Holy Trinket questionFollow

I used Xi'ri's gift for a long time, and also had the Prayer Book before I got more suitable trinkets.

But if I were in your position, I would take Xi'ri's Gift for the crit, and the Scarab.

Link your armory, or at least tell me what server/char name you have so I can give you a good recommendation. I have a ton of trinkets in my bank, between drops, JC trinkets, rep stuff, badge stuff.... I honestly feel like the last boss in sethekk halls sometimes "RAWK TRINKETS.... PRETTY TRINKETS!" Only one I'm missing from my collection is the one off shade, which I don't even really want now that they 'fixed' it.

@Jack
The scarab is actually useful outside of PvP if you don't need any other stats. I spend 90% of my time spamming holy light now, so the occasional haste makes a difference. Its not as useful on a flash of light though, I think you only lop off about .2 seconds, and then you have to deal with GCDs. I honestly use it as my 'fallback trinket' when I need a trinket but don't need any particular stats or specific abilities. A lot of the paladins at my level use a combo of the scarab/martyr.

You're running kara primarily? Your gear is perfectly fine then, don't change a thing. Go ahead and get the martyr, and replace your LCP with it until you get some more crit from the rest of your gear, then ditch the gift and pick back up the LCP.