Forum Settings
       
Reply To Thread

Tanking mobs so DPS are behind them?Follow

#1 Jan 14 2008 at 11:18 AM Rating: Good
Here's a little question for Normal/Heroic/Kara+ trash pulls.

Do you bother to face the mob so that its back is to your melee?

Just wondering. That Parry/Dodge thread had me thinking why I'm not doing that for trash pulls. With less (Hunter/melee-non-Rogues) mob parry/block we'd prolly burn the mobs down quicker..... BUT is it enough to really go thru the positioning per 100000 trash pull?

I know in Gruul's we face the mobs away from the group. We're getting ready to run SSC and TK-Eye runs... Thinking about using that method.

Let me know if you do or not, or if you'll start or not.
#2 Jan 14 2008 at 12:07 PM Rating: Decent
**
422 posts
I always try to make the mobs face away from the group, just in case they have some sort of AoE attack, cleave, etc. However, I typically leave it up to the melee DPS to position themselves correctly. The tank has enough to do already. I'm not going to worry about it if they have to take a few steps to get into position. If they're stupid enough to stand in front of a mob I'm tanking, I'll tell them to attack from behind.

It's not so much that you'll burn them down much quicker, it's really only about 5% more DPS (nothing to sneeze at, but not necessarily noticeable), but rather I really don't feel like eating extra attacks from mobs because they're parrying attacks from the DPS. It's usually not a big deal on trash, but it can be an issue on bosses, large pulls, or mobs that attack fast/hit hard.
#3 Jan 14 2008 at 1:44 PM Rating: Good
***
3,801 posts
GYFFORD, Pie Eating Champion wrote:
Do you bother to face the mob so that its back is to your melee?

Let me know if you do or not, or if you'll start or not.


I always do. Just a habit, mainly. The main reason I do it is for cleaves, because I like to run with 1 healer and it's much harder for a single healer if multiple people are taking damage.
#4 Jan 14 2008 at 2:12 PM Rating: Decent
Ah, cool. I think I'll start trying to do that.

Mobs with cleave I most certianly face away (or in Romelo's case... face his back away- Back cleave).

I'll have to run it by our #1 tank, see what he thinks... it is only trash mobs... but on ZA timed runs it might help getting that extra 5% dps and healing mana from not having him parry and hit faster.

Looks good on paper anyway Smiley: lol
#5 Jan 14 2008 at 2:50 PM Rating: Decent
**
632 posts
it's not only a thing about you positionning your mob, but your dps having enough common sense to get behind them. Tell every melee-er that their dps will increase if they're behind the mob and they should automatically adjust themselves for the encounters if possible.
#6 Jan 14 2008 at 2:58 PM Rating: Decent
During trash (esp. in SSC/TK) you don't have the room to try and tank them facing away from the raid. With the CC and lack of room, its best for you to hold the aggro as best you can without having to try and move the mob. With that being said it's just easier for the melee to run around the back and dps. Now in SSC there are big Boglord guys that you will have to turn away from the raid, but other than that there are like 5 and 6 mob pulls and you just tank where you can (if you want to position them a certain way, I'm not telling you not too).

In TK there are always multi-mob trash pulls and some have a whirlwind and others have an Arcane Flurry which can be countered by Sheeping, so facing them from the raid doesn't really work since they do AoE dmg anyway.

Good luck in SSC/TK, I can't wait to hear your stories!
#7 Jan 14 2008 at 3:16 PM Rating: Decent
*
78 posts
Another good thing about tanking away from the group is that if you somehow lose aggro, it's easier to run to it.
#8 Jan 14 2008 at 9:46 PM Rating: Decent
***
2,717 posts
It's not necessarily easier to run TO it, but easier to see it. Off the top of my head, here's all the reasons to face a mob away from the group:

1. Meleers get more DPS. If they're hitting from behind, the mob can't parry, can still dodge (but hey, at that point any DPS warriors can OP), and can't block. DPS warriors may get some rage by getting hit by cleaves, but it's easier on your healers if they aren't, which brings me to...
2. Cleaves hitting DPS is bad if they can avoid it by standing behind. This is why only if mobs back-cleave you want the DPS in front.
3. Back to the point in 1 about parry...if the mob can't parry nearly as often, you'll take less DPS.
4. It's easier to see when mobs run away from you toward another party member if you're facing away.

I always face mobs away from the group (or have smart DPS who run behind them). Rogues and cats get more DPS from behind anyway by way of backstab and shred (or any higher level variants) so they will benefit from that anyway.
#9 Jan 15 2008 at 4:29 AM Rating: Excellent
****
8,779 posts
ive never really had that issue in heroics. when i run em i always tank them in a place where getting behind isnt an issue. we like to pull way back however, preferably behind a nice LoS'ed area just so theres no fear of accidental addness.

then again, we also routinely use fear as a CC, so i suppose we're not what youd call "normal".
#10 Jan 15 2008 at 9:07 AM Rating: Excellent
***
3,202 posts
If the mob has some ability that requires me to face it away from the group then I do that. If the mob has a knockback then I usually position myself with my back to a wall. If the mob has no other special requirements, I position myself where I can see the other CC mobs. Melee DPS is responsible for their own positioning though I do try to remain stationary if possible when working with melee DPS.
#11 Jan 15 2008 at 10:41 AM Rating: Decent
I DPS on nights when we don't need my tank, and I feel that it is my job as a dps to position myself behind the mob anytime possible. The tank has WAY more things to worry about than me as a lowly mele dps, so I try to make his/her job as easy as possible. And it is not by any stretch of the imagination hard to get behind a mob. I feel that a better help for the dps is to, when possible, remain relatively stationary. I play arms dps and when the tank moves for mo reason other than boredom or some inane obsession with pushing buttons, and it pulls him out of range of my slam, it can be a little frustrating(yes it has happened and the tank, when asked, said "Don't know, I was bored of standing there")

Edited, Jan 15th 2008 1:44pm by tibblet
#12 Jan 15 2008 at 5:56 PM Rating: Decent
It doesn't matter where you tank the mobs as long as you have some smart melee dps and understand that dps'ing behind the mob will reduce the chance of Parry and Dodge effects thus increasing overall dps.

You will have tanks that want to turn the mob and others that don't really care where the mob is tanked or what kind of position it's in. If the mob has an AoE attack, sure face the mob away from the group, if not..who cares right?
Reply To Thread

Colors Smileys Quote OriginalQuote Checked Help

 

Recent Visitors: 194 All times are in CST
Anonymous Guests (194)