Forum Settings
       
Reply To Thread

redesign SV talent tree.Some ideas!Follow

#1 Jun 03 2008 at 1:36 AM Rating: Sub-Default
Some ideas for redesign the SV talent tree.SO to be again fun to play.Also to be effective in PvP

1=improved wing clip, Change the immobilize with stun.It is only 20% of chance.So its logical to have a better cc if you hit.

2=counteratack. Same change the immobilize with stun.When you have little chance to use an ability at least if you are lucky and you can counterattack it would be something.(As warriors have mace stun)

3=wyvern sting.cooldown 1 min from 2.The 2 minutes cd its very long time for a sting that counts as poison.

4=improved feign death..useless stupid talent.change the change of the ability will be removed with this"when you are in feign death you are vulnerable for 2 sec in all attacks".Survival also in pvp.

5=Thrill of the hunt.Another useless ability.SV is about survival and not mana efficiency.At least make the 40% of regain mana cost to 100% when you crit.

6=master tactician=ok what is this?deep in SV tree we have a talent that reminds me the improved aspect of the hawk which is the first talent in BM tree.Remove it.Make a deep survival talent.Like 5 talents points when if you are under 20% of your health you take 10%(1/5), 20%(2/5)....50%(5/5)of your pet armor and health.We can call it whatever we like.Point of this talent?Survival hunter=hard to kill

Some ideas because i am boring at work!xe xe
#2 Jun 03 2008 at 3:28 AM Rating: Good
You obviously want the SV tree to be the new PvP tree. Why?
I really like SV for raiding atm, why change the tree so much? If you want to PvP spec MM.
The changes you propose won't help hunters in arena very much and are still somewhat overpowered (and useless at the same time). A hunter who has stuns in melee range?

I do not like your points 4, 5 and 6 at all.
While improved FD is not huge, it is a nice place to put your talent points in when you are specced for raids.
Thrill of the hunt is a very nice talent currently. Buffing it to 100% chance would be very overpowered (I'm at raid buffed 50% crit at the moment, this talent then would cut my mana consumption by 50% which is way to much for a meager three talent points).
And while master tactician is not a very strong talent as it is why nerf it with such a useless effect.
So if I get under 20% I get some armor and hit points? Useless in raids, useless in instances, nice in PvP but a bit overpowered as well.
#3 Jun 03 2008 at 4:32 AM Rating: Default
You have right probably.Dont take serious my proposals(most of them are for fun).But MM is not a pure pvp specc.We are force to use it cause hunters do drain mana games in arena. BM is better for most of the pvp situations.

But still its sound strange to me how a talent tree called survival its better for raids than pvp.Also it still second for raids(first is BM) so if there is only one hunter in raids the best solution is to be BM right? Besides what is the point to choose a talent tree for raids which most of his talents are useless in raids.Like all the melee talents(savage strikes,improved wing clip,deflection,deterrence,counterattack) and some others that most of the times you dont use it in raids(like hawk eye,entrapment,clever traps,improved feign death etc).
So you have 22 talent points that most of the times are useless in raids.And deep deep in SV tree you have "readiness" that the most you can take from this is rapid fire!!!!but you can spent only 2 talent point in rappid killing which is better!

Imo SV is not a pure raid tree.Dont have a problem to change it in raid tree.But then lets change also his name.Not anymore survival :)



#4 Jun 03 2008 at 7:44 AM Rating: Decent
*
203 posts
BM is only questionably better in 2v2's, and mostly against casters. Your BW is kinda nullified if you have 2 rogues beating you down. Sure they cant stun lock you, but all you can do is swing your pitifull melee weapon. Pet stun once a minute is ok, but only really usefull as a one time interupt.

MM is way better for pvp becaus of silencing shot and scatter shot, both on 30 second cooldowns, so you have a better way of interupting healers, and with the MM/SV build, is much easier to kite melee around than being the BM/MM build, plain and simple.

Sure, make counterattack a chance for a stun. Make deterrence trainable and make that slot improved counter attack. Wing clip is fine as it is really.
Thrill of the hunt is far from useless. Though I would rather them refund me, say 5% of my total mana on all crits, rather than 40% of base mana of special shots.

Master tactician already is a deep survival talent. It isnt that great, but nerfing it really would make it worthless and buffing it would make it op. Its the perfect crappy talent. Dont see how it reminds of you of aspect of the hawk, though.
#5 Jun 03 2008 at 8:31 AM Rating: Decent
**
438 posts
Mainly I would say that imp FD should remove debuffs like CloS or ice block, or pally bubble
#6 Jun 03 2008 at 9:01 AM Rating: Decent
You know after periods and commas you need a space....
#7 Jun 04 2008 at 2:59 AM Rating: Good
uzemaki wrote:
Thrill of the hunt is far from useless. Though I would rather them refund me, say 5% of my total mana on all crits, rather than 40% of base mana of special shots.


Wow, that would be overpowered :)

Just to give you an idea. Raid buffed I have currently 8.7k mana and a 50% crit rate.
Imagine every seconds steady shot would refund me 435 mana. In my standard 3:2 steady spam rotation that would give me ~700mp5 just by using steady shot.

40% of mana costs on a crit is a very solid amount of mana; and it scales rather well but does not make this talent overpowered.

@Doro
- SV is not a raiding spec because of readiness. It is a raiding spec because of +3%crit, +15%agi and most important of all Expose Weakness. And you still can have those nice 20 points in MM spec which yields another 5% crit, shorter rapid fire CD and 30% bonus damage on your crits (which is huge for SV hunter who will have > 40% crit raid buffed rather fast).
- And SV is a better raid spec then BM for one hunter in the raid (because of Expose Weakness). All other hunters should spec BM as this is the spec which does the most personal damage. This is being preached for > 1 year on this board. I'm suprised you did not know that until now.
Reply To Thread

Colors Smileys Quote OriginalQuote Checked Help

 

Recent Visitors: 173 All times are in CST
Anonymous Guests (173)