivability because of bone armor, but it has a major flaw in my opinion. It requires you to stand in desecration for the full damage. It seems like most raids I've done either require me to run in and out, or the tank to move the mob. I personally like the fact that it doesn't matter where I stand for blood. I do enjoy unholy as well, I hope they fix the 1 unholy per raid thing.
#14 Dec 08 2008 at 2:33 PM Rating: Decent
Hey doorslammer,

you say u use the healing abilities alot?
What way are u working through the mobs?
I lvled to 80 as frost, and xcept some elites i never used a single heal in fights, except when i accidently pulled more than 3-4 mobs.
I think that if you are needing the selfheals, you are lacking the damage to kill mobs fast enough, which totally would be solved by going deep into unholy or frost, on the other hand, if u like single target more you should go blood :)

Theres enough specs on the boards to try, but for a lvl 74 id personally go for:
http://www.wowhead.com/?talent=jfmMZZfM0htfkxcq0csut - Unholy without tanking talents
http://www.wowhead.com/?talent=jZ0xZfgzhtfkxcq0csut - Unholy with tanking talents (if u wanna go this way, make sure to read more about it, im a silly noob if it comes to unholy tanking)
http://www.wowhead.com/?talent=j0xzZGxxthczRhRVosx0g - Frost tank/dps (yea i dont think you should be frost without tanking talents :P your gonna get alot of them anyway, and its easy and great tanking)
#15 Dec 08 2008 at 5:49 PM Rating: Good
***
2,069 posts
Dilbrt wrote:
Ailitardif, Star Breaker wrote:
Personally, I have found that Unholy has better survivability than Blood, but play what you enjoy the most.


It can have more survivability because of bone armor, but it has a major flaw in my opinion. It requires you to stand in desecration for the full damage. It seems like most raids I've done either require me to run in and out, or the tank to move the mob. I personally like the fact that it doesn't matter where I stand for blood. I do enjoy unholy as well, I hope they fix the 1 unholy per raid thing.


I rarely use bone armor outside of instances. I said it has more survivability because there have been times where I have been AoEing 8 mobs at once and killed them all with above 90% health (using deathstrike for heals). With blood and frost I would end with less then 20% health or dead in the same situation. Of course I spent about 95% of the time in unholy, so I know better how to use it.

I haven't raided yet, so I can't comment there...I'm sure that desecration is not as powerful in those situations due to how much movement is needed in the encounters. I will be speccing for whatever my guild needs at lvl 80 for raids, hopefully I can stay unholy, but if not I will just have to learn the other two specs (probably a good idea to do anyway).
____________________________
http://www.marriageissogay.com/

Song of the day:
May 26, 2011 -- Transplants
#16 Dec 08 2008 at 6:14 PM Rating: Good
*
76 posts
Quote:

To answer the question earlier I would like to dps and survive during leveling, then possibly move into a tank role.
However i do not really like the frost items much. It seems like the survival spec for hunters.
so i guess the question is..
1. If I go UH I loose some of the heeling ability's that i use all the time.
2. If I go Blood I loose by buddy and exploding bodies.
Is there a big benefit to the ghoul and CE? and will i do as much dps as blood?
Are the heeling parts in Blood worth it?
Or am i looking at the small picture of a few of the goodies in the trees?

DS


I understand what you were going for with your build. The thing you have to understand is most people at high levels turn into min/maxers. They go for 1 spec and make it the best(tanking,AOE or DPS) and your spec did none of that. Leveling wise(pure questing) your idea is fine. I have seen many people go 26 deep into unholy for the perma ghoul and then sink everything else into blood, and that works well for pure leveling. If you are raiding/tanking/spending every waking moment in instances, then that build is going to underperform. Your problem were the talents you chose. If you really really really wanted a perma ghoul and only planned to quest your way to 80, then I would go for something like this http://talent.mmo-champion.com/?deathknight=2305021533003313200230013000000000000000000000000000000230200305023113000100000000000&glyph=000000000000
You could get rid of aura and go hysteria and sudden doom if you like. That is more along the lines of what you wanted. But I will reiterate, this is not going to max your DPS nor is it going to max your AOE as you would still do better going full blood or unholy, but for questing and leveling up, it would work fine. You lose blood gorged and DRW but have gargoyle and a perma pet to add some dps, while keeping most core healing skills and mark of blood.
#17 Dec 09 2008 at 7:33 AM Rating: Good
36 posts
Well I re-specd last night and went mostly all unholy.
Before the respect I grabbed a team and went into Nexus and was #4 on dps and we had some issues with a couple of bosses.
I re-speced real quick and we went back in for a 2nd run. Wow what a difference.
I went from #4 to #1 on the dps and we smoked Nexus with no issues. I even tanked the last boss after the warrior croaked and we took her down.
Now yes I understand the Nexus is not the most powered up instance but it was one we had all ran before and knew all the boss fights.
I also managed to swap out a peace of haste gear so that’s cool, now i am down to one peace.
Thank you all for your advice!

Reply To Thread

Colors Smileys Quote OriginalQuote Checked Help

 

Recent Visitors: 187 All times are in CST
Anonymous Guests (187)