Forum Settings
       
Reply To Thread

Ok, what now?Follow

#1 Jul 15 2008 at 7:27 PM Rating: Decent
Hey all...

I posted a couple of weeks ago as to what i should do about gear & spec etc.

Well my gear has much improved since then http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sheet.xml?r=Alonsus&n=Tapole

I respecced to 40/0/21 from full frost and it is a world of difference in raids and instances. I've gone from non raiding a couple of weeks ago to clearing kara, 4 bosses in ZA & Gruul. I got rid of my frozen shadoweave set over the weekend and got my hands on whatever i could to replace it. Basically my plan was to switch to fire once i was shot of the gear. Well, i also tried that. And i can pretty much say it was a failure. I realize that my crit isn't high enough for fire and i do lose a lot of spell dmg from not having so many points in arcane. Well, dps was my problem. I went to SP straight after going 3/47/11 i immediately knew i was screwed. Throughout the whole instance, my dps averaged 650 - 700.

On the same instance with my arcane/frost and same gear, i get about 850 - 950 dps. Should there really be that big a difference with the same gear? Or am i just a fire noob? On trash i was just using fireball and on bosses x5 scorch/x1 fireball/repeat. I also tried 40/21/0 to boost my crit and spell dmg, but the dps was only marginally better. So can anyone tell me where i might be going wrong? My knowledge points me towards my low crit, which i'm trying to fix with more boj gear.

Am i on the right track, or should i give fire another go with my current gear?
#2 Jul 15 2008 at 9:19 PM Rating: Decent
29 posts
Hey Tapole

First of all then i see u need a lot better +hit the cap is 164 so u need to get gear that helps on that issue or gems. When u cap is 164 then go for +crit.

About gear i think u should look at this website i use it i know there are others but just use one of those then u are okay.[] http://www.maxdps.com/[/]

Hope that will help u :)

Trold
#3 Jul 15 2008 at 11:56 PM Rating: Excellent
Citizen's Arrest!
******
29,527 posts
Tapole wrote:
I respecced to 40/0/21 from full frost and it is a world of difference in raids and instances. I've gone from non raiding a couple of weeks ago to clearing kara, 4 bosses in ZA & Gruul. I got rid of my frozen shadoweave set over the weekend and got my hands on whatever i could to replace it. Basically my plan was to switch to fire once i was shot of the gear. Well, i also tried that. And i can pretty much say it was a failure. I realize that my crit isn't high enough for fire and i do lose a lot of spell dmg from not having so many points in arcane. Well, dps was my problem. I went to SP straight after going 3/47/11 i immediately knew i was screwed. Throughout the whole instance, my dps averaged 650 - 700.

On the same instance with my arcane/frost and same gear, i get about 850 - 950 dps. Should there really be that big a difference with the same gear? Or am i just a fire noob? On trash i was just using fireball and on bosses x5 scorch/x1 fireball/repeat. I also tried 40/21/0 to boost my crit and spell dmg, but the dps was only marginally better. So can anyone tell me where i might be going wrong? My knowledge points me towards my low crit, which i'm trying to fix with more boj gear.

Am i on the right track, or should i give fire another go with my current gear?


Odds are that part of it was lack of skill with the build(which I'm sure you can overcome with time) and another part is that fire is not a strong spec on trash mobs due to reliance on the Imp Scorch debuff and the tendency for ignites to be lost when mobs die too quickly.

Quote:
About gear i think u should look at this website i use it i know there are others but just use one of those then u are okay.[] http://www.maxdps.com/[/]


MaxDPS.com isn't bad, but without the knowledge to properly interpret the results it gives you, it can be confusing and lead you down the wrong paths. Especially where +hit is concerned.
#4 Jul 16 2008 at 2:01 AM Rating: Decent
Hey, sorry i forgot to mention, i normally have the scryer's bloodgem equipped. The armory always catches me with my riding crop. So normally my hit is 149. It was higher on fire, but since the frost cap is lower i think, i replaced some gems with more crit. Isn't the cap without elemental precision on, 202 on fire?

I don't really see what i could have done different on the build though. My dps was constantly bad, whether on trash mobs or boss fights. Unless i was getting a lot of resists, which i don't think i was.

I'll definitely give it another try though.
#5 Jul 16 2008 at 12:02 PM Rating: Good
**
428 posts
Tapole wrote:
On trash i was just using fireball and on bosses x5 scorch/x1 fireball/repeat

It may have been a typo, but 5x Scorch --> 1xFireball and repeat is a way too few Fireballs. I believe it's 5xScorch --> 7xFB --> 1xScorch and repeat, though you're not going to get through many rotations of that sequence on anything other than raid bosses.

Honestly, when I was Arc/Fire with crappy gear, I just spammed scorch on trash, though I believe the powers that be (read: Pol and Anobix) say Fireball spam is better.
#6 Jul 17 2008 at 9:43 AM Rating: Decent
*
131 posts
Tadpole wrote:

I respecced to 40/0/21 from full frost and it is a world of difference in raids and instances. I've gone from non raiding a couple of weeks ago to clearing kara, 4 bosses in ZA & Gruul. I got rid of my frozen shadoweave set over the weekend and got my hands on whatever i could to replace it. Basically my plan was to switch to fire once i was shot of the gear. Well, i also tried that. And i can pretty much say it was a failure. I realize that my crit isn't high enough for fire and i do lose a lot of spell dmg from not having so many points in arcane. Well, dps was my problem. I went to SP straight after going 3/47/11 i immediately knew i was screwed. Throughout the whole instance, my dps averaged 650 - 700.


My guess is that you are not used to the rotation (basically 5s then 7fb/1s)and how to manage your various cool downs. My gear is inferior to yours and I generally expect to see at least 900dps on the boss fights. I don't generally do close to that on trash, but my guild tracks only the boss fights separately so that is how I'm measured. But my boss dps can vary quite a bit. I need to be on my game, and not have to move around a lot. It is also critical that I use icy veins in conjunction with the blood gem and combustion at the appropriate times. Also if I know I'm going to need an evocation I plan the sequence so that its completed before the boss hits 20% health. Quartz and Scorchio will do wonders for your timing. I'd recommend that you use Dr. Boom to practice with the 3/47/11 spec and the addons for a bit and you'll see a huge improvement.

Edited, Jul 17th 2008 1:45pm by MrFredII
#7 Jul 17 2008 at 1:28 PM Rating: Decent
*
84 posts
Poldaran found the biggest reason why your dps would be lower. Fire strength is ingites and letting big nukes go off. On short fights this does not happen.
Trash and 5mans, though dps is important. Is not a good gauge of your dps. I didn't look at your armory, but i would stick with arca/frost until you have 164splhit, 800+spldmg and at least 25%crit. unbuffed.
#8 Jul 17 2008 at 6:10 PM Rating: Decent
**
920 posts
Quote:
I'd recommend that you use Dr. Boom to practice with the 3/47/11 spec and the addons for a bit and you'll see a huge improvement


MrFred, I thought the actual "raiding" spec was 2/48/11? That is what my mage has. If you interested in my mage and her gear its Magepain on Mannoroth. She is in her PvP gear and I have played her in awhile. Her PvE gear is nice. She is hit capped with 30% or so crit with molten armor on. Anyways, I'm going to start playing her again and was just curious what the difference is with the extra 1 point in arcane. Also, I'm curious why the OP's spec is 40/0/21. When I had lower spell damage I always went with the 40/21/0 for the bonus to spell damage via intellect and the Pyroblast. We all know that fire is currently the best raid dps for most boss fights. With the gear I have for PvE I know for a fact that my base spell damage is over 1.1k, but I also know that my dps is alot less. I did hit 8k multiple times on Gruul back in the day, but my dps wasn't as sustained it seemed as with fire. Like everyone said Tapole it isn't necessary to repeat scorches after one fireball they last for awhile. The only time I would renew scorch before it was less than half way to being gone is when Gruul shatters you, or something similar that way you can start dpsing right out of the down time.
____________________________
It's not that I'm so smart, it's just that I stay with problems longer. -Albert Einstein

Feyras, ****** Superhero wrote:
I think I'm going to sig myself, just to be different.


PSN tag: DavidChrist. If you add me, send me a message telling me who you are, please.
#9 Jul 17 2008 at 6:42 PM Rating: Decent
*
128 posts
A rule of thumb. In 5 man heroics expect that no matter your spec if you get a 3 pull per say, spamming AB's will be the highest dps NO MATTER YOUR SPEC. The reason being the low threat and the 1.5 second cast time and the mana needed for 3 trash mobs is minimal.

Where you should really be worried is a boss mob in kara, za, gruul ECT. Fire will do much better given no 2 piece t5.

So to answer you will going fire decrease your dps in 5 mans? YES.
Will going arcane decrease you dps on 2 man fights without 2 piece tier 5 AND proper group set up? YES

So bottom line, if all you do is 5 mans, go arcane.
If you want to do serious boss raids, embrace 2/47/11 ... (+1 somewhere) and learn it
#10 Jul 18 2008 at 4:33 AM Rating: Decent
*
131 posts
As already mentioned there is a "loose" point in the deep fire with icy veins spec that you can put any where. I generally put in it fire but if OP wants to put it in arcane its his choice. Right now until you get 2 pc T5 the highest sustained dps spec for boss fights is either 2/47/11 (+1) or 10/47/3 (+1). People who have mana consumption issues generally use the second but if you can maintain your mana the Icy Veins spec is best. Generally when we discuss raid specs we consider the mage in isolation. Obviously if you can PLAN on having a shadow priest and/or enhancement shammy you can pretty much ignore mana issues. In my last boss encounter I was with both and with Quag's eye procced and icy veins (roughly 36% spell haste) spamming a 2.1 sec fire ball I was barely dropping mana. Very sweet. To bad it was only for a few seconds...

As for minimums to use deep fire. This is more political than theory craft. If you are already an active raider in a guild that is successful taking down the bosses they tackle and you personally can get higher sustained dps on the boss with a hybrid spec and your class leader is fine with it, so be it. If you need to convince someone that you know what you are about, it is often easier to follow "conventional wisdom". Use deep fire and demonstrate that you know how to optimize your damage with it and you MAY find it easier to get a slot with a raiding guild. Initially, I used the Icy Veins spec with +550 spell damage and 79 Spell hit in Kara, and did just fine, and it was great practice for when I got my spell damage to 800.

#11 Jul 21 2008 at 2:43 AM Rating: Decent
28 posts
Disagree, you can go arcane before 2 piece t5, but in order to do it you have to commit to intellect. Here's my guy.

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-sheet.xml?r=Malfurion&n=Vuurbol

With a spec almost the same as yours I am able to achieve nearly 1300-1400 dps even on a long fight like Gruul or Mag's. The key is just keep stacking intell like its going out of style, pop potions and mana gems at every earliest opportunity, and know when to switch to frostbolts, (I usually do this at around 2k mana and I can spam them pretty much nonstop till my next gem/pot/evocate). With the spirit changes and fully raid buffed I have a mana regen that gets into the 500's so with mage armor on, over 300 while casting.

Thats just for raiding mind, for 5 mans forget about it, your golden. Arcane Power, Icy Veins, AB spam till IV runs out pop cold snap, IV again, any heroic boss is dead and you've just barely depleted your bar, because you've melted him so fast, maybe even just swallow a gem if your other dps's are slow or dead, I save pots for raids.
#12 Jul 21 2008 at 2:46 AM Rating: Decent
28 posts
Oh, btw not necessarily recommending this to the OP yet, might want a bit more intell on gear, and defenatly the Pendant of the Violet Eye first.
#13 Jul 21 2008 at 7:51 AM Rating: Decent
Thanks for the advice. I respecced to 3/47/11 and practiced on Dr. Boom for a while, doing x5 scorch & 7 FB. Yet even only when popping trinket/combustion, i was ever able to reach 800 dps. I tried loads of combinations but still i couldn't get my dps above 800 sustained. Then i went back and respecced arcane/frost and FB spammed Dr. Boom and was getting 980 - 1000+. So i really think i'll stick with this build for the time being, since no matter how hard i try on fire, i always get crap dps. My guild cleared ZA last night, and there was a fire mage who had considerably better gear than myself, yet i was still able to out dps him on boss fights and overall dps. So i don't think my guild will have a problem with my spec for the foreseeable future, but maybe when we get past maggy etc. At the moment i'm concentrating on building my crit though, since it will benefit my current build and for the future when i decide to try fire again.
#14 Jul 21 2008 at 8:24 AM Rating: Good
For having tailoring to 375 why aren't you using any of the good pve tailoring patterns (spellfire/frozen shadoweave)
#15 Jul 21 2008 at 3:33 PM Rating: Decent
*
128 posts
Zappington very nicely done. I would love to have my mage equipped there but thats a ton of badges. To the OP who is starting to raid, a spellfire/spellstrike set is much easier to get and they arent conducive to arcane because of the low INT.

The new badge gear is on par with Tier 5 (i think) so if you can get that kinda gear and go arcane, looks awesome. Wish I could I am so sick of fire.

#16 Jul 21 2008 at 4:08 PM Rating: Decent
Like i stated in my first post, i had the FSW set, but i wanted more flexibility. So i replaced it, and it's now sitting in the bank collecting dust. I don't see any reason to farm an assload of primal fires for a spellfire set, when the boj/mgt gear is on par if not better.
Reply To Thread

Colors Smileys Quote OriginalQuote Checked Help

 

Recent Visitors: 168 All times are in CST
Anonymous Guests (168)