Forum Settings
       
Reply To Thread

Professions for Protection WarriorFollow

#1 Feb 17 2008 at 3:49 PM Rating: Decent
**
261 posts
Didn't see much in the stickies about professions...

Do most of you do BS with a random other? I was thinking possibly JC, also. Of course, I would be supplying money from a main.

My question is... what specialization is best for a protection warrior in the BS tree?

Thanks
#2 Feb 17 2008 at 4:45 PM Rating: Decent
**
384 posts
TBH blacksmithing sucks for protection. The only thing i have made and used is the red havoc boots and only because i have yet to get the boots from ZA. Go engineering for the helm, or alchemy to make your own flasks and stuff.
#3 Feb 17 2008 at 7:39 PM Rating: Decent
****
4,297 posts
i was mining/herbing and it worked well. could farm everything i needed for crafted gear and raid pots... plus all the herbs left over usually converted nicely into stacks of mana pots i used to hand out.

plus dire maul east is reasonably profitable for an undergeared miner/herbaler protection warrior on a pvp server.
#4 Feb 17 2008 at 10:24 PM Rating: Decent
**
501 posts
Yeah, I honestly would not go BSing for prot. I have BSing for the weapons and engineering for the goggles. For a prot warrior, engineering is a much better choice for gear.

Edit: Most definitely profitable Axhed. I remember my old roommate and I used to do runs of DM East for cash. He was enchanting/herbing pally and I was a miner. He and I would drop the bosses, he would DE the mats, herb, and I would mine the thorium in the zone. Made money fast. Then daily quests came along and we didn't need to do that anymore. Yay daily quests!

Edited, Feb 18th 2008 1:29am by FletusSanguine
#5 Feb 18 2008 at 5:52 AM Rating: Good
*
199 posts
I started out with blacksmithing but when I reached level 70 and went the way of the tank I realized that it was more of a waste of time for me than it was worth. I ended up dropping it and picking up jewel crafting which has payed off way more than BS would have.

Prospecting and cutting my own gems has saved me a ton of money when I upgrade gear. I can also make some decent cash if I sell some of the more desired cut gems, although making money is not why I leveled it.

The couple of BoP Unique-Equipped cuts that are available are nice too to help up your stamina and defense that much more.
#6 Feb 18 2008 at 10:30 AM Rating: Decent
**
261 posts
What in engineering is so great besides the googles that isn't BoE?

I was looking at a gear guide in one of the stickies on this forum and much more of the equipment that was craftable was from BSing, where maybe the googles and gun was all I could see from engineering. Maybe the googles are just that much better, idk.
#7 Feb 18 2008 at 10:42 AM Rating: Decent
**
842 posts
The tanking goggles are T5 equivalent. With them, GBKD and the 45 stam eng trinket, I can gain about 1k health over my current setup. That's pretty much a big deal.
#8 Feb 18 2008 at 11:17 AM Rating: Decent
**
286 posts
Pick a profession that can make you money IMO. Crafted epics are nice but if you have a nice flow of money coming in, it opens up many more possibilities in the game than 1 or 2 pieces of gear that will someday get replaced.
#9 Feb 18 2008 at 12:14 PM Rating: Decent
**
842 posts
duvar wrote:
Pick a profession that can make you money IMO. Crafted epics are nice but if you have a nice flow of money coming in, it opens up many more possibilities in the game than 1 or 2 pieces of gear that will someday get replaced.


unless you go with a high consumable profession like alchemy and gather all your own mats, i'm not sure that making money from a profession > making money from farming primals/rep items/cloth/etc. then again, i've never leveled alchemy so i wouldn't know. what i DO know is that once i've leveled engineering to 375, i can make 100g or so per GBKD on the nether fee, and the same with any other epic BoE from BS that needs a nether to create... at least, until nethers become non-BoP in 2.4 /cheer /slashwrist
#10 Feb 18 2008 at 12:19 PM Rating: Decent
**
632 posts
blacksmithing isn't that bad. The ________ of kings items are very nice for tanking if you have enough defense from other gear and you're just gunning for max stam. Sure, everything will get outdated once you reach late ssc/tk and above... but in which profession is that NOT true?

If you have a main and don't have to worry about money do enchanting and bs'ing so you can put +4 stats on your rings for an even higher stat gain. BS'ing will always be nice to have at the start of new content (when people were just hitting 60, smithing was amazing... when TBC came out, bs'ing was amazing. When WotLK comes out, i'm sure that smithing [and lw'ing/tailoring/etc] will again have a jump on those characters that do not have either.
#11 Feb 18 2008 at 12:30 PM Rating: Decent
**
286 posts
Gathering your own mats doesn't count as making more money than if you had bought the mats. Because you could also sell them on the AH for exactly the amount you paid to buy them. So your net profit isn't any higher if you gather your own mats.
#12 Feb 18 2008 at 12:38 PM Rating: Decent
**
501 posts
The only BoP drop from BSing that's worthwhile are Red Havoc Boots. BSing is not worth it for tanking. Everything else is BoE, and you'll spend far less money gathering the mats and having someone else make them for you than you would leveling the profession and buying the pattern. Is it worth spending 2-3k gold leveling BSing, and then 1k on the pattern just for one pair of boots? No, not at all.
#13 Feb 18 2008 at 12:41 PM Rating: Good
**
842 posts
+1

also take into account your playing style. a couple months ago, i was able to raid maybe once a week. now, due to RL scheduling changes, i'm lucky if i can raid once a month, and most of the time now that's a gruul farm that i can't get T4 from anyway because other guildies have been farming him for much longer without any luck. i've managed to get 3 tanking pieces from kara and 4 dps pieces from kara/gruul, but that was all in the first few months of raiding. nothing has dropped for me since, and my overlord's helmet of second sight and felsteel helm/nethershrike are getting really old for dpsing and tanking.

solution: drop mining for engineering, and craft the dps and tanking goggles, GBKD, and goblin rocket launcher. the tanking goggles have more stam than the T5 helm, have a bit less dodge and have 13 +hit. the dps goggles have more strength than the T5 dps helm, a bit less hit and have a bit more crit. despite not having a single T4 or T5 piece, i'm still very raid viable for tanking or dpsing thanks to crafted gear and badge gear.
#14 Feb 27 2008 at 1:43 AM Rating: Decent
Actually, BS is fine...you can craft great weapon Fireguard with low costs. All the materials are fairy easy obtainable. BTW you can upgrade it and get weapon which is simply very good til Mallet of The Tides.
#15 Mar 13 2008 at 4:54 AM Rating: Decent
*
91 posts
Quote:
What in engineering is so great besides the googles that isn't BoE?


the trinkets with 51 stam are awesome tanking trinkets if you ask me.

Edited, Mar 13th 2008 2:55pm by gnetter
#16 Mar 13 2008 at 8:36 AM Rating: Decent
**
387 posts

fromanthebarbarian wrote:

The tanking goggles are T5 equivalent. With them, GBKD and the 45 stam eng trinket, I can gain about 1k health over my current setup. That's pretty much a big deal.


That and the Rocket Launcher for some serious initial pulling threat (from 40+ yards!) when needed. Sometimes a nice little AoE bomb to shuffle things up does wonders... No seriously, engineering IS cool these days /cheer.
Reply To Thread

Colors Smileys Quote OriginalQuote Checked Help

 

Recent Visitors: 44 All times are in CST
Anonymous Guests (44)