Quote:
and with earth shield you could main heal some of the harder instances,
There was no 5-man you couldn't mainheal pre-BC as resto. I mainhealed every 5-man as Enhancement pre-BC, pre-talentChange. All you needed was knowledge of which heals were efficient and which weren't.
Quote:
@70
PVE
So now everyone starts playing with builds and talents mim-maxxing for DPS or PVP or heals and it becomes clear we are only good(for the most part) if we can help others as our spells and talents left us behind or even as dps(but we had no CC) and heals. There are areas were we excel but for the most part everyone else>shaman after 60.
My elemental shaman is hardly ever out-DPSed in all of the content I do (Heroics, Kara, ZA, Gruul, Hyjal),
except by Destruction Warlocks (and occasionally by Rogues in fights where ranged DPS has to move a lot). An occasional Fury Warrior sneaks up there too, but basically my shaman is awesome DPS while providing significant buffs to his party. Even through ridiculously AOE-tilted Hyjal trash only one of the three mages out-DPSed me (which perhaps indicates a serious failing on the part of some of our mages)
Dunno how people can consider that merely "good".
That said, I certainly want to explore the potential of my other two 70s in raid content to see if I could serve the group better in either of those roles. The mage hasn't excited me a ton through the limited Kara groups I've ran on her, but the rogue has always seemed to be solid DPS (through solo PVE I recall being level 62 and achieving higher DPS than most PUG Normal 70 instance DPSers got.) Given that we have a regular enh shaman in our raids, I wouldn't mind switching over to the rogue (melee DPS has a lot of things to worry about, which seems to make it a fun playstyle in raiding; particularly with all the kickass tools rogues get).
But basically I'd dispute the idea that shamans aren't solid for PVE. I think two of our specs (Ele/Resto) are great for 5-mans, and all three are great for 10+ man raiding.