Forum Settings
       
Reply To Thread

Is **** too EZ to get now?Follow

#1 Feb 21 2008 at 10:10 AM Rating: Excellent
*
112 posts
This is a slight spinoff from the "Welfare Epics" discussion. Mongoose has brought up some points that got me wondering about some stuff that doesn't relate to nubsauces.

Mongoose in the "Why are they called Welfare Epics" thread wrote:
pre-expac pvp gear was only better then raid gear if you earned the R14 badge along with it

...but if you did that, you prob didnt have time to raid

but what did they do? they made the HWL loot honor grind


So a general point (which perhaps is better suited to the general board BUT, I'm a rogue so I'm bringing this up with rogues...well and RPZip and Quor who love to OP and Execute their way through here):

Is good stuff simply too EZmode? Let's think about the old PvP system. I was barely playing long enough to play WSG for a week or two and get to R1 (Private) so I have little knowledge of the mechanics, but I believe it was essentially an intrafaction battle to see who had the most honor/week and from what I understand that grind was suicide at best and just impossible at worst.

If you could do it, then you got GM/HWL gear that was equal to some raid quality stuff. Otherwise, you didn't.

I could be wrong but it sounds like more work than simply attaining 1850 (?) for weapons and 2000 (?) for shoulders in the arena system. Was that system better or worse? Was it worth removing completely? I myself was looking forward to reaching Knight but o well...

Now what about Legendaries (ZOMG ORANGE!!!!)?

If I remember correctly, there were three legendaries pre-TBC: Ateish, Sulfuras and Thunderfury. I also recall hearing that these weapons were more than just simple drops from a raid, but that they required work even AFTER a raid drop was attained (probably more raiding but i dont really know). Now Illidan just nicely places his Warglaives down to be looted after battle. I guess from a logic standpoint it makes sense; I believe the other weapons had to be "remade" so it requires some production and some crafting whereas Illidan is obviously still using his blades so there doesn't seem to be much else that could be done for them.


Perhaps it doesn't bother anyone at all and I'm still fresh off the welfare discussion, but it seems to me that not only have epics become a little easier to get for non-serious/skilled players, but that everyone is getting the road to phat lewts paved just a little smoother.


Now am I to understand that they are going to make a way to "donate" your way to a new title for the new faction? I'm sure it will require 1) Exalted and 2) more than that. And then a "donation" of gold? I guess I will see what it requires before I make any judgments but I'm suspect of it.

Of course I think that Shadowgryph of the Shattered Sun has a ring to it.

Anyway there's more I suppose...attunements for one, honored for heroics instead of revered. Maybe I haven't experienced enough to see that this is probably better but it seems like maybe its not.

I don't know maybe I should go back to my hunter and experience leveling again...maybe this BG grind is killing me.

Edited, Feb 21st 2008 1:15pm by shadowgryph

Edited, Feb 21st 2008 1:16pm by shadowgryph
#2 Feb 21 2008 at 10:14 AM Rating: Excellent
While things are easier to get an epics certainly don't have the same meaning anymore...

I don't see that as a bad thing.

I don't understand the jealous mindset of 'Oh noes! Anybody can get my gear now!'.

Now I'm both a raider, and despite my class choice, I try to be a serious pvper as well.

In pvp, if anything, it has helped level to playing field.

In pve, it means you can't get into the interesting content faster and skip the 'gearing up' process.

The 'it creates' bad player argument is funny... don't recruit them in your guild/arena team. And if you're fighting them, just take the free points.

Edited, Feb 21st 2008 1:15pm by Tyrandor
#3 Feb 21 2008 at 10:30 AM Rating: Good
**
340 posts
I fully understand how an older toon, who busted their @ss through 5 mans and heroics to get through the Tiers, would be upset that newer toons can earn the same gear with lesser effort.

Accomplishments in this game are generally represented through gear. You bust your @ss, and it is very rewarding to hear "Holy **** sweet dual warglaives!" It would be very upsetting if all of a sudden warglaives became an honor reward.
#4 Feb 21 2008 at 10:54 AM Rating: Decent
Warchief Tyrandor wrote:
While things are easier to get an epics certainly don't have the same meaning anymore...

I don't see that as a bad thing.

I don't understand the jealous mindset of 'Oh noes! Anybody can get my gear now!'.

Now I'm both a raider, and despite my class choice, I try to be a serious pvper as well.


Yes, well... you're a bad raider. I want you to turn in your membership card by the end of the day. EDIT: And really, it's been said before but "QQ, I'm a Rogue and everybody is means to me in PvP" has moved beyond 'trite' to 'boring' months ago.

More specifically, there used to be a real sense of loot progression. ZG and AQ20 had some gear that was better (or equal to) MC quality, but that was really as far as you got. You'd do level 60 instances to gear for UBRS to gear for MC (or 20-mans, once they came out) to gear for BWL to gear for AQ40 to gear for Naxxramas. There wasn't really a way to... I guess 'short-circuit' that progression. For better or for worse, people were still running Molten Core as a serious raid up until 1.12 came out.

1.12 (and most of TBC) changed everything. Whereas before you ran PvE content (and, by and large, didn't skip PvE content) to gear up for more PvE, now you can run PvP to short-circuit the PvE progression and skip up several levels. There's definitely some advantages to that... new players gear up considerably faster, as do alts, and people can progress more easily though some of the, uh, less well designed PvE instances. The march of the Badge gear serves much the same purpose as the easily-obtained PvP gear - giving people a significant 'leg up' for gearing and making the PvE progression chart more or less obsolete.

There's some disadvantages too, though. Seeing gear you worked extremely hard to acquire turn into something you can pick up for 30 badges and five gold can be frustrating. So, too, does feeling the compulsion to do both PvE and PvP even if it's not your forté; it's one thing to do both and mix and match to gear up faster, it's quite another to feel that even at the very end of PvE progression your gear is inferior unless you PvP (*cough* weapons *cough*).

I don't personally think the 'gear = obsolete/easy' question is as valid as needing high-end PvP gear to do high-end PvE, any more than if you needed high-end PvE gear to do high-end PvP. It's about as imbalanced as if they made the reward for killing Illidan a free belt enchant that gave you 100 resilience and a 25% chance to resist fears; it's a significant upgrade that requires you to invest in a different sphere of gameplay and to succeed in it to get back to what really interests you. That's something that's better solved by tweaking the weapons (103 DPS -> 100 DPS for S3, for example) than it is by just destroying the two systems, though.

Anyway... when Blizzard makes changes to help push progression along, the high-end raiders aren't really hurt that much. The people who are most 'hurt' (pissed off, more like) by the improvements to, say, PvE badge gear are people who are behind in progression but advancing. For a guild that's spent the time, effort and energy to complete the BT/Hyjal attunements just before the patch hits, their achievements are made somewhat worthless. They're the ones who will suffer most from equivalent gear being available from badges or PvP, and they're the ones who will be lashing out the most.

As for me, I'm just happy we don't have to bother attuning recruits anymore.
#5 Feb 21 2008 at 11:06 AM Rating: Excellent
Quote:
Yes, well... you're a bad raider. I want you to turn in your membership card by the end of the day.


I'm assuming I'm bad because I'm still stuck in SSC and can't my guild to kill Vasjh? ;p

Quote:
So, too, does feeling the compulsion to do both PvE and PvP even if it's not your forté; it's one thing to do both and mix and match to gear up faster, it's quite another to feel that even at the very end of PvE progression your gear is inferior unless you PvP (*cough* weapons *cough*).


That's more or less the only real problem with the situation IMO.

The fact that when the Talon of Aszhara drops for us(hasn't yet), it'll most likely get sharded because everybody has S2-S3 weapons by now, is kinda sad.

It works both way as well - several top arena player mix and match pve gear with their pvp and there's something to be said about what the Warglaives can do for a rogue in 3v3. Heck, if a rogue wants the best weapon for pvp, he has to go kill Illidan.

Blizzard thought, want people to do both pve and pvp. I'd rather wish they were even more seperated then they are now.

The way pve drops are handled as always been frustrating... but it's only more so now that there's the pvp system right alongside it.
#6 Feb 21 2008 at 11:15 AM Rating: Good
Warchief Tyrandor wrote:
Quote:
Yes, well... you're a bad raider. I want you to turn in your membership card by the end of the day.


I'm assuming I'm bad because I'm still stuck in SSC and can't my guild to kill Vasjh? ;p


No! No... no, no... no... well, yes. What I was getting at more was that you're at the 'key point' in progression where your best option is to mix and match T5 and S3 options to gear up more quickly. You have the biggest benefit from this. It qualifies you to speak as someone on the dole, not someone who's moved off welfare. =p
#7 Feb 21 2008 at 12:58 PM Rating: Excellent
Mmm.

Unless my spreadsheet are lying to me, aside from the my S3 weapons... no S3 (Arena or Honor) are better for me then my T4/T5 (and equivalent) gear I'm using at the moment.

Granted, several people (especially healers) are using some S3 piece to PVE with, but it's a minority really. Still, overall the power of S3 gear in pve is greatly exagerated.

#8 Feb 21 2008 at 1:10 PM Rating: Decent
*****
13,048 posts
Gryph, until you're sitting there in full epics at the edge of progression, you really can't talk about stuff being "easy".
#9 Feb 21 2008 at 1:19 PM Rating: Good
Warchief Tyrandor wrote:
Mmm.

Unless my spreadsheet are lying to me, aside from the my S3 weapons... no S3 (Arena or Honor) are better for me then my T4/T5 (and equivalent) gear I'm using at the moment.

Granted, several people (especially healers) are using some S3 piece to PVE with, but it's a minority really. Still, overall the power of S3 gear in pve is greatly exagerated.



Depends on the class. S3 BPs are often (not always) quite good, and are typically an upgrade to Tier 4... which not everyone even gets, because they can depend on S3 so they just skip Mag all together.
#10 Feb 21 2008 at 1:26 PM Rating: Good
*
112 posts
Theophany the Sly wrote:
Gryph, until you're sitting there in full epics at the edge of progression, you really can't talk about stuff being "easy".


No not easy for me particularly, I'm simply comparing what people at that level of epic-ness have stated that they have to do to get stuff now compared to what they had to do to get stuff pre-TBC.

You know good and well I ain't talking about me. You hear me complaining about having to BGs to get weapons dont cha? LOL. Hell I'm the guy whose to lazy to use the welfare that he's given. I just want blizzard to ask me for a monthly list of stuff that I want...and then bulk mail it to me!

Exalted with all factions...CHECK
Full S4 ahead of schedule...CHECK
Full T10 from soloing Sargeras naked with a fishing pole....ROTF! DEFINITELY CHECK


Do you disagree with the logic behind the question? Or simply the status of the questioner? Sounds like the latter...


That's why I asked the community and didn't get on here saying..."ZOMG!!!111!!1 WoW is EZMODE come get ur frEE PURPLZ and ORANGZ from teh ICE CREAM MAN!!!!!"


or something like that

Edited, Feb 21st 2008 4:29pm by shadowgryph

Edited, Feb 21st 2008 4:41pm by shadowgryph

Edited, Feb 21st 2008 4:41pm by shadowgryph
#11 Feb 22 2008 at 8:42 AM Rating: Good
**
340 posts
shadowgryph wrote:


I just want blizzard to ask me for a monthly list of stuff that I want...and then bulk mail it to me!



QFT
#12 Feb 22 2008 at 1:08 PM Rating: Default
*****
13,048 posts
shadowgryph wrote:
That's why I asked the community and didn't get on here saying..."ZOMG!!!111!!1 WoW is EZMODE come get ur frEE PURPLZ and ORANGZ from teh ICE CREAM MAN!!!!!"

All the stuff that's worthwhile now isn't free.

Sure you can get 4/5 S3 and have S2 weapons, but that's not that good.

If it were still like S2 where there's no rating limit on weapons and shoulders, I'd say yeah, stuff is handed out too easily. Because most of the people last season that got S2 weapons didn't deserve them, because they could just save up a few points and boom, they had weapons.
#13 Feb 24 2008 at 12:14 AM Rating: Decent
***
2,602 posts
Blizz doesnt like that only a small percent of the wow community has accessed the stuff they put a huge amount of work into.

The best #1 stuff is still the hard to get. But easier than it was in vanila wow.
Reply To Thread

Colors Smileys Quote OriginalQuote Checked Help

 

Recent Visitors: 216 All times are in CST
Anonymous Guests (216)