Aethien wrote:
You'd need an isane amount of crits/focusregen for WS to get better then ravagers.
namely so much that a ravager cant use all its focus.
And in 30 seconds it uses 3 x bite and 17 x gore so 530 focus, or 17.66 focus per second.
A WS uses 20 LB's in 30 seconds so 1000 Focus or 33.33 focus per second.
now someone else can calculate how much crits you'd need for that, what crit% that would be and wether the WS would actually deal more dmg then.
A WS also has Bite, and you SHOULD have it active. LB is 2.12 DPF, Bite is 2.4. Now, of course you only need 112 AP for them to be on the same level.
So, you have a base focus regen of 25 every 4 sec. With Bestial Discipline, that's 50 Focus every 4 sec, or 12.5 FPS. Assuming you've got a 2.8 speed weapon, a +15 haste quiver and Serpent's Swiftness, you'll have an effective attack speed of 2.03. Seeing as this is enough to fit in a Steady Shot in between every auto shot, we're going to assume that. So, that's two attacks every 2.03 sec.
You need 5.16 more FPS (or slightly more than that... like 5.2) for Ravagers to not being able to dump all their focus. So, with 50 focus every crit and an effective shot timer of around 1 sec (less if you factor in Multi-Shot and Arcane Shot), you only need a 9.6% crit rate to reach that.
----- Checking math! -----
In 30 seconds you're able to use 14 Auto Shots and 14 Steady Shots (as well as 3 Multi-Shots and 5 Arcane Shots). Counting Multi- and Arcane Shot as well we're landing at 36 shots every 30 sec (or 72 Shots/min). Now, if 9.6% of those are crits, you'll get approx 3 crits in 30 sec. So, your focus regen is 50 per 4 sec, meaning 375 focus in 30 sec. Add the extra 150 from critting: 17.5 FPS.
----- Stop checking math! -----
A Ravager which can go all out on its damage abilities will do 1609.5 damage without crit multiplyer. 1931.4 with, since I believe they have a 20% crit rate with Ferocity. So, 1931.4 damage, plus regular melee, over 30 sec... That's 64.38 DPS from abilities only.
A Windserpent which has a 17.5 FPS rate will get 525 Focus over 30 sec. That allows them to cast 10.5 LB's (I'm counting the half LB because it matters in fights that last > 1 min). Now, Ravager abilities do not scale with you AP... WS ones do though. We're going to assume a 1.5k AP pool, nothing too fancy, yet thinkable for a new kara raider. This makes the LB's hit for 293.5.
----- Realization! -----
I've never played a caster class seriously... but I looked up how +spell damage scales with abilities, and found out that instants only get ~43% coefficient... (This of course phucks up my math on the first paragraph... I can't really be ***** changing it atm. I'll get the rest right!)
----- Realization ends! -----
This makes 10.5 LB's of 106 base damage and 125.7941 spell damage bonus (231.8 total) hit for 2433.8381 damage over 30 sec. That's ~81 DPS from abilities only...
Which by the looks of it, makes WS's a better DPS-pet option. Of course, there are some pathing errors that make WS DPS go down a bit... When/If they're fixed though... WS seems like a solid raiding pet, unless anyone proves my math wrong.
----- Realization! -----
I didn't crit multiply LB... But I'm not sure whether to use regular pet crit or some sort of hidden spell crit.
----- Realization ends! -----
Erm... that's it. What do you other elitists think of this?