So I'm doing SV on my hunter with a fraternity brother (holy paladin with 400 healing, but I'm not going there), and we get in, and the prot tank has never tanked anything before. He's trying to hold aggro using judgment of wisdom, hardly any spell damage so his consecrates do nothing, critable, crushable, and he has under 9k health (including talents). I go and inspect him, look what talents he was told to get (by the +400 healing paladin) and he's rocking this:
http://www.wowhead.com/?talent=sZVhtIx0dggqtVb
He couldn't even hold aggro when I would misdirect the mob to him and give him a huge chunk of initial threat. It was all I could do to keep from running from my room screaming. We didn't even make it to the first boss.