Forum Settings
       
« Previous 1 2
Reply To Thread

Again Blizzard Screws Me....first warriors ..now Shamans !Follow

#1 Apr 15 2008 at 6:42 AM Rating: Default
Over two years ago I rolled a warrior to the level 60 cap. Then the massive pvp urge kicked in and I quickly became frustrated on how useless warriors were in general none arena/organized pvp...just out about questing and getting jumped. I quickly became tired of trying to close the gap on mages after my one and only useless 1 second effect of hamstring wore off. Watch the mage freeze me in place and then blink and toast me in two shots. If it wasnt that then it was priests ...fear...pain...fear...blah blah blah. Warriors had no way of getting close..intercept and charge were useless if you didnt get the jump first. So did I whine or complain? No...I did the easiest thing. I quit.

Two years hiatus I come back and get the expansion and horray! Shamans on the alliance side! I quickly start the mad rush to hit 70 before the 2nd expansion is released. Oh wait...something is wrong....shamans suck at pvp too??? Great, the shaman does the DPS a Warrior does...but as enhanced spec I still cant get near anyone and still get toasted like im naked running around swinging a toothpick? I mean seriouisly, my buddy has a mage the same level as me (65 right now) and He can freeze me and blast me for 2200 a pop and if im lucky and can get close enough to him after freezing me and blink i might be able to hit him 6-8 times to kill him? Oh wait ...my mail armor will save me right? lol......please...might as well be naked drinking ale at the Inn and let myself get mauled by a elwynn forrest boar.

I hate whining but...this is horrible. As enhanced spec shaman..I cant do elemental damage because im spec'd enh for dps. Ok fine..that was my choice to spec enhancement. I cant get close enough to anyone to kill them and meanwhile they cut through me like a hot knife through butter. Ok fine! Cant beat em? join them. I re-spec to elemental spec....worse! I now can do more damage from a distance the problem is now I have no CC to keep them in place to do the damage? Everyone says "use the frost spell to slow them down" lol..please..it slows them down...they still close the gap..they dont stop moving. Most of the time it doesnt even stick....this is starting to be another waste of time.

I read a good article that said it the best: Shamans great at alot of things..masters at none. Couldnt say it better myself.


HELP BLIZZARD !!

I give up...I hear Conan and Warhammer will give shammy's love..I hope.
#2 Apr 15 2008 at 7:00 AM Rating: Good
***
2,069 posts
This belongs here!
____________________________
http://www.marriageissogay.com/

Song of the day:
May 26, 2011 -- Transplants
#3 Apr 15 2008 at 7:36 AM Rating: Decent
#4 Apr 15 2008 at 8:52 AM Rating: Good
**
569 posts
Quote:
I specced the worst PVP spec shamans have and do badly at PVP! /cry


Shamans aren't like Warriors. We own it up pretty well in non-organized BGs, but aren't particularly good in organized PVP. Personally as elemental I lead damage in the majority of BGs I enter unless the enemy consistently focus fires me first. As resto I'd be a pretty solid healer (particularly with insta-GW being an option now)

Enhancement is bad for PVP. Basically either of the other two melee-centric classes (Warrior/Rogue) have far better abilities for closing the distance and staying there. Given Blizzard's track record, it'll likely be a very long time (or at least til WOTLK) until this is addressed. Don't spec a bad PVP spec if you want to PVP.
#5 Apr 15 2008 at 10:38 AM Rating: Default
Yea, im finding this to be very true. Organized pvp'er I am not...dont really have a interest in hard core pvp...but when I get jumped by someone at should at least have a fighting or equal chance to survive. Also...I would love to have an AOE or a stun? I mean my aoe is a nova totem ..that I actually have to physically hit each target prior to setting the totem down. If I dont hit the totem then one mob reaches over and blows it out like a candle..meanwhile 5 mobs are beating on me. stun? forget about it...I mean mages get a stun on some spells, warriors get charge, rogues stun, hell even pallys get stun. why dont shamans get plate? I mean every melee class gets plate except shammys?

Ok if your elemental spec I dont think you should get plate..your not up melee style...but they should revamp that if your enhance spec you should get a talent point for plate...elemental should stay mail. dont want a plated caster rolling around indestructible :) But overall...im sad...I was really pumped to play. PVE we are a sought after class....to bad blizz doesnt care enough to keep customers.
#6 Apr 15 2008 at 12:47 PM Rating: Good
**
569 posts
Every melee class doesn't get plate. Rogues and Feral Druids don't get it.

Shamans don't need it. They clearly need some improvements to make the spec work, and Plate would be an improvement, but there are far better solutions than just tacking Plate onto the spec. While Plate would have the neat side benefit of letting Enh Shamans use fury warrior gear, it seems like a change that would make shamans more like existing classes (bad) without addressing the underlying issue.

It'd be better to give shamans something unique and different which helps address their weaknesses or strengthen their strengths. The trick is to make the changes primarily affect PVP, as in PVE we're a fairly strong class imo.
#7 Apr 15 2008 at 1:46 PM Rating: Excellent
***
3,339 posts
SCONN wrote:
why dont shamans get plate?


What's plate going to do to mitigate your mage friend's spell damage again?
#8 Apr 15 2008 at 2:19 PM Rating: Excellent
***
2,590 posts
Quote:
Again Blizzard Screws Me...


And the worst part is, they never even want to cuddle afterwards. :(


Shamans are definitely not the best class for PvP, but I wouldn't say playing Shaman makes you instantly bad at PvP, it still depends on the player--it's just more of a challenge. Personally, I'm pretty bad at PvP, and I tend to stay away from it if at all possible--there are things I can do, though, when it's group vs group, that I really couldn't do as any other class. Earth Shield, Windfury totem, chain heal, spam more heals on the pally, drop some mana totems, frost shock the runners--sure, on my own I get clobbered (even by other shammies), but with a group, if the others can keep the Allies occupied, then there are so many things I can do in a support role, it's really amazing. Gotta love when the mage that blinks away from the melee finds himself getting a lightning bolt in the back. :)

I guess what I'm trying to say is--it's not all the class or even the spec. Part of the problem may be your approach to it, or the fact that Shamans really don't seem to be cut out for 1v1 PvP at all. If you're getting ganked a lot, maybe try questing with a group?

#9 Apr 15 2008 at 3:08 PM Rating: Decent
Well, truth is, I started a forum awhile back just on this subject, and it went 4 or 5 pages. You can beat almost any class as long as you pay attention to anything cept for demon spec'd locks and believe it or not, prot tauren warriors (just too many interrupts and counters) Our biggest advantage is being able to get one of those spells off even after they cancel one. The trick is getting geared. As of right now, I'm using alot of haste gear as elemental and my LB hits for bout 1600-3600 with a crit rate of 34%. you just simply have to kill them before they kill you. Now dont get me wrong though, we are still very much screwed over compared to other classes.
#10 Apr 15 2008 at 11:43 PM Rating: Decent
*****
13,048 posts
I love how Shamans whine about sucking in PvP when they're pretty much the most desired class for 5v5.

I have a Duelist Holy Paladin rerolling right now to level an Elemental Shaman to 70 for S4. Ele Shamans are that good.

Edit: of course, if you suck at PvP, you suck at PvP and no one will want you on their team. It's not the class' fault, though.

Edited, Apr 16th 2008 12:44am by Theophany
#11 Apr 16 2008 at 12:40 AM Rating: Decent
**
514 posts
In my opinion, Ele shamans CAN be useful in 5v5s. ***Provided you are geared***

Due to the fact that we have no CC or counter CC and we deal so much burst damage, when fighting against a competent team, they WILL target us 1st and kill us off, becoz we are easy to kill, and we are dangerous to be left alone.

But this changes once we have enough resilience. We can last longer and thus soak some damage. This enables our teammates in 5v5 to do some serious damage to our opponents when they have heroism buff. And if we survive long enough, those with 4 piece Glad gear have a good chance to throw out at least one 100% Crit Chain Lightning.

If any team leave the shaman alone, they are asking for trouble, lol.

I came to the above conclusion from my experience in arena at various stages of gearing up. The KEY is SURVIVING long enough to make that one useful shot.

Also, surviving long enough also means that your totems have a chance to make a difference.

Having said all that, I haven't been to the higher brackets of Arena so I can't say whether the above is still true there. But I was told that Ele Shamans are an important component in some high ranking teams.
#12 Apr 16 2008 at 8:40 AM Rating: Default
Again...the last four posts...your missing the point of my original post. I am not talking about 5 vs. 5 and the role of shaman and if they can do that type of pvp. Hell, anyone can pvp in 5 vs. 5 and have a role to play.

I am talking about when I am out by myself..or even with others...how do I SURVIVE? Posting totems and healing pallys doesnt keep me from dying. Im talking one on one ..or 2 vs 2 everyday questing attacks from the opposition. Justifying that if I gear Tier 1000th epic gear and spec this or that for that situation isnt an answer. The bottom line is shammys are dead in the water if you have to save yourself. Granted...no argument here from a group stand point if your "assisting" others in surviving pvp...but as far as you saving your own skin....its usually not an option. I do what damage I can and then die. I didnt make this character to pvp and I understand that issue...its not the ideal if I WANT TO PVP...but sometimes PVP COMES TO YOU! Now, whether I want it or not isnt the issue. Im on a pvp server and I get attacked..I just want a chance to survive...thats all. Is that too much to ask?

Quick question....off subject...can resto spec'd shammys do enough damage to survive in melee? or as elmental?
#13 Apr 16 2008 at 8:48 AM Rating: Good
***
2,069 posts
Overlord Theophany wrote:
I love how Shamans whine about sucking in PvP when they're pretty much the most desired class for 5v5.

I have a Duelist Holy Paladin rerolling right now to level an Elemental Shaman to 70 for S4. Ele Shamans are that good.

Edit: of course, if you suck at PvP, you suck at PvP and no one will want you on their team. It's not the class' fault, though.

Edited, Apr 16th 2008 12:44am by Theophany


I'm in the camp of those that don't complain about the pvp abilities of my shaman because I don't pvp. I'm not good at it and pvp sucks if you suck at it. I shine in pve and I'm happy for that.
____________________________
http://www.marriageissogay.com/

Song of the day:
May 26, 2011 -- Transplants
#14 Apr 17 2008 at 2:07 AM Rating: Decent
**
514 posts
LOL, SCNONN, if I get jumped in world PVP...... I usually just let them kill me fast. Then I logout and play another toon.

Yes, it's that bad. People who jump u are usually prepared geared to the teeth, normally we don't stand much of a chance, even to run away.

Sounds pathetic? Yes, but... I don't know what else can I do about it.

Any other shamans out there with feasible recomendations?
#15 Apr 17 2008 at 12:22 PM Rating: Decent
**
782 posts
Quote:
Quick question....off subject...can resto spec'd shammys do enough damage to survive in melee? or as elmental?


Situationally sorta.

Dmg and "Resto" shaman are oxymorons, first of all. Resto shaman's are sorta like Pally's. Big on survival, low on dmg. So typical fights with a Resto shaman, goes something like (Hopefully start at distance) Earth shield up, LIghtning bolt (til in shock range), Flame shock, Searing totem, and from there on its healing and throwing out a appropreate shock for the situation. Either way to cut it....expect a long drawn out fight (assuming you have the MP to go the distance).

Resto's bank on the hopes that they can weather the onslaught long enough for their "little" dmg to wear someone to death.

Elementals bank on the hopes that their LB's, CL's, and shocks will kill their target before they get into melee range on them.

Enhancement bank on the hopes that they can get into melee range (and STAY THERE)and a SS and/or WF will crit.

As far as the likeliness of "strategy's" playing out the way I mentioned it above, I'd say I put it in proper order.

Course in the BIG picture compared to ALL other classes in PvP, we generally suck. Even the Resto's gameplan has TONS of holes in it, and there's nothing "we" as players can do about it, til Blizz get's their heads outta their naughty hole.
#16 Apr 28 2008 at 3:59 PM Rating: Decent
***
1,162 posts
Quote:
I didnt make this character to pvp and I understand that issue...its not the ideal if I WANT TO PVP...but sometimes PVP COMES TO YOU! Now, whether I want it or not isnt the issue. Im on a pvp server and I get attacked..I just want a chance to survive...thats all. Is that too much to ask?



There's no class balance in world PvP

No matter which class you play if the other player gets the drop on you and he knows what he's doing, you are done. Fair 1v1 world PvP is a myth. You get attacked by players 30 lvl higher or when fighting a mob or drinking... it's not fair but that's the way it is.

You might want to think about rolling PvE cause you'll never get a chance to "survive" in world PvP. You attack first and fight dirty or you die.

Edited, Apr 28th 2008 7:59pm by feelz
#17 Apr 28 2008 at 11:22 PM Rating: Decent
*
210 posts
sounds like you need to learn to use all that you've got, i perfer enh for pvp over elem because once im known/targeted im screwed, theirs a ton of ways to shut me down.. so i pvp enhancement and really have no problems with any class other then warriors and rogues.

i don't know how you play but all other classes are basically easy/free kills.

friends of the enh shaman: grounding totem, earth shock, PURGE<<big one there and instant ghostwolf.

mage freezes you purge him twice, drop a grounding totem somewhere in there earthshock or if novas about to break frost instant wolf drop earthbind then rape the *****.

honestly your best friend is purge, you can make some classes basically a free kill by throwing a few purges, key thing if theirs a druid and say its wsg he has flag purge purge purge frost shock wolf earth bind frost purge he'll die fast with no HoTs.

another thing don't get suckered into a kite mage freezes you and starts running around expecting you to chase.. ghostwolf and run the other way.. close the distants on your grounds not his.

warlock?? purge purge tremor grounding night night lock, tries to kite ^do as above suggests with a mage, do it with a hunter too.. attack when you want to attack don't be suckered into a fight to close the gap.. let them come to you then.. mouse turn bam your in their lap. (in ghostwolf of course)

hunters will either frost/freeze trap or scatter you see it coming frost shock earth bind so he can't get away then finish him.

really don't get the QQing i love pvp as enhancement its so much easier, its really the ppl under plate your after and thats what your great at other then rogues cause the stuns. elemental will eat plate classes tho.
#18 Apr 29 2008 at 2:37 PM Rating: Good
****
5,729 posts
Quote:
I didnt make this character to pvp and I understand that issue...its not the ideal if I WANT TO PVP...but sometimes PVP COMES TO YOU! Now, whether I want it or not isnt the issue. Im on a pvp server and I get attacked..I just want a chance to survive...thats all. Is that too much to ask?

Yes, actually. It is too much to ask.

World PVP revolves mostly around ambushes. In world PVP the defender loses almost every time no matter what class/spec they are because the aggressor usually waits until the odds are significantly in their favor before attacking. Class balance is meaningless and pretty much non-existent world PVP.
____________________________
75 Rabbit/75 Sheep/75 Coeurl/75 Eft/75 Raptor/75 Hippogryph/75 Puk
75 Scorpion/75 Wamoura/75 Pixie/75 Peiste/64 Sabotender
51 Bird/41 Mandragora/40 Bee/37 Crawler/37 Bat

Items no one cares about: O
Missions no one cares about: O
Crafts no one cares about: O
#19 Apr 29 2008 at 2:54 PM Rating: Decent
**
842 posts
SCONN wrote:
I am not talking about 5 vs. 5 and the role of shaman and if they can do that type of pvp.


too bad blizz based class balance on 5v5 arena, not 1v1 encounters. reroll a rogue, play more in BG's and 5v5's, or QQ moar, your choice.
#20 Apr 30 2008 at 3:56 AM Rating: Good
*
134 posts
If you hate organised pvp and getting jumped then just lvl to 70 and do pve. rest assured enh shammies do just fine at pve content.
#21 Apr 30 2008 at 4:52 AM Rating: Decent
I spent about a year leveling my Shaman and dealing with the identity crisis that is the "Utility Class Shaman" before I finally found my niche as an Enhancement Raiding Shaman. During that time, I tried BG, Arena, and ganking the unfortunate horde players to walk around flagged. I figured out a few things: if I want bigger numbers and flash, Elemental was the way to go. If I wanted to actually be brought into 5 man runs (due to the common ignorance of the majority of the player base), I had to go Resto. Finally, after 2.4, I decided to try out Enhancement. As I have a 70 Resto Druid, I was never allowed to bring my Shaman on guild raids because we're always hurting for healers. I ended up answering a /whisper from a guy looking for an enhancement shaman for Karazhan. In my two months of running with this other guild for Karazhan raids, I've seen that, while me may be "lacking" in the PvP department, we can really excel in PvE. I'm not always top of the DPS chart, but I'm up there in the top 2 or 3 every run. And it's not just the numbers I can put out, it's the chain heals, chain lightening, AoE fire totems, and every other buff that my totems bring to the party that just add icing to the cake. I have not even bothered trying to find an arena team this season for my shaman, my time now is focused on Gruul's, Mag's, Kara, and planning where I want to go next. I think that being able to be "Top Dog" with an underdog class is a blast. Maybe one day the Dieties that are Blizzard will actually "fix" Shaman PvP, but until then, I know I have a full plate seeing the materials they have placed in front of me now.
#22 Apr 30 2008 at 10:50 AM Rating: Decent
Thanks for the comments alot of great feedback here. thanks for your opinons and honesty.

again im no pvp expert..but alot of good information here to increase my survivabilty.

I was orginally a enhancement shammy and recently have switched to elemental spec and for the most part my survivability has gone through the roof !

also I will also confirm I have never disputed our need in PVE. I believe every group should have tank, healer, shammy, mage..last one should be a filler.

shammies are the bomb in PVE..always will be.

As far as pvp I will continue to research new ways to stay alive...and take a few chumps with me :)

I especially like the info regarding purge..if anyone can elaborate what exactly purge does and how it benefits me I would greatly appreciate this..as I have never utilized purge in pvp.

thanks!

Edited, Apr 30th 2008 2:52pm by SCONN
#23 Apr 30 2008 at 11:07 AM Rating: Good
**
861 posts
Purge often = win in PvP.

A pally runs up to you to start smacking you around? Purge his auras, blessings and judgments. All he can do now is white damage. Lets say s/he tries to grab flag in wsg and run with BoF, making them immune to snares. Purge it and frost shock.

A frost mage shows up and frost nova's you? Purge his ice barrier, frost armor and AI while letting your grounding totem eat the fb. Now he's got no protection you effectively drained his mana. And the nova is just about to break.

Taking on a priest? Purge away. You probably just removed thousands of pts of armor by purging Inner Fire and hundreds of health by purging PW:F. Maybe you can purge Renew, too.

A druid just dropped a bunch of hots on him/herself or a teammate? Purge em. No more heals (But be careful not to purge lifebloom, that'll trigger a big burst heal.)


Unkillable resto shammy giving you trouble? Purge that earth shield and two-shot him.

Note that some talents make buffs harder to purge, so it's not guaranteed you'll take out a disc priest's buffs by purging, for example. But purge can be a terrific weapon.

Edit: PS, if you're not clear on what purge does, it basically dispels two beneficial spell effects from the target. And there's no cd, you can spam it, though it does cost mana, not something that shamans often have a big supply of.

Edited, Apr 30th 2008 3:11pm by tuskerdu
#24 Apr 30 2008 at 12:09 PM Rating: Default
See the problem with that is... if you spam purge, you aren't doing any damage.
#25 Apr 30 2008 at 12:57 PM Rating: Good
**
861 posts
Spamming purge usually isnt great but Shamans have more GCDs to play with than some other classes. As an enhancer, much of my damage comes from auto-attack. I can shock every 6 secs and ss every 10. Thats about it. If my totems are already down I have lots of purge opportunities. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't believe weaving a purge or two in there will impact the number of autoattack swings you get between ss. Even if it does, sometimes a purge is worth that (purging fort at max rank can remove, what, 540 health from an enemy in one click).

I imagine this is a tougher calculation for elementals.
#26 May 14 2008 at 9:43 PM Rating: Good
*
194 posts
720 health untalented.

Enh shammies that purge spam are the only thing that my disc priest has to worry about in pvp.

All other melee classes I run around for 'til my 11k mana pool is gone.
« Previous 1 2
Reply To Thread

Colors Smileys Quote OriginalQuote Checked Help

 

Recent Visitors: 65 All times are in CST
Anonymous Guests (65)