Forum Settings
       
Reply To Thread

Improvments for a tanking druidFollow

#1 Jun 25 2008 at 7:51 PM Rating: Decent
*
97 posts
Hi everyone I need some help with my feral druid and gear to improve ext.

Basically its the summer now, no school yay, and I now have time to raid, do heroics, dailies and all that wonderful stuff. I realized that my gear is subpar to that of other tanking druids and I really should improve it so I can move up in the raiding world.

So I have two things

The first is my warcrafter sandbox with current gear ext. http://thunderlord-us.warcrafter.net/Charade
**The Cape should be the tanking cape from the new seasonal boss.....**

The second is my warcrafter sandbox of gear improvements from heroics only http://www.warcrafter.net/sandbox/78614

My questions are the following;
A) Are the planned changes enough assuming no raiding or badge gear (other then idol)?
B) Assuming the items I have changed do not drop on the first run, would adding the badge chest and staff be a good idea?
C) I realize that fully raid buffed with new gear I would have 26k health, 33k armor, 49% dodge, and 388ish defence rating. Should I use gem sockets to add def rating to 415 or w/e?
D) Are there any other changes to spec, gear, enchants, gems ext. that you would make?

-Charade

Here is my armory just incase http://www.wowarmory.com/character-sheet.xml?r=Thunderlord&n=Charade
#2 Jun 25 2008 at 8:45 PM Rating: Decent
***
1,239 posts
26k health?! I'm not sure the gear you listed there will actually get you that high. You sure you did your math right?
#3 Jun 26 2008 at 12:59 AM Rating: Good
**
817 posts
jeffoncom wrote:
26k health?! I'm not sure the gear you listed there will actually get you that high. You sure you did your math right?


I'm no math guy and the percentages get kinda wonky in my head, but self-buffed you're looking at the following.
You must be getting much better raid buffs than I get to hit the numbers you're talking about. : /
- Base armor of 5,271 puts in the neighborhood of mid-to-high 20s armor in bear form...jump of another 6-7k with raid buffs?
- Base HP of 12,000 plus the 20% stam boost of bear form puts you in the neighborhood of 15-16k -- jump of another 10,000 with raid buffs?
- Base dodge change of 31.53% puts you at 35.5% in bear form -- jump of another 15% with raid buffs?

That gear you have picked out looks fine except for the cloak. And the cloak off the summer seasonal boss isn't nearly as good as the cloak off Capacitus in normal or heroic mech, nor the cloak off Kael'thas in heroic MgT.

Emmerald's guide to pre-raid druidic tank gearing FTW.



Edited, Jun 26th 2008 2:02am by JeeBar
#4 Jun 26 2008 at 2:22 AM Rating: Excellent
37 posts
I agree, your numbers seem to be more than a bit off. Some of your gear choices also seem a bit off for what's just as available. Check the link posted above.

First thing, make sure you're def capped (through def, resil, or some combination) not too hard with options like the S1 helm to get you started. Also, as mentioned, there are many better suited cloaks such as the one in Mech, or the one in SP. Also the Cipher of Damnation quest gives you a better belt than primalstrike and a better wrist than either of your options. There are also high +armor rings such as the one in Ramps, and the one in MgT. Lastly...get your CE rep up so you can get earthwarden.
#5 Jun 26 2008 at 5:05 AM Rating: Decent
*
97 posts
Yeah my appologies on the 26k health, that was raid buffed with all the buffs.......my bad. I just updated the sandbox with the cape from MgT, and checked my health in Dire Bear with self buffs, along with exilers, and food. I have 19.4k, with 27k armor and 43% dodge, which seems a little high...and is Earthwarden really better then the staff I have from heroic Bot?
#6 Jun 26 2008 at 6:01 AM Rating: Decent
Hi,

Velkyri if you want to check gear to improve, try rawr b14.1.

It's a pretty usefull program, wich you can load your toon form armory and after try to swap gear to see the change.


Locklear (druid lvl 70)
Eredar
#7 Jun 26 2008 at 9:20 AM Rating: Good
**
817 posts
Velkyri wrote:
Yeah my appologies on the 26k health, that was raid buffed with all the buffs.......my bad. I just updated the sandbox with the cape from MgT, and checked my health in Dire Bear with self buffs, along with exilers, and food. I have 19.4k, with 27k armor and 43% dodge, which seems a little high.


Just so ya know, "we" typically talk about our bear form stats self-motw-buffed with no consumables. Eliminates the variables of which uberbuffs or elixirs you might have at any given time.



Velkyri wrote:
is Earthwarden really better then the staff I have from heroic Bot?

For raw survivability/tanking, yeah.
-> 1,000 more armor
-> 27 def rating make up for the loss of it when you upgrade from heavy clefthoof set
-> 24 expertise results in less misses

Feral Staff of Lashing is badass, though. Since it and has more crit/dodge and dps I'd personally use it for situations where maxing damage/threat becomes more of a problem than not dying. I have the ghetto equivalent of that choice: Braxxis Staff of Slumber for pure tanking, Staff of Natural Fury when damage/threat becomes more important or difficult than stayin alive.
#8 Jun 26 2008 at 9:43 AM Rating: Good
***
1,764 posts
Another vote for Rawr, whatever the current version is. (I think it's 14.1) Like JeeBar said, the basic druid benchmarks are with Mark of the Wild, no other buffs/elixirs/food/scrolls.

A) In a word, no. See below for an explanation.

B) The badge chest is a good investment once you can afford to lose the Def from Heavy Clefthoof. The badge staff is for DPS, you really want Earthwarden unless you're going to dump all your Stam gems for defense rating.

C) Defense rating/resil up to crit-immunity is your most important stat. After eliminating crits, Dodge, Armor, and Stam have different priority depending on who you ask. (I like armor, then stam and dodge about equal.)

D) Your gem/gear choices in the sandbox leave you vulnerable to crits, so get Steelweave (Def to cloak), Def to chest, and def to bracers. If that's not enough, start replacing green gems with yellow +8 def gems. You could also get the badge/kara tanking neck, Earthwarden, and one of the badge tanking rings. (I haven't looked at the Sunwell Isle one recently, so I don't remember if it's better than the one in Shat.)
#9 Jun 26 2008 at 10:46 AM Rating: Excellent
37 posts
I'd agree with the use of Rawr. It's very helpful, other lists such as Emmeralds can be useful, but Rawr does the best of comparing in relation to your other gear. Also from getting a general idea of what your starts are in bear with motw, I'd say your (in comparison to your other stats), that your armor is pretty low
#10 Jun 26 2008 at 7:17 PM Rating: Decent
*
97 posts
My armor is low? I was thinking more that my health was the area in need of help, along with well lets not lie here everything else...

Is 24k armor/29-31k armor low?
#11 Jun 26 2008 at 7:55 PM Rating: Good
**
817 posts
Velkyri wrote:
My armor is low? I was thinking more that my health was the area in need of help, along with well lets not lie here everything else...

Is 24k armor/29-31k armor low?


I'm entry level raider, just into Kara, and never done a 25-man, but how the heck do you plan on getting 5,000-7,000 extra armor from raid buffs?

You can see now why we compare self-buffed-no-consumable stats now...I recommend you post yours and the conversation will get back on track. They are probably comparing your 24k armor with the 19k health you supposedly have just self-buffed and downing some stambuff food. With 19k base health 24k armor would indeed be low.

Even accounting for the food, elixirs and scrolls, though the numbers you threw out of 19k hp, 27k armor and 43% dodge are way way WAY beyond what you should set as "next step" goals if you're just getting into heroics and Karazhan, and you're saying those are your CURRENT stats? Something continues to be squirrelly.
#12 Jun 27 2008 at 6:28 AM Rating: Decent
*
97 posts
Jee yeah my appologies for throwing out those quite large stat increase, they were with every buff imagenable in a 25 man, along with food buff, and self buffs which made the stats seem well impossible, which they probably are.

Last night I used rawr to see what the improvments would be but I could not need to get the health to update...I added in all the gear from heroics that I planned on getting along with earthwarden and the badge chest(more to see) but my health stayed at a constant 16,000 which got quite agrivating. Has anyone else had this problem or did I just miss the "update button" that sits in plain site?

Also I have raided before, MTed everything up to shade and illhoof. Gruuls I have OT both bosses and I MT any heroic I can get into....
#13 Jun 27 2008 at 6:42 AM Rating: Good
I'm not sure what change you have made in your gear but i realize one thing when i began to switch the old clefhood set with the new awsome badge one.

The clefhood with gem have plenty of stamina on it.The gear you may want to get dont have more but still be better, cause iy improve all your other stat armor, agi str etc...

I don't not if it's what you ask for but it's my 2c.

Locklear druid 70 (eradar)
#14 Jun 27 2008 at 6:45 AM Rating: Decent
*
97 posts
yeah I began to realize that, the gear I have currently has sockets galore, and the badge gear really doesn't...

As for changes, the warcrafter second link is what I'm going to get "in theory" are there any peices of gear I've missed out, skipping badge gear cause the chest is going to cost me a lot
#15 Jun 27 2008 at 7:11 AM Rating: Decent
I take a look on your choice of gear and my may suggest what i prefer.

bracers: If you dont mind doing some pvp the vindicator dragronhide can be a ittle bit better then the forest one since resilience help your for crit immunity, the gem can be usefull and they are not to hard to get.

back:the slikk's cloak of Placation cost only 35 badge i think and its the better back of the game.

Your other choice seems good. But if you can run heroic and kara get badge for the new chest pants and boots really whort it

Have fun in your gear improvement

Locklear (druid 70, eradar)
#16 Jun 27 2008 at 9:48 AM Rating: Decent
*
97 posts
cheers man, yeah I plan on getting the idol, then moving on to getting lots and lots of badges for the chest....and onwards if my other gear doesn;t drop...along with having to run many others for quests and rep for enchanting stuff......ug
#17 Jun 28 2008 at 2:01 AM Rating: Decent
***
1,970 posts
Pretty sure it wasn't mentioned but you will absolutely need to get a minimum of 415 defense. 388 would be too low because at 415 you become uncrittable. Just my two cents :)
#18 Jun 28 2008 at 11:23 AM Rating: Excellent
37 posts
Quote:
My armor is low? I was thinking more that my health was the area in need of help, along with well lets not lie here everything else...

Is 24k armor/29-31k armor low?


Comparatively yes. You can MT/primary OT T5 content with your health, but you're about 8K armor too low; due to druid mitigation normally you stack to armor cap at the HP you have.

Also, if you plan on doing heroics and 10-man's you will not have the luxury of all those buffs jacking up your stats. Again, your health is more than good enough for these, but your armor is at the bare minimum. Sure you have a good resource pool of hp's; however your healers will struggle to keep up with the incoming damage or run out of mana frequently with that low of mitigation
Reply To Thread

Colors Smileys Quote OriginalQuote Checked Help

 

Recent Visitors: 33 All times are in CST
Anonymous Guests (33)