Losie wrote:
Suneater is a great weapon to swap in after you already have an incredible threat-lead. In serious raiding that wont really happen -- but in heroics, Kara, and even ZA it's not too difficult to end up with 50k more threat than the next person on the list.
Still -- The Cudgel of Consecration is awesome unless you're clearing ZA or Hyjal often. It's the first epic that's REALLY useful to a Paladin tank.
This: but then, if you're doing Heroics/Kara/ZA, are you even going to need the extra mitigation from the Suneater? Kind of makes it a moot point.
That Cudgel definitely is awesome. I wish I had it longer cause it looks wicked too, but very shortly after getting it, I got the Hyjal trash mace (which imo looks stupid) =/
Anyway, point is, Warrior tank weapons =/= Paly tank weapons, so sell the Suneater and use the money to buy a Continuum or Crystalforged. Whatever you do though +40 spell damage enchant is the only way to go.