Forum Settings
       
« Previous 1 2
Reply To Thread

Low kara dps?Follow

#1 Jun 27 2008 at 6:54 AM Rating: Decent
*
109 posts
Heya guys,

Long time since my last post anywhere on Alla, but was in kara last night on my hunter, and even though I topped damage on the run, my dps was only around 750. I thought i remembered my dps being up around 1k but i could be wrong. Here's a link to my armory page...

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-sheet.xml?r=Lothar&n=Triptan

I am survival spec and I'm spec'd a little more towards heroics and 10 man raids. I don't get a chance to really raid any 25 mans due to g/f... /sigh oh well. So I'm wondering whats wrong since I believe my gear to be good. I use a auto, arcane/multi, auto, steady, arcane/mutli rotation... or something like that, i copy'd it from the sticky i believe. Is that where my problem is? Should I go back to BM which I loved, but at the same time I love the utility of survival. I have Dorie's embrace along with 2 of Kal'thas's swords from heroic MgT in the bank, would the extra armor ignore help over what I've got? Would those 3 piece's be more for a BM spec? I'm getting the shattered sun neck piece in about 2 days and i'm almost up to 100 badges for the chest. Your help would be appreciated. ^.^

Triptan --- 70 sv hunter
Miirage --- 70 fire mage
Myrathat --- 70 holy priest
#2 Jun 27 2008 at 6:58 AM Rating: Decent
I didn't understand your shot rotation?
Is it macro'd? If so, post it :)

(you can find it in your WOW folder under World of Warcraft\WTF\Account\[account name]\macros-cache.txt)

Edited, Jun 27th 2008 11:02am by Kelnoen
#3 Jun 27 2008 at 8:03 AM Rating: Decent
**
797 posts
You seem to be geared primarily for PvP. You don't need 10K health for raiding.

As a survival hunter you should be using +agility gems instead of +attack power. You should do this regardless of PvE or PvP.

You're +hit is a little too high for PvE and way too high for PvP. 142 is the hit cap for PvE. 75 is plenty for PvP. Swap out some of the +hit gems for +agility. You want to be to be around +120 hit for PvE raids and 50ish for PvP. That way your drenai heroic presence will bring you up to around the cap.

Prince's bow deserves the +crit scope not a mere +10 white damage scope.

Change your leg armor to Nethercobra or Cobrahide You don't need the stamina bonus of the clefthide armor kit currently on your leggings for PvE raids.

Get the Scryer shoulder armor enchantment available at exalted.

Work on your Shattered Sun Offensive reputation so you can get a much better necklace. You're almost to exalted.

Consider the 3:2 shot rotation for that bow's speed. Aethian's gear list, stickied at the top of the forums, contains several shot rotation macros, including the e 3:2. Try out a couple of the shot rotations at Dr. Boom to find the best one for you.

Edited, Jun 27th 2008 11:25am by ItsaGaAs
#4 Jun 27 2008 at 11:08 AM Rating: Decent
*
109 posts
Thanks for the replies guys.

Not sure what you mean geared for pvp since I've only got 1 piece of pvp gear on. I plan on getting the badge chest within the next few days, I'm at 88 badges. I know prince's bow should have the crit, just got the pattern the other day and actually forgot that it needed it.

As for the gemming, since I'm replacing my chest I wasn't about to spend any gold on those gems and several of the other attack power gems are epic ones that I happend to get so I figured I'd use them. Not too much stam on my gems so my health is mostly from gear, I figured it didn't hurt. I know agi should be my main priority for gemming so I guess I'll replace the epic attack power ones for agi.

Now the leg enchant I choose for the agi, not the stam. I know the other one might give me more dps in other spec's, but the agi I though would be better for survival. Am I wrong?

Now with the new badge chest I think I'm going to be short on gems for my meta gem. Is there a replacement that I should look at getting? I know my engineering helm is pretty good, but is there something else that would be better for survival spec that has more agi maybe?

Here's my shot rotation now that I can copy it from in game...

/console Sound_EnableSFX 0
/castsequence reset=3/target !auto shot, steady shot
/castrandom arcane shot, multi-shot
/cast [exists,target=pettarget,nodead] kill command
/script UIErrorsFrame:Clear()
/console Sound_EnableSFX 1

Should I look at going back to BM considering my gear? Would Dorie's embrace and/or the two Kal'thas swords be worth equiping? Thanks guys for the replies.

Triptan
#5 Jun 27 2008 at 1:48 PM Rating: Decent
Unless you have 6 physical dps'ers on the raid, SV is usually wasted in 10-mans (I love MM and Surv Mechanics, ask Aethian, I am huge fan of them both, but at the same time I fully comprehend my role in 10 man's and that's to deliver dps), if you're concerned about dps, I recommend speccing BM, using the 3:2 macro if you have the mana to handle it, and use agi gems over any other.

In regards to pvp, it's just about the gear, it's also about the enhancement to your gear. Stacking stamina might help you in a BG or Arena, but in a 10-man you shouldn't be getting hit at all. Overstacking hit isn't going to help you at all.

#6 Jun 27 2008 at 2:01 PM Rating: Decent
***
1,519 posts
Whitegandalf wrote:

Now the leg enchant I choose for the agi, not the stam. I know the other one might give me more dps in other spec's, but the agi I though would be better for survival. Am I wrong?


Yes. You're going to contribute So much more DPS from having the AP/Crit from the cobrahide/nethercobra. Keep in mind that even though you're losing 10 Agi (which is 1.5 more AP for EW), you're going to gain 2-3 raw DPS from the AP, and more uptime for EW with the Crit rating.

Quote:

Now with the new badge chest I think I'm going to be short on gems for my meta gem. Is there a replacement that I should look at getting? I know my engineering helm is pretty good, but is there something else that would be better for survival spec that has more agi maybe?


You can achieve the meta gem bonus with as little as 4 gems: 2 orange/2 purple, or 2 red/2 green. If you put an orange gem in your new Chestpiece, and an purple gem in your boots, you will be able to keep that bonus. If you want to replace your helm, run some BGs and get the S2 helm- it has 37 agility on it. It's a really nice helm. I'm trying to get it to replace my Tier 4 helm.

Quote:

Here's my shot rotation now that I can copy it from in game...

/console Sound_EnableSFX 0
/castsequence reset=3/target !auto shot, steady shot
/castrandom arcane shot, multi-shot
/cast [exists,target=pettarget,nodead] kill command
/script UIErrorsFrame:Clear()
/console Sound_EnableSFX 1


Looks good. I'd just make sure to have a copy of that macro that does not have multi-shot for situations with lots of CC.

Quote:

Should I look at going back to BM considering my gear? Would Dorie's embrace and/or the two Kal'thas swords be worth equiping?


Are you talking about the Quickening Blades, or the Breeching comets? The blades... Probably not so great. The S3 axe that you have is really great for BM. If you want SV weapons, go with dual-wielding Breeching Comet would be a good choice.

In general, your Agility is too low, and your hit is WAY too high. As a Draenei SV hunter, you only need 78 hit (you have 3% hit from Surefooted, and 1% hit from heroic presence). My suggestion is that if you REALLY REALLY like survival, just go back to BM until you can replace all the pieces of gear you have that don't have agility (helm, necklace, melee weapon and ring).
#7 Jun 27 2008 at 5:00 PM Rating: Decent
*
109 posts
Ok guys, VERY helpfull. Will pretty much do what you said. I used to be BM and loved it so I don't mind going back to it. But when I was BM I was using just a 1:1 shot rotation and seemed to do just fine... auto, steady, auto, steady. Are you saying that my current shot rotation might work better? And yes I do have a copy that doesn't have multi in it.

I was talking about the quickening blades but pretty much they have the ignore armor so I was thinking they weren't worth it. Now should I swap back to my Dorie's embrace for BM or keep what I've got? Tomorrow morning I'll have a new neck and stupid curator won't drop Garona's ring so until he does, I'll keep what I've got. And I agree with the cobrahide armor so I'll get the last few mats up and have it made. Thanks again guys.

Triptan
#8 Jun 27 2008 at 5:47 PM Rating: Good
**
377 posts
Get a level 70 green ring of Agi. The one I have for survival is only very slightly less DPS than any of the Kara epic rings, assuming hit capped its only a couple of AP less and a very small amount of crit% less (less than .1% iirc) before taking into account the extra AP from EW and has far more agi.

Edited, Jun 27th 2008 9:48pm by Ieatrocks
#9 Jun 27 2008 at 8:47 PM Rating: Decent
***
1,519 posts
Ieatrocks wrote:
Get a level 70 green ring of Agi. The one I have for survival is only very slightly less DPS than any of the Kara epic rings, assuming hit capped its only a couple of AP less and a very small amount of crit% less (less than .1% iirc) before taking into account the extra AP from EW and has far more agi.


Or a Pathfinder's Band. I really wish that I hadn't gotten rid of mine. Now that I want to go back to Survival, and Hydross/Akama won't drop their rings, I really need it, but I can't find it on the AH.
#10 Jun 28 2008 at 9:07 PM Rating: Decent
*
51 posts
Quote:
Your +hit is a little too high for PvE and way too high for PvP. 142 is the hit cap for PvE. 75 is plenty for PvP. Swap out some of the +hit gems for +agility. You want to be to be around +120 hit for PvE raids and 50ish for PvP. That way your drenai heroic presence will bring you up to around the cap.


Doesn't Surefooted make the Hunter's hit cap 95?
#11 Jun 28 2008 at 9:50 PM Rating: Good
*****
10,601 posts
Krile wrote:
Quote:
Your +hit is a little too high for PvE and way too high for PvP. 142 is the hit cap for PvE. 75 is plenty for PvP. Swap out some of the +hit gems for +agility. You want to be to be around +120 hit for PvE raids and 50ish for PvP. That way your drenai heroic presence will bring you up to around the cap.


Doesn't Surefooted make the Hunter's hit cap 95?
He's a draenei.
____________________________
01001001 00100000 01001100 01001001 01001011 01000101 00100000 01000011 01000001 01001011 01000101
You'll always be stupid, you'll just be stupid with more information in your brain
Forum FAQ
#12 Jun 28 2008 at 10:37 PM Rating: Decent
*
51 posts
Nevermind, I got my answer.

Reason for edit: I need to L2Read before I post. /facepalm

Edited, Jun 29th 2008 3:29am by Krile
#13 Jun 30 2008 at 8:38 AM Rating: Decent
**
830 posts
I gotta respec to BM. I pull waaaaay too much aggro as MM in Kara. I upgraded my helm to S3 yesterday and now I can barely fire a half dozen shots before I get the Omen warning. I can't even FD fast enough. It's also killing my dps because I have to hold back due to aggro. I erased a 6K threat lead by our tank in seconds... oi!

Our BM hunter never has to FD (much of the dps threat is going on the pet and with growl off, it doesn't compete with the tank). So another feather in the BM cap for raiding is better aggro management. I noticed this point really isn't emphasized enough in the Raid debates.

No wonder why everyone says MM can't Raid... sheesh. Drove me nuts last night. I never realized just how much impact aggro has on dps until last night. Should come up with some kind of aggro standards chart rating tank vs. dps from hunters... my dps was yo-yo'ing all over the place. The dang 'locks were doing more consistent damage than I was (not better dps, just more consistent! The BM hunter and I swapped #1 around.)

I can't believe that just adding the helm really changed it that much... <sigh> My tooltip dps only went up by 5.

So, Raid = BM... no doubts now. How does SV mitigate the aggro? Faster FD cooldown?
#14 Jun 30 2008 at 8:48 AM Rating: Good
Just wait until you get further into the raiding scene, Sloshot. BM will outdps MM even if the MM had every threat reduction tool in the game on him. Threat generation is a very very small part of the reasons MM isn't a raidbuild anymore.
#15 Jun 30 2008 at 8:57 AM Rating: Decent
*
158 posts
Quote:
I gotta respec to BM. I pull waaaaay too much aggro as MM in Kara. I upgraded my helm to S3 yesterday and now I can barely fire a half dozen shots before I get the Omen warning. I can't even FD fast enough. It's also killing my dps because I have to hold back due to aggro. I erased a 6K threat lead by our tank in seconds... oi!

Our BM hunter never has to FD (much of the dps threat is going on the pet and with growl off, it doesn't compete with the tank). So another feather in the BM cap for raiding is better aggro management. I noticed this point really isn't emphasized enough in the Raid debates.

No wonder why everyone says MM can't Raid... sheesh. Drove me nuts last night. I never realized just how much impact aggro has on dps until last night. Should come up with some kind of aggro standards chart rating tank vs. dps from hunters... my dps was yo-yo'ing all over the place. The dang 'locks were doing more consistent damage than I was (not better dps, just more consistent! The BM hunter and I swapped #1 around.)


Firstly, the problem isn't MM being an agro magnet, the problem is your tank. Looking at your gear you really should not have any problem with agro with any tank who knows how to threat especially since you are a hunter with the BEST agro loss in the game. Also how does your BM hunter never have to FD? If he knows how to dps he should be doing more threat and dps than you (same gear level).

Secondly, dont post dps spots. From looking at your gear and being an MM hunter, I really doubt you get over 800 dps. Your spot in the raid just means everyone else is terrible.
#16 Jun 30 2008 at 10:25 AM Rating: Decent
*
184 posts
Progression does not equal terrible. Obviously the poster is progressing with like geared players which is a real challenge (I am there myself). I can pull aggro from a better geared tank with ease (feel free to look at my armory and call me a NOOB if it makes you feel good). Nothing wrong with being proud of #1, keep hunters there, it is good for our underappreciated class. Also, big crits seem to plague the MM hunter in my guild (can't get him to respec), a couple of big crits with the slower, higher damage weapon will pull aggro. BM damage is lower but quicker and steadier, therefore much easier to anticipate threat, IMO.

This does not change the fact that the smart guys have already figured out that BM is basically the only viable spec for Kara (assuming you want to maximize your contribution and are not playing the fun card). So respec and enjoy being the top DPS.
#17 Jun 30 2008 at 2:56 PM Rating: Good
**
830 posts
Oh, I never said the rest of the raiders were good, most are new to raiding, but we are working up and everyone is getting more gear. I was more surprised with the aggro difference.

I didn't expect my PvP MM build to last long but it's worked well enough through Chess. I new I was going to have to respec regardless but I was shocked at the aggro difference.

I've seen our BM hunter FD maybe twice or three times during a Raid. I am doing it almost every encounter, sometimes multiple times. A string of crits gets me into trouble in a hurry.

Recount doesn't give me my dps so I don't know what it is, I get the totals (with pet) though. I certainly am not up to what fully geared and equipped Hunters are. I just need to respec BM just to keep firing. Sadly, I'm not sure I will do well with BM until I learn it. I've never played the spec so this will be educational in other ways... ^_^

I have a long way to go yet. I just never thought I'd be forced to respec due to aggro issues.
#18 Jun 30 2008 at 9:49 PM Rating: Good
***
1,292 posts
Tugnus wrote:
Firstly, the problem isn't MM being an agro magnet, the problem is your tank. Looking at your gear you really should not have any problem with agro with any tank who knows how to threat especially since you are a hunter with the BEST agro loss in the game. Also how does your BM hunter never have to FD? If he knows how to dps he should be doing more threat and dps than you (same gear level).

Secondly, dont post dps spots. From looking at your gear and being an MM hunter, I really doubt you get over 800 dps. Your spot in the raid just means everyone else is terrible.

First, you don't appear to have read the post you quoted. The issue was not with having a poor tank, it was from having crits make Slo's damage bursty and inconsistent. Which makes some sense from having just upgraded to a piece of S3, although the true impact would depend greatly on the item being replaced.

Second, 800 DPS is excellent for Kara. 350 is a decent entry level, and progressing with your Guild through Kara you don't get to 800 until you're pretty much geared out. If Slo has 800 DPS that's another easy call for why aggro is a problem. If running with lesser geared (read: not "terrible", just lesser geared) players a Hunter can coast a bit and not have to chain guzzle Fel Mana pots to deliver respectable DPS in context with the rest of the raid.

And Slo, you can still deal a lot of DPS if you remember to open with a MD. Set up a MD macro so you don't even have to stop pew-pewing to fire the second MD after it cools down. And encourage that BM Hunter to rotate MDs with you, too. And of course FD is your friend, don't save it to avoid repair costs (I'm not saying you do), use it to help the raid not need to worry about repair cost inducing wipes.

Edited, Jul 1st 2008 1:50am by Kompera
#19 Jun 30 2008 at 10:12 PM Rating: Decent
*
158 posts
lol the problem for him is most likely the tank. My war with with just only a few heroic epics can easily pump out at least 800 tps which I really doubt his "crits" will cause much problems for. He's probably critting for like 1k multi's. A tank who knows how to actually tank should be able to hold his threat even with strings of crits and even a semi smart use of FD.

800 dps was a little bit of off for "terrible" dps but it isn't excellent. 350 average dps and dont get 800 dps until over geared in kara? Where the hell do you get that. I got 350 dps when my hunter was lvl 50 and I can get 700 dps with my 65 mage. Now since they did take out the keying from kara, people who are extremely undergeared do go into kara and push out crap dps. But anyone who actually did some heroics and got gear should be able to push out at LEAST 600 if they know there class rotation at all (and every dps class has an extremely simple rotation).
#20 Jul 01 2008 at 1:00 AM Rating: Good
**
377 posts
No. Slow has close to the same AP as me in survival and my multis crit for on average (according to recount from me running around doing my dailies) 1513. Add in raidbuffs and I'd imagine he's hitting for at least a couple hundred harder. 800 DPS from any DPS class in Kara is very respectable ( I didn't start breaking 1K until virtually full T4+ geared and 1:1 spam isn't (wasn't) difficult).

I suppose you missed the bit about the first half dozen shots in his post? There is no warrior or druid I've played with on the server (and I've run with tanks that are in T6) that I can't out TPS in the first several seconds of a fight especially if I get an unlukcy (or lucky?) string of crits. Equally geared tanks I'm not safe with until at least a second ( or third depending on the length of the fight) FD and that's including the use of misdirect. If you can't out TPS your tank either he way outgears you, or you fail as a DPS.

Use of FD does not remotely guarantee safety either. I've thrown my first flop, popped up, and been on the heels of the tank well before my FD was up again on many occasions (especially as survival, and I'd assume marks has this problem as well). With a string of crits I can easily be sitting at 9K threat in 6 seconds, and I seriously doubt any tank wearing, at best, Kara gear can touch that.
#21 Jul 01 2008 at 1:31 AM Rating: Decent
***
1,292 posts
Tugnus wrote:
800 dps was a little bit of off for "terrible" dps but it isn't excellent. 350 average dps and dont get 800 dps until over geared in kara? Where the hell do you get that. I got 350 dps when my hunter was lvl 50 and I can get 700 dps with my 65 mage. Now since they did take out the keying from kara, people who are extremely undergeared do go into kara and push out crap dps. But anyone who actually did some heroics and got gear should be able to push out at LEAST 600 if they know there class rotation at all (and every dps class has an extremely simple rotation).

lol right back at you. Kids are spoiled these days, what with the re-tuning of Heroics, the availability of T6 equivalent BoJ gear, and S3/4 PvP gear which is as good or better than some or all Kara drops. Back in my day, we had one source for gear prior to entering Kara: 5 man instances. Heroics were harder than Kara for the most part, you didn't get BoJ for Kara bosses, and the top rate BoJ gear didn't exist. And yes, 350 DPS was good, but then no one was chain quaffing Fel Mana pots because they cost a small fortune and there was no such thing as a daily quest to make everything affordable. I wrote the Hunter gearing guide for my Guild. Here's what I recommended:

Summary of raiding bars:
1500 RAP, unmodified by your Talents or self-buffs
79 Hit Rating
5500 Mana and 15MP/5
6500 Health

That was "step in the door" gearing levels, and you were expected to have better or to be swapped out after the first few fights for someone who had geared past that entry point.
#22 Jul 01 2008 at 2:16 AM Rating: Good
Kompera's right. Back in the Ye Olde days when Karazhan was actually considered a raid instance, we were mostly kitted out in various blues, sometimes cross-class blues even. Epics? You rarely saw one until you got yourself some gloves from Attumen and the Violet ring. When I look at what the new 70s face these days compared to what we did, I can't help but wonder how much of a shock they are going to get when they can't get free epics anymore.

When the bosses will trounce them because they haven't learned how to maximize their dps through skill and teamwork instead of relying on their basically free epics. When the high-end raiding guilds laugh at their applications because they are kitted out in PvP gear only instead of showing they know how to take down tactics bosses. When they have to farm Resist gear for the fun-fun dps gimped bosses.

Getting to 70 is easymode these days. Getting to full epic is almost as easy. Moving on to harder stuff? Blizzard's coddled the new 70s for so long most of them ain't going to be able to handle it. I actually saw a new Hunter complain about the Quel'danas dailies because it took so long. What? 30-40 minutes for around 75-100g? He also whined about how to get gear so he could get into raiding Karazhan. It was too hard and timeconsuming.

Now I'm working my way up to a nice frothing rage, nice. I'll just finish this rant now and go take out my anger on an unsuspecting wall in dire need of some paint. It will be the most violent layer of paint ever laid, fortunately it will also cover the bruises I'll inflict.
#23 Jul 01 2008 at 7:44 AM Rating: Good
**
830 posts
Kompera, yeah, you're right about the MD's. I've threatened a macro and really only use it on non-trash mob and better so I didn't need it. Switching out with the other hunter is a good idea. (I love little tips like that, anything to get better at the role)

I'm not embarassed by the damage I toss out. I have yet to 'wipe' the Raid (knock on wood) so I've saved a few of those for later. I know I am doing my job well enough but I've always viewed part of that job as not pulling aggro from the tank. Now that I am doing it after using all the aggro wipe tools I have and still doing it (after a stupid gear upgrade). So, of all the things I anticipated making me switch to BM, aggro was the lowest on the radar.

There is just an intertwining between aggro and dps I hadn't considered before, because as was pointed out, I can wipe it with an FD every 30 seconds. However, pulling aggro between CD's is bad!

I'm open to any other tips and tricks for Raiding. I do need to keep us hunters up on the 'desireable' list to bring along. ^_^ Thanks for the help guys.

(North: Alternate cold packs on those bruises, and buy a tub of spackle for that wall. It will likely need it.)
#24 Jul 02 2008 at 5:34 AM Rating: Good
**
377 posts
if you really wanna stay marks, wait until he has few K threat before you even MD (Or alternately have the other hunter MD first and just stand there till he's done). By the time it wears off you'll probably be ~12-15K behind (more quite possibly if the other hunter MD'd)and can safely dps for a while. If you can make it to the second Feign without significant problems you'll usually be golden. Just hit the deck whenever your CD is up after that.
#25 Jul 02 2008 at 7:48 AM Rating: Good
**
830 posts
Naw, the writing is on the wall for the spec. I knew it would be once I started Raiding. I stayed in PvP spec just to see how far I could take it and I've discovered that point. ^_^

So, time for BM, I'll do my SS dailies to start and rework my macros. Hopefully that will give me enough experience to start Raiding with the new spec. I'll let everyone know how it goes.

Any tips or tricks would be appreciated.
#26 Jul 02 2008 at 8:33 AM Rating: Decent
******
27,272 posts
depending on weaponspeed either get the 3:2 macro or the 1:1 macro and manually replace a steady with a multi when it's up.
And dont forget to pop BW alongside your trinkets and all that every 2 minutes.


That's about it I guess :P
« Previous 1 2
Reply To Thread

Colors Smileys Quote OriginalQuote Checked Help

 

Recent Visitors: 93 All times are in CST
Anonymous Guests (93)