I know from reading the FAQ and just from general WoW experience that the thing to do when leveling a paladin in a time efficient manner is to go ret until the mid-60s or ret to 35 and then AoE prot grinding.
Sure enough, with my Blood Elf Paladin I poured my points into ret until level 30 I switched to prot (I know, a little early) when I could get Blessing of Sanctuary. With BoS, ret aura, and a shield spike (later a few points into reckoning) I was doing real well tanking instances, and when I did solo I had a fun time experimenting with AoE grinding. The constant blocking I think is really cool.
However, as cool as it is, I really have found that I prefer to heal over tanking instances. As a prot paladin, I kept a set of +int and some +healing cloth for a nice healing set to allow me to be the main healer if necessary. More often than not, I seemed to find myself in more situations when I needed to heal rather than tank. Even though I was prot, I managed to heal exceptionally well spamming FoL and fights would seemingly have to drag for 15 minutes (more and more additional mobs joining in) for me to run out of mana.
Since I enjoyed the healing role I caved in and switched to a holy spec. Why fight what you enjoy doing? I knew that by switching to a holy spec soloing was going to be much more of a *****, but since I enjoy instances so much I figure I would try to spend 90% of my leveling just instance grinding. It's definately slower than soloing/questing due to a fair amount of bad PUGs but the good groups make it all worth it for me. I now enjoy the Holy Light crits along with Divine Favor, Illumination, and the extra mana from Divine Intellect. I love healing even more now that I have greater potency even if the extra potency wasn't necessarily required. It's fun to excel at what I do.
I guess the question is a curious one, did any of you have a similar experience? Did any of you switch to holy real early and decide to level with the same strategy? I understand if most responses are "no."
What I do see in a response to this is, "why not play a priest?" I certainly tried it, but I just ended up missing my paladin. Even though I'm healing with mostly cloth right now, I know it will be replaced eventually by Outland healing plate, and when I do go out to fight monsters on my own it's nice to throw on the mail (I'm level 34), take hits, and be able to be a knight.
More of a spilling of thoughts than a question. It's late for me so that's my excuse.
Edited, Feb 10th 2008 1:00am by Dansmith