Forum Settings
       
1 2 Next »
Reply To Thread

Got Badges?Follow

#27 Jul 15 2008 at 12:58 PM Rating: Good
**
676 posts
Since this post has started to get crazy I thought I'd jump in and do a little *CRIES*

I went resto to help out my guild (Yes I am GL so I took the hit) progress past Kara and into ZA

I have been spending all my badges on resto gear. (only thing I did get was Idol of Terror)
*CRIES AGAIN FOR EMPHASIS*

Edited, Jul 15th 2008 4:57pm by Galenmoon

Edited, Jul 15th 2008 4:58pm by Galenmoon
#28 Jul 15 2008 at 1:06 PM Rating: Excellent
**
817 posts
anonymosity wrote:
Downrated everyone who linked to wowhead when it wasn't necessary, you are all horrible people who deserve it....


Hear hear! And on the flip side, I hope I got an uprate for having no less than eleven floating alla links in a single post. : )
#29 Jul 15 2008 at 5:18 PM Rating: Default
FigaroBugs wrote:
Crit cap and armor are more easily replaced.


Really? Where is the def on our tiered gear? Where's the def on any leather above the clefthoof set outside of glad gear? No, def is the hardest stat for bears to stack throughout progression.

This is the EXACT issue that I'm experiencing now with 4-pc T4 moving into T5 content (our guild is skipping mags, so no T4 chest for me).
With:
350 base def SotF
20 res from Glyph of the Gladiator
26 res from glad chest (S1, but all 4 have the same res)
18 def from violet signet (VS of great protector is only gonna give 1 more def)
and
27 def from Earthwarden,
I would still be just under crit immune with Slikk's... Blade Turning puts me over.
Since I'm able to get back .56 of the dodge pre raid buffs through the +8 agi gem (which could eventually start being +10 agi gems if our guild gets far enough) that I get to use over the def or res gem I would need to use with Slikk's, it comes down to the 7 more stam and .94 more dodge (again, pre raid buffed) on Slikk's vs 168.1 more armor and increased crit, threat generation and dps... The choice is clear for a permanent hybrid tank like me.

It'll be even harder for me to stack def down the line if I have to give up the glad chest for set bonuses... I might have to give up Stalwart Protector for Ring of the Unyielding Force and STILL have to gem for the balance of crit immunity, but I haven't planned that far ahead yet since the drop gods are so fickle. With all that, I'm sure the extra def from Cloak of Blade turning will give me a little more breathing room.

That brings me back to my original point: Even though Slikk's is better in abstract, I'd STILL take Cloak of Blade Turning for the breathing room it gives me in crit immunity... The dodge and stam are simply easier to replace.

Edited, Jul 15th 2008 9:20pm by scrubmonkey
#30 Jul 15 2008 at 6:27 PM Rating: Default
**
355 posts
JeeBar wrote:
anonymosity wrote:
Downrated everyone who linked to wowhead when it wasn't necessary, you are all horrible people who deserve it....


Hear hear! And on the flip side, I hope I got an uprate for having no less than eleven floating alla links in a single post. : )


Now that you mention it, you do deserve something for that. Rate ups all around! Except those who linked to wowhead, of course. You know who you are.
#31 Jul 16 2008 at 8:51 AM Rating: Decent
Eh, am I supposed to care or something?
#32 Jul 16 2008 at 9:13 AM Rating: Decent
**
817 posts
scrubmonkey wrote:
Eh, am I supposed to care or something?

Lighten up, Francis. (that's from 'Stripes' for you youngins) It was a friendly albeit admittedly somewhat sharp-edged reminder that it is better/preferred to link to items here at Alla for our benefit because of the popup display, and because it supports the site/forum that you like enough to use. If you don't care, dont, but don't get all defensive and snippy because about that WE don't care. And if you want to keep linking to wowhead items just expect increasing amounts of grief that detract people from your very high quality posts as more people get more used to seeing/expecting Alla links instead of Wowhead links.

Back on topic because I can't stand subthreads that go ENTIRELY askew, I'd rather have Cloak of Blade turning than Slikk's Cloak too. When I said above that it wouldn't be replaced I guess I meant that under normal circumstances Slikk's Cloak wouldn't need to be replaced. I just meant that as a comment that it's a decent way to spend some badges. What do I know, I still have a total scrub cloak.
#33 Jul 17 2008 at 12:50 PM Rating: Good
JeeBar wrote:
scrubmonkey wrote:
Eh, am I supposed to care or something?

Lighten up, Francis. (that's from 'Stripes' for you youngins) It was a friendly albeit admittedly somewhat sharp-edged reminder that it is better/preferred to link to items here at Alla for our benefit because of the popup display, and because it supports the site/forum that you like enough to use. If you don't care, dont, but don't get all defensive and snippy because about that WE don't care. And if you want to keep linking to wowhead items just expect increasing amounts of grief that detract people from your very high quality posts as more people get more used to seeing/expecting Alla links instead of Wowhead links.

Back on topic because I can't stand subthreads that go ENTIRELY askew, I'd rather have Cloak of Blade turning than Slikk's Cloak too. When I said above that it wouldn't be replaced I guess I meant that under normal circumstances Slikk's Cloak wouldn't need to be replaced. I just meant that as a comment that it's a decent way to spend some badges. What do I know, I still have a total scrub cloak.


*shrug* I have no problem using Alla links, or with anything you said specifically, but 5+ posts of what's essentially nit-picking is more than a little dumb to me. As you said, I'm bringing conversation here and a bunch of people have no more to add then "I'm the HALL monitor around these parts, watch out, or I'll blow my WHISTLE!!!" Other than that, I really don't care about being downrated, or uprated for that matter. From what I've seen, getting scholar or sage doesn't seem to mean too much.

I agree, there's not a HUGE difference in the cloaks overall, I just went a different way because of DEF issues which get worse. I was talking to some feral tank buddies that are a lot further on in progression than my guild, and they were saying the same thing... And that the general answer back when they were at my lvl before there was za, easy glad gear was to get 2x chestpiece for the 3 sockets and gem 1 for dps and 1 for def... Since I would be competing with equally well-geared warrior tanks and priest healers for the tokens if I went that route (but, they're BOTH for my main spec, guys!) I could see the grief that my buddies had to go through...

Well, I guess if no one asside from JeeBar has anything useful to add, I guess I'm done here...
#34 Jul 18 2008 at 7:16 AM Rating: Good
***
1,888 posts
change some of your t4 by pvp gear. enchant your gear with some resillience. use some resilience/def gem. there you go.
really, I never ever had any dificult on been uncritable. Now I have t4 helm, merciless shoulder, vengefull chest, badge wrist, necklace of the deep, badge hand, natural something belt, t5 leg, 2 kara rings (rep and the other one), kael trinket and moroes trinket, earthwarden and idol of terror.
right now, im so high on uncrit, that I changed some of the enchants to dps enchants so I can have more threat.
Been uncrit as bear shouldnt be a problem. Actually, you even shouldnt be worried.
#35 Jul 18 2008 at 10:51 AM Rating: Decent
deleted



Edited, Aug 26th 2008 10:10pm by kawainui
#36 Jul 19 2008 at 4:14 PM Rating: Default
Brisin wrote:
change some of your t4 by pvp gear. enchant your gear with some resillience. use some resilience/def gem. there you go.
really, I never ever had any dificult on been uncritable. Now I have t4 helm, merciless shoulder, vengefull chest, badge wrist, necklace of the deep, badge hand, natural something belt, t5 leg, 2 kara rings (rep and the other one), kael trinket and moroes trinket, earthwarden and idol of terror.
right now, im so high on uncrit, that I changed some of the enchants to dps enchants so I can have more threat.
Been uncrit as bear shouldnt be a problem. Actually, you even shouldnt be worried.


I'd be reluctant to break up the 4pcT4 bonus for any glad gear less then vengeful or brutal, and those don't exactly drop out of trees... Otherwise, those look like they would be a pretty big upgrade, actually... I would be TOTALLY unwilling to give up the 2pcT4 and MASSIVE survivability upgrade of 2pcT5 combo down the line tho, so that would put me in the exact same situation that I am in now.

Y'know, I'll really have to think about getting the veng or brutal chestpiece anyways for pure dps/trash tanking purposes. A high dps piece with a socket bonus that I could actually use while not having to fight over drops sounds tasty, IF I can get the rating for them.

Edited, Jul 19th 2008 11:12pm by scrubmonkey
#37 Jul 22 2008 at 10:37 AM Rating: Good
***
1,888 posts
Quote:

4pcT4 bonus

Never had this and never had a problem with this. Really.

Quote:

2pcT5

Thats the one that gives you insta-heal? Thats totally useless, really. You think you will switch out from bear form during a boss fight? If your healers cant keep you up with their heals, something is wrong and this bonus wont give you any advantage. Actually, that bonus is kinda good for pvp, but for pve, its pretty useless.
#38 Jul 26 2008 at 10:03 AM Rating: Default
Brisin wrote:
Quote:

4pcT4 bonus

Never had this and never had a problem with this. Really.


Let's look at it a different way: Even without the 4-pc bonus, the S2 pieces are a sidegrade at best, and a downgrade at worst depending on the piece; I generally lose out on every stat except stamina. The 4-piece bonus just puts it over the top. The only reason I would consider S3/S4 is for the armor pen, which benifits my role as an OT.

Again, I've never suggested that the way I went about it is the ONLY way to do it, I'm simply demonstrating how I did it. In my build, Cloak of Blade Turning happens to be an important piece of gear to keep me from having to gem for crit immunity. Also, since I'm already crit immune now, I'm not worried about my current gear. It's the next level of progression that I'm worried about.

BTW, I thought that the set bonus for the glad gear didn't stack between season sets. Are you getting the +35 res from the 2-pc? If not, it would benifit you to get matching pieces for the bonus, it would mean that you wouldn't need to gem/enchant for crit immunity at ALL.

Brisin wrote:

Quote:

2pcT5

Thats the one that gives you insta-heal? Thats totally useless, really. You think you will switch out from bear form during a boss fight? If your healers cant keep you up with their heals, something is wrong and this bonus wont give you any advantage. Actually, that bonus is kinda good for pvp, but for pve, its pretty useless.


I'm guessing you've never used a cancelform macro? It allows you to instantly shift out of form, use a health pot, and shift back into bear between a boss's attacks. It takes a bit of skill to use correctly w/o eating an attack (and likely wiping the raid), but it's a pretty good increase in survivability when used properly.

The 2-pc T5 bonus USED to be useless before they changed nurturing instinct. Now, it's a bigger heal then a pot with a hot at the end without needing to wait for pot cooldown. How could I pass that up, especially if it leaves me with better PvE stats then if I went with glad pieces?

2-pc T4 is even more irreplaceable.

Again, Blizz is throwing bear druids so much easy gear at the end of TBC that it is EASY to gear a druid at our level, to the point where we have the option of skipping entire stages of progression... Due to the way we stack crit immunity and how we scale with our early gear, it's hard to gear incorrectly. It's only at T5 and beyond where it seems to go back to being tricky.

Edited, Jul 26th 2008 2:36pm by scrubmonkey
#39 Jul 26 2008 at 9:18 PM Rating: Good
**
817 posts
scrubmonkey wrote:
BTW, I thought that the set bonus for the glad gear didn't stack between season sets. Are you getting the +35 res from the 2-pc? If not, it would benifit you to get matching pieces for the bonus, it would mean that you wouldn't need to gem/enchant for crit immunity at ALL.

The set bonuses definitely kick in when you equip the appropriate number of pieces even if they're from different seasons. My set right now is S1 "Gladiator's" shoulders and hat, S2 "Merciless" vest, and S4 "Brutal" gloves. (gotta love that no rating thing) The only pieces that DO NOT contribute to the set bonuses are those from the so-called "Season 0.5" blue rep gear set, even though it's the same exact +35 resil and +15% speed boost bonuses.
#40 Jul 27 2008 at 1:42 PM Rating: Decent
***
1,888 posts
scrubmonkey wrote:
Brisin wrote:
Quote:

4pcT4 bonus

Never had this and never had a problem with this. Really.


Let's look at it a different way: Even without the 4-pc bonus, the S2 pieces are a sidegrade at best, and a downgrade at worst depending on the piece; I generally lose out on every stat except stamina. The 4-piece bonus just puts it over the top. The only reason I would consider S3/S4 is for the armor pen, which benifits my role as an OT.

Again, I've never suggested that the way I went about it is the ONLY way to do it, I'm simply demonstrating how I did it. In my build, Cloak of Blade Turning happens to be an important piece of gear to keep me from having to gem for crit immunity. Also, since I'm already crit immune now, I'm not worried about my current gear. It's the next level of progression that I'm worried about.

BTW, I thought that the set bonus for the glad gear didn't stack between season sets. Are you getting the +35 res from the 2-pc? If not, it would benifit you to get matching pieces for the bonus, it would mean that you wouldn't need to gem/enchant for crit immunity at ALL.

Brisin wrote:

Quote:

2pcT5

Thats the one that gives you insta-heal? Thats totally useless, really. You think you will switch out from bear form during a boss fight? If your healers cant keep you up with their heals, something is wrong and this bonus wont give you any advantage. Actually, that bonus is kinda good for pvp, but for pve, its pretty useless.


I'm guessing you've never used a cancelform macro? It allows you to instantly shift out of form, use a health pot, and shift back into bear between a boss's attacks. It takes a bit of skill to use correctly w/o eating an attack (and likely wiping the raid), but it's a pretty good increase in survivability when used properly.

Edited, Jul 26th 2008 2:36pm by scrubmonkey



Good luck trying to insta-shift using a spell in between. That's what i was talking about. Reread please.
#41 Jul 27 2008 at 2:17 PM Rating: Decent
plus you lose all your rage XD. thats never good
#42 Jul 27 2008 at 3:22 PM Rating: Good
The instant cast regrowth is fantastic. It is the 1.5 secs afterwards that you have to wait before shifting back to bear form that will cause you a little trouble :)

Pots & healthstones don't cause a global cooldown so they can be used and you are instantly back in bear form - spells are a whole different matter.
#43 Aug 10 2008 at 8:08 AM Rating: Default
RareBeast wrote:
The instant cast regrowth is fantastic. It is the 1.5 secs afterwards that you have to wait before shifting back to bear form that will cause you a little trouble :)

Pots & healthstones don't cause a global cooldown so they can be used and you are instantly back in bear form - spells are a whole different matter.


!!! Wow, you're right... I guess I always looked at regrowth after the cast time and assumed that it had no gcd, I never actually paid attention to when it was cast... Ah well, I guess I would still take T5 simply for the stats, since I'm not that great at arena...

I was thinking about taking some of the non-set S4 pieces to work on crit immunity, specifically Guardian's Dragonhide Bracers both for the easy rating and because it is an actual upgrade compared to the belt slot... The guardian's boots are an upgrade as well, but will be replaced in SSC. This way, I can work on getting a tiered chest of SOME sort and go for the non-rated S4 pieces, like the gloves. If the OP wanted to go that route, the S4 bracers could replace band of the swift paw, depending on whether or not 35 badges are harder to obtain than a 1575 rating on your server.
1 2 Next »
Reply To Thread

Colors Smileys Quote OriginalQuote Checked Help

 

Recent Visitors: 96 All times are in CST
Anonymous Guests (96)