OMG! Not surprising then...
I took my hunter out of retirement yesterday. I want to make my rogue yet another leatherworker, and seeing how leather prices are totally insane on my server now, I decided that I needed a skinner to make it possible. Mining always interfered with my tracking, and jewelcrafting works well enough without mining yourself, so the hunter had to relearn.
To give this whole hunter thing somewhat of a fresh start, I went and tamed one of the druids dire ravens in BEM. I then went up to Netherstorm to gather my (almost) daily 20 Zaxxis insignias, and while doing so, the bird's loyalty went up to 2.
Then came the skinning training, and since then... nothing. All the way from 1 to 285, and no more loyalty gain. 5+ hours of grinding Winterspring yetis then - nothing. Well, almost nothing since intervals between feeding have become shorter and shorter, to the point that the bird is now stabled since it sucks having to feed all the time when the meat drops are too low in level.
This entire time in my career as a hunter I was under the impression that loyalty was just a matter of time ONLY. Thinking about it now, how could I assume anything different being that you usually only kill mobs that either give or would give xp?
Guess I might as well get the bird out of the stable again then and deal with his appetite for the few more hours of low-level skinning I need before I can go straight to Nagrand to start the Knothide grind. After all, my skinning skill went up to like 373 on just the yetis.
Wish I had read this thread earlier...
On another note, screech and dive are awesome. It's actually big fun to round up 3 yetis and multi-shot them without drawing aggro most of the time - despite hitting them hard. Just have to turn off the sound or else I'd go nuts. Think I found a new permanent farming pet.